Barrett v Ministry of Defence [1994] EWCA Civ 7; [1995] 1 WLR 1217; [1995] 3 All ER 87
Court of Appeal, 21 December 1994 — negligence, assumption of responsibility and contributory negligence.
The Ministry of Defence was not under a duty to stop a responsible adult serviceman drinking himself into unconsciousness. However, once it took charge of him after his collapse, it had to exercise reasonable care. Its failure to do so remained actionable, although his own contribution to his death substantially reduced the damages.
What happened?
Terence Barrett was a naval airman stationed at a Royal Navy base in northern Norway. On 22 January 1988, his thirtieth birthday, he drank heavily in the base’s bars. He had also recently learned that he was to be promoted. Alcohol was available cheaply, and enforcement of rules against excessive drinking was lax.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
After Barrett became unconscious, a duty petty officer arranged for him to be taken to his cabin on a stretcher. He was placed in his bunk in the recovery position and checked on a few occasions. No medical officer or medical attendant was called. He later inhaled his vomit and died.
His widow claimed damages for herself and their son under the Fatal Accidents Act 1976, and for his estate under the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1934. The trial judge found the Ministry liable both for failing to prevent dangerous intoxication and for inadequate care after the collapse. He reduced damages by 25% for Barrett’s contributory negligence, awarding £160,651.16.
The Ministry appealed against the first basis of liability and the allocation of responsibility. It accepted that, having assumed responsibility after the collapse, its care had been inadequate.
Why was there no duty to prevent the drinking?
The trial judge had relied on the base’s environment, the foreseeability of heavy intoxication and failures to enforce naval regulations. The Court of Appeal rejected that reasoning. Beldam LJ, with whom Saville and Neill LJJ agreed, explained that foreseeable harm alone did not establish a duty of care.
The Queen’s Regulations and standing orders were directed at discipline, fitness for duty and avoiding conduct bringing the service into disrepute. They were not equivalent to a code prescribing reasonable care for the safety of off-duty drinkers. Breach of a regulatory or disciplinary duty did not itself establish the private-law duty claimed.
The Ministry’s control of the base and provision of inexpensive alcohol did not make it responsible for a competent adult’s consumption. The Court considered it fair to leave such an adult responsible for deciding how much to drink. Canadian cases involving an intoxicated person admitted to a dangerous race or expelled into an immediate road danger involved additional circumstances and did not establish the proposed duty here.
Taking responsibility after the collapse
The position changed when naval personnel took charge of Barrett. The Ministry accepted that it then owed a duty to care for him and had breached it by failing to obtain medical help and providing inadequate supervision.
The distinction was between preventing Barrett from creating the danger through his own drinking and exercising reasonable care once responsibility for his condition had actually been undertaken. The Court did not dismiss the widow’s claim simply because Barrett had brought about his intoxication.
Contributory negligence and outcome
Barrett’s fault had not ceased to matter when he lost consciousness. His drinking both caused him to vomit and impaired his ability to protect his airways. It therefore remained a direct and continuing cause of his death, as well as creating the need for others to look after him.
The Court attributed two-thirds of the responsibility to Barrett and one-third to the Ministry. It allowed the appeal, replaced the original award with judgment for £71,400.51, and left interest to be assessed. Liability for the negligent care after his collapse remained; the reduction reflected his substantial responsibility for the fatal situation.