Why was it introduced (political/sociological context)?
The changes to the law made by the Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008 were based on recommendations contained within a number of Government reports. These pointed towards the need for a faster and simpler criminal justice system and the overall importance of putting law-abiding people and communities first. In addition, there were a number of issues that were arising in the UK in the years prior to its enactment that influenced these reports and the final statute.
For example, the prison population had been rising at a rapid rate over the previous years and there was a growing concern about how prisons could sustain this growing population. This led the Government to seek new ways to reduce the overcrowding in UK prisons in a time of crisis. In addition, the Government was also looking for new ways to cut down on crime and make sure re-offending was reduced, as this was a problem that was contributing to overpopulated prisons. Tackling this problem was also part of their goal to better protect society.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
There was a need for a new criminal offence regarding extreme pornography and this was discussed in detail before the Act. In particular, the campaign for legal change was launched in 2004 by Jane Longhurst’s mother, after her daughter was murdered by Graham Coutts in 2003. This campaign and case were very public, gathering momentum in the public eye. It was believed that Graham Coutts had been influenced by violent pornography prior to Jane Longhurst’s murder. A significant number of websites were not based in the UK. This caused problems for the Government in enforcing existing laws against publication and distribution. Thus, there was a desire for more to be done by the law to ban this kind of abhorrent material and there was a growing campaign to make possession of this material a crime.
What was the aim of the Act (legal context)?
The aim of the Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008 was to build on previous changes to the law, as well as introduce reforms to the criminal justice system. The goal was to cut crime and protect the public, as well as make the criminal justice system more effective and simpler.
There had been rules and precedents set through case law that were to be clarified in statute, for example, self-defence law. This Act would aim to make changes to the criminal justice system in England and Wales, as well as some laws applying to Scotland and Northern Ireland.
What main changes did it make to the law?
The Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008 made a number of changes to the law, clarifying previous case law, as well as creating new offences.
To tackle overcrowding, section 26 of the Act contained the details concerning the early release of prisoners. This provided for automatic release on licence at the halfway point for qualifying prisoners whose offences were committed before 4th April 2005 and who were serving sentences of four years or more under the Criminal Justice Act 1991 release regime. It replaced discretionary release by the Parole Board for those prisoners, with the licence continuing until the end of the sentence. This did not apply to life sentences or sentences for the violent or sexual offences specified in Schedule 15 to the Criminal Justice Act 2003.
Section 63 of the Act produced the new offence of possession of extreme pornography. The offence came into force on 26 January 2009 in England and Wales and Northern Ireland. It required an image which must reasonably be assumed to have been produced solely or principally for sexual arousal which was grossly offensive, disgusting or otherwise obscene and explicitly and realistically depicted one of the specified acts. These were acts threatening life, causing or likely to cause serious injury to the anus, breasts or genitals, sexual interference with a human corpse, or intercourse or oral sex with an animal. A reasonable person looking at the image must think that the people or animals were real. This focused on making it a crime for consumers to have this material, rather than targeting the distributors, as this had been a problem presented in the past.
Other big changes to the law include section 1 creating new community orders, aimed at young offenders under the age of 18. These Youth Rehabilitation Orders could be imposed as non-custodial sentences where the offence was serious enough to warrant a community sentence, subject to the statutory conditions. They were not limited to offenders who could not be sent to prison. Orders with intensive supervision and surveillance or fostering were designed as alternatives to custody.
Part 10 of the Act provided for a special immigration status for designated foreign criminals who were liable to deportation but could not be removed because of section 6 of the Human Rights Act 1998. It also covered qualifying family members, but excluded anyone with a right of abode. Designation would not give leave to enter or remain and could involve conditions concerning residence, work and reporting. These provisions have never been brought into force; they did not create an operative immigration status or a new bar to deportation.
In addition, hate crime legislation under the Public Order Act 1986 was amended by section 74 of the Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008. From 23 March 2010, the offences in Part 3A extended to intentionally stirring up hatred against a group defined by sexual orientation. They require threatening words, behaviour or material and an intention to stir up hatred, rather than merely offensive views or discrimination. Section 29JA protects discussion or criticism of sexual conduct and practices, and, following a later amendment, discussion or criticism of marriage concerning the sex of the parties: these are not of themselves threatening or intended to stir up hatred.
Section 76 clarified the use of reasonable force in self-defence, defence of another person, prevention of crime and lawful arrest. The reasonableness of the force is assessed in the circumstances as the defendant genuinely believed them to be, including a mistaken belief, except where the mistake resulted from voluntary intoxication. The section recognises that a person acting legitimately may be unable to judge the exact amount of force needed.
Other important changes included restrictions on the availability of sentences of imprisonment or detention for public protection, the introduction of youth conditional cautions and violent offender orders, and powers to close premises associated with persistent disorder or nuisance. Section 79 abolished the common-law offences of blasphemy and blasphemous libel in England and Wales. The Act also reformed police misconduct procedures and required the relevant public-protection authorities to consider disclosure of child sex offenders’ convictions to members of the public.
2026 update
The Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008 remains partly in force. Youth Rehabilitation Orders are now governed by Part 9, Chapter 1 of the Sentencing Act 2020, which replaced the original provisions from 1 December 2020. Section 26 was omitted in December 2012 as prisoner-release provisions were reorganised under the Criminal Justice Act 2003. Sentences of imprisonment or detention for public protection can no longer be imposed following their abolition in 2012, but that abolition did not cancel existing sentences. The premises-closure provisions were replaced in 2014 by Part 4, Chapter 3 of the Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014.
Since the Act was passed, some of its provisions have been amended by later legislation. In particular, the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 expanded the definition of extreme pornographic images in England and Wales from 13 April 2015 to include the specified forms of non-consensual penetration, addressing concerns that the original legislation did not cover this type of material. The equivalent extension applied in Northern Ireland from 13 May 2016 under the Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 2016.
Sections 64–66 exclude certain classified-film images and provide defences, including legitimate possession, lack of knowledge or reason to suspect the nature of an unseen image, and unsolicited receipt without keeping the image for an unreasonable time. A limited defence also protects direct participants in qualifying consensual acts; it does not permit harm to which a person cannot lawfully consent. The maximum sentence on indictment under section 63 is three years for life-threatening acts, serious injury or the specified non-consensual penetration, and two years for the remaining categories.
From 6 November 2026, the Crime and Policing Act 2026 added to the 2008 Act separate offences of possessing or publishing pornographic images depicting strangulation or suffocation (section 67A, applying in England and Wales and Northern Ireland), specified sexual activity between actual or pretended relatives (section 67E), and sexual activity where someone is, or is pretending to be, under 16 (section 67H). The latter two offences apply in England and Wales. They require explicit and realistic depictions meeting the statutory tests, and are subject to exclusions and defences. The maximum on indictment for possession is two years under sections 67A and 67E, and three years under section 67H; publication carries up to five years.
Section 76 has also been amended. In England and Wales, the 2013 amendments expressly cover defence of property and make clear that there is no duty to retreat, although an opportunity to retreat can be relevant. In a qualifying householder case, grossly disproportionate force cannot be reasonable; force which is disproportionate but not grossly so must still be reasonable in the circumstances as believed. This exception applies to self-defence by a person who is not a trespasser, while in or partly in a dwelling or forces accommodation, against someone believed to be in or entering as a trespasser. In other cases disproportionate force is not reasonable. The householder amendments do not extend generally to Northern Ireland.
Last updated: 11 November 2026