The passing of property and risk in the sale of goods
Question
Delicious Wines Ltd is the creator of innovative alcoholic products, and imports a large amount of ingredients in order to manufacture these. However, June is a bad month for the Company, and a number of issues occur with some of their contracts.
Based on the rules regarding the passing of property and risk in sale of goods contracts, advise the Company on their rights or liability in the following circumstances:
- Delicious Wines Ltd agreed with Grapes Grapes Grapes (“GGG Ltd”) for 5,000 tonnes of grapes to be shipped to their factory in Liverpool. GGG Ltd had packaged up all of the grapes at their factory in Chile, into one big container which had Delicious Wines’ name and address written on it. However, prior to being loaded onto the carrier, GGG Ltd went into liquidation.
- Delicious Wines Ltd had ordered 750 tonnes of potatoes from Potatoes Potatoes Potatoes Ltd (“PPP Ltd”) which were being shipped as part of a bulk of 2000 tonnes, over to Liverpool from France on the MV Badluck, under an F.O.B contract. Unfortunately, halfway across the English Channel, the vessel strikes an unexploded mine left in the sea following the Second World War, and sinks with all cargo being lost at sea.
- Delicious Wines Ltd also spoke with Mr Logins, the managing director of Bottles Are US Ltd (“BAU Ltd”). He stated he had 600 bottles available to sell them, but they were all different sizes. Delicious Wines Ltd stated they would take all of the bottles, and a contract was agreed to this effect. However, Mr Logins confirmed that in order to agree a price he would need to count up all the bottles and measure their sizes. Delicious Wines Ltd agreed this was ok. Mr Logins was given a week in which to ascertain the price of the bottles, but during this time, a freak earthquake struck the town in which his factory was based and all of the bottles were destroyed.
Answer
Introduction
Delicious Wines has dealt with three suppliers and wishes to understand its liabilities. The grapes and potatoes transactions involve suppliers in Chile and France respectively. The third transaction does not specify the location of the seller. It is necessary to distinguish the court with jurisdiction from the law applicable to the contract. Chile and France are parties to the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods 1980 (CISG). The UK is not[1]. Article 1(1)(a) applies where both parties have their relevant places of business in different contracting states[2]. Article 1(1)(b) can also apply where private international law leads to the law of a contracting state, unless the Convention is excluded or a relevant reservation applies[3].
Law Teacher writing support
Working on a law problem question?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us the scenario and any marking criteria. We’ll write an answer to your instructions, identifying the legal issues and applying the law to the facts.
The scenario does not identify a choice-of-law or jurisdiction clause. In an English court, under Rome I the parties’ choice generally governs contractual obligations. Without a choice, a sale of goods is ordinarily governed by the law of the seller’s habitual residence, subject to exceptions including a manifestly closer connection elsewhere[34]. On the stated facts the ordinary rule points to Chilean and French law respectively, so the CISG may govern the international contracts. If Chilean law applies, its declaration under Articles 12 and 96 also makes the applicable rules on form relevant. The analysis below considers the CISG where applicable and explains the position if English sale of goods law governs. The proprietary effect of a transfer against third parties is a separate issue, generally governed by the law of the place where the goods were situated at the time of the alleged transfer. For the grapes this points to Chile. The effect of the liquidation must also be checked under the applicable insolvency law[35].
GGG Ltd
There are three key provisions which determine when property will pass from the seller to the buyer, in sections 16–18 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 (SGA)[4]. Subject to section 20A, section 16 requires unascertained goods to be ascertained before property can pass. Goods can be identified and agreed at the time of contracting or ascertained afterwards[5]. Until property passes the buyer ordinarily has contractual rights rather than ownership of the goods[6]. Section 17 provides that even where the goods are specific or ascertained, title passes when the parties intend it to pass[7]. The court looks at the terms of the contract, the parties’ conduct and the circumstances[8]. Unless a different intention appears, section 18, rule 5(1) requires goods of the contractual description in a deliverable state to be unconditionally appropriated to the contract with the other party’s assent. Assent can be express or implied and given before or after appropriation. Under rule 5(2), delivery to a carrier for transmission to the buyer without reserving the right of disposal is deemed unconditional appropriation[9].
GGG put 5,000 tonnes of grapes into a single container and marked it with Delicious Wines’ name and address. That identifies the grapes intended for the contract[10]. However, identifying the grapes is not necessarily unconditional appropriation. In Carlos Federspiel v Charles Twigg, packing and labelling goods was insufficient where shipment was still to take place and the goods had not been irrevocably committed to the contract[11]. Here the container remained at GGG’s factory. Without evidence that the parties intended title to pass before shipment or that there was already unconditional appropriation with the buyer’s assent, title is unlikely to have passed under English law. Payment alone does not determine title, although a seller may reserve the right of disposal until conditions such as payment are met[12]. These terms are often referred to as retention of title or Romalpa clauses[13].
If Delicious Wines establishes that it owns the grapes under the applicable property law, they would ordinarily be excluded from the assets available to GGG’s general creditors, subject to the applicable insolvency rules and any unpaid seller’s rights. If ownership remained with GGG and the buyer prepaid, it would ordinarily have to prove in the liquidation for any unsecured contractual claim. If unpaid, the company’s claim for the price depends on the contract and the applicable law. The CISG does not determine ownership of the grapes or priority in the liquidation. Under Article 67 the risk ordinarily remains with the seller before handover to the relevant carrier, even if the container has been clearly identified. This does not decide who owns the grapes[14].
PPP Ltd
The second contract between Delicious Wines and PPP Ltd concerns the sale of 750 tonnes of potatoes that were lost at sea. The potatoes for Delicious Wines had not been separated from the larger quantity on the shipment. Section 16 SGA ordinarily prevents title to unascertained goods from passing before ascertainment[15]. Historically, an agreement to sell part of a bulk did not by itself transfer title to any particular goods in it[16]. A proprietary interest could arise in a segregated bulk on particular facts, as in Re Stapylton Fletcher[17].
The Sale of Goods (Amendment) Act 1995 introduced a specific provision into the SGA for goods forming part of a bulk. Under section 20A, unless otherwise agreed, a buyer who has paid for some or all of a specified quantity becomes an owner in common of the bulk if it is identified in the contract or by subsequent agreement. If the shipment of 2,000 tonnes aboard the MV Badluck was the agreed bulk and Delicious Wines paid for all 750 tonnes, its share would ordinarily be 37.5%. If it paid for only part, its share would reflect the quantity paid for. If it paid nothing, shipment alone would not confer a share under section 20A. There is no indication that the bulk was reduced to the quantity due to Delicious Wines before the loss[18].
Risk can pass to the buyer even where ownership has not passed. Section 20(1) SGA makes risk follow property unless the parties agree otherwise[19]. The contract is stated to be FOB, or free on board. The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) publishes Incoterms to provide standard rules for interpreting such terms[20]. Under FOB Incoterms 2020, if incorporated, the seller normally delivers and risk passes once the goods are on board the vessel at the named port of shipment. The rule does not determine when ownership passes[21].
The use of FOB does not automatically incorporate a particular version of Incoterms. The contract, applicable trade usage and course of dealing must be considered[22]. Incoterms 2020 is the current ICC edition, but earlier editions can still apply by agreement[23]. An ordinary English-law FOB contract likewise generally puts transit risk on the buyer once the goods are properly shipped, subject to the terms of the particular contract. If the 750 tonnes were identified to the contract as a quantity out of the named shipment and PPP duly performed its shipping obligations, the loss is likely to be at Delicious Wines’ risk. That does not establish that title passed or that a particular payment is due. The payment terms and section 49 SGA must be considered, including whether the price was payable on a day certain irrespective of delivery. If PPP was required to send the goods by sea and insurance was usual, section 32(3) also requires consideration of whether it gave the buyer notice to enable it to insure, unless otherwise agreed[36].
Delicious Wines should check whether its insurance covers loss from the mine. A claim against the carrier depends on the carriage contract, rights under the shipping documents and any applicable carriage rules or defences. The sinking alone does not establish negligence[37]. Under the CISG, the agreed FOB risk allocation can displace the default rule. Otherwise, Articles 66 and 67 generally leave the buyer liable for the price after risk passes on handover to the relevant carrier, provided the goods were clearly identified to the contract and the loss was not due to the seller’s act or omission. Shipping documents identifying the 750 tonnes as part of the named cargo could satisfy that requirement. The facts do not say what the documents recorded[24].
BAU Ltd
The contract between Delicious Wines and BAU is a little more problematic. The key issue to resolve is whether the negotiations between Delicious Wines and Mr Logins are sufficiently complete to amount to a contract. It is noted, that Mr Logins offered the stock of about 600 bottles of varying sizes and Delicious Wines agreed to take all of it. Basic principles of contract law determine that there must be an offer and an acceptance of that offer in order to make a valid contract, in addition to consideration and an intention to be legally bound.[25] The court looks objectively at what the parties agreed and whether they intended to be bound before the price was calculated.[26]
The parties agreed on all the bottles in the identified stock. Counting them would establish the precise number without requiring a further agreement on quantity. The promises to supply the bottles and pay for them can constitute consideration[27]. A price need not be fixed in advance. Under section 8 SGA it can be fixed by agreed machinery or a course of dealing, and an otherwise binding sale can carry a reasonable price. If the parties intended to be bound only once they had agreed a price, there would be no binding contract before that agreement. The description of a contract and a week for Mr Logins to ascertain the price supports a binding agreement if the count and measurement were intended to calculate the price rather than reopen negotiations[28].
If there was a binding agreement to sell, the identified bottles were specific goods[29]. Under section 18, rule 3, where the seller must count or measure specific goods in a deliverable state to ascertain the price, property does not pass until that step has been completed and the buyer has notice, unless a different intention appears. Neither completion nor notice is shown here[32]. Under section 20, risk therefore remained with BAU unless the parties agreed otherwise. The bottles perished without either party’s fault before risk passed. Section 7 avoids the agreement in those circumstances, so Delicious Wines does not have to pay for the bottles[30]. The general law of frustration discharges obligations where the event makes performance radically different from what was agreed. The Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 expressly excludes this kind of contract for specific goods that perish[31]. If no contract was formed, there is no contractual obligation to pay. If the CISG applied and no carriage was contemplated, Article 69 would ordinarily govern risk. The facts do not show that Delicious Wines took over the bottles or was in breach by failing to take delivery[33].
Conclusion
Contractual provisions can vary quite significantly under differing laws and jurisdictions. For the grapes, the right to claim the goods in liquidation depends on title under the applicable property law. For the potatoes, the FOB risk allocation and the question of ownership must be considered separately. For the bottles, Delicious Wines is unlikely to have to pay whether the price was a condition of contract formation or the agreement was avoided after the goods perished.
Understanding the point at which the contract is made and the point at which the risk passes between the buyer and seller is important. In future transactions, Delicious Wines can specify the governing law and forum, the applicable Incoterms edition and named place, and the terms for payment, passage of title and insurance.
Footnotes
[1] P Viscasillas, ‘Applicable Law, the CISG, and the Future Convention on International Commercial Contracts’ [2013] 58 Villanova Law Review 733, 734.
[3] CISG, arts 1(1)(b), 6 and 95. For Chile’s declaration on form, see arts 12 and 96 and the UNCITRAL status table.
[4] Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 16–18.
[5] N R Campbell, ‘Passing of property in contracts for the sale of unascertained goods’ (1996) Journal of Business Law 199, pp 200-201.
[6] W Hibbert, Sale of Goods: Overview [2014] Westlaw Insight, Available at: Click here to read the full article Accessed [25 September 2015] [11].
[7] Sale of Goods Act 1979, Section 17.
[8] Campbell, n5 [11].
[9] Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 18, rule 5(1)–(2).
[10] Re Stapylton Fletcher Ltd; Re Ellis, Son & Vidler Ltd [1994] 1 WLR 1181.
[11] Carlos Federspiel & Co SA v Charles Twigg & Co Ltd [1957] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 240, 255. See also N McKay, ‘The Passing of Risk and s.20A Sale of Goods Act 1979’ (2010) 15(1) Coventry Law Journal 17, 19; Hanson and Another, v Meyer (1805) 6 East 614.
[12] Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 19. See also W Davies, Romalpa Thirty Years on – Still an Enigma? (2006) 4(2) Hertfordshire Law Journal 2, 3.
[13] E McKendrick, Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (5th edn, Oxford University Press 2012) 395; Aluminium Industrie Vaasen BV v. Romalpa Aluminium Ltd [1976] 1 WLR 676.
[14] N G Oberman, ‘Transfer of risk from seller to buyer in international commercial contracts: A comparative analysis of risk allocation under the CISG, UCC and Incoterms’ (Master of Law Thesis, Maître en droit 1997) Available at: Click here to read the full article accessed 25 September 2015 39; CISG, arts 4(b) and 67.
[15] Davies I, ‘Continuing Dilemmas with Passing of Property in Part of a Bulk’ [1991] Journal of Business Law 111, 112.
[16] Capital and Counties Bank Ltd. v. Warriner-Bretherton Ford and Co (1896) 21 Comm. Cases 314; Leigh and Sillavan Ltd v Aliakmon Shipping Co Ltd (The Aliakmon) [1986] A.C. 785
[17] E Peel, Treitel: The Law of Contract (13th edn, Sweet and Maxwell 2012). [21:024]; Ellis Son & Vidler Ltd [1994] B.C.C. 532 (Ch D)
[18] Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 18 (rule 5(3)–(4)), 20A and 20B.
[19] Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 20(1); Sterns Ltd v Vickers Ltd [1923] 1 KB 78. See also J Ramberg, ICC Guide to Incoterms 2010 (ICC 2011) 17.
[20] I Carr, International Trade Law (4th edn Routledge Cavendish 2010) 6.
[21] ICC, Incoterms 2020, FOB rules A2–A3 and B3. See also Chikwava K, Sustaining Contractual Business: An Exploration of the New Revised International Commercial Terms (Xlibris 2012) 26.
[22] Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 55(1); Pyrene Co Ltd v Scindia Navigation Co Ltd [1954] 2 QB 402, 424. See also F Dasser, ‘Incoterms and Lex Mercatoria: Applicability of Incoterms in the Absence of Express Party Consent’ (Master of Laws Thesis, Harvard University 1990), Available at: Click here to read the full article accessed 25 September 2015, 71.
[23] H Gabriel, ‘The International Chamber of Commerce INCOTERMS 1990 – A Guide to their Usage’ (1999) 3 Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law and Arbitration 61, 61.
[24] CISG, arts 6, 9, 66 and 67. See also Oberman, n14, 39.
[25] R Stone, Modern Law of Contract (9th edn, Routledge 2011) 32.
[26] RTS Flexible Systems Ltd v Molkerei Alois Müller GmbH & Co KG [2010] UKSC 14, [45].
[27] Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256 (CA)
[28] Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 2 and 8; May & Butcher Ltd v The King [1934] 2 KB 17 (n); Foley v Classique Coaches Ltd [1934] 2 KB 1. See also Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v Selfridge & Co Ltd [1915] AC 847.
[29] Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 61(1). See also Peel, n17, [21:025]
[30] Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 7; Pioneer Shipping Ltd v BTP Tioxide Ltd (The Nema) [1982] AC 724, 752 (Lord Roskill).
[31] Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 2(5)(c). See also J Poole, Casebook on Contract Law (11th edn, Oxford University Press 2012) 513.
[32] Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 17–18 (rule 3) and 20.
[33] CISG, art 69. See also Oberman, n14, 39.
[34] Rome I Regulation, arts 2–4, 19 and 20.
[35] Winkworth v Christie, Manson & Woods Ltd [1980] Ch 496; Glencore International AG v Metro Trading International Inc [2001] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 284.
[36] Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 20, 28, 32 and 49; PST Energy 7 Shipping LLC v OW Bunker Malta Ltd (The Res Cogitans) [2016] UKSC 23, [44]–[58].
[37] Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1992, s 2; Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1971, Sch, arts III, IV and X, if applicable.
Last updated: 13 November 2026