Law Case Summary
Attorney General for Northern Ireland v Gallagher [1961] UKHL 2; [1963] AC 349
Criminal – murder – relevance of intoxication – defence of insanity and intoxication
Facts
Patrick Gallagher was convicted of murdering his wife. There was conflicting medical evidence about whether he was an aggressive psychopath and how this affected his understanding. He had bought a knife and whisky after deciding to kill her. It was not established whether he drank the whisky before or after the killing, or both.
Issues
Whether Gallagher was insane at the time of killing or was incapable of forming an intent necessary to constitute murder through drunkenness. Secondly, whether the trial judge had correctly directed the jury under M’Naghten’s Rules, particularly about the time at which his mental condition should be considered.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Held
The court held that there had been no misdirection by the trial judge. Reading the summing-up as a whole, Lord Tucker held that the jury had been properly directed to distinguish a disease affecting knowledge of the act or its wrongness from mere loss of self-control.
Lord Denning reaffirmed the law on drunkenness as a defence to crime. Applying DPP v Beard [1920] AC 479, drunkenness rendering a person incapable of forming the specific intent required for murder could reduce the offence to manslaughter. Gallagher was aware of what he was doing and had formed an intent to kill his wife, remembering he had done so afterwards. A distinct disease of the mind brought about by drinking could support an insanity defence under M’Naghten’s Rules if it meant that the accused did not know the nature and quality of the act or did not know it was wrong. Lord Denning found that Gallagher’s alleged psychopathy was not a disease brought on by drink.
Lord Denning explained that someone who, while sane and sober, formed an intention to kill and then became drunk for ‘Dutch courage’ could not rely on that self-induced drunkenness when carrying out the uninterrupted intention. Nor could such a person escape liability by presenting the resulting defect of reason as insanity. The Attorney-General’s appeal was allowed and the conviction of murder was restored.