Barton v County NatWest Ltd [1999] Lloyd’s Rep Bank 408 concerned guarantees given for a company’s borrowing following a false statement about the valuation of its properties. The Court of Appeal allowed the guarantors’ appeal and explained the presumption of reliance arising from a material fraudulent misrepresentation.
Facts
County NatWest lent £2.025 million to Regent Leisure Time Ltd. The borrowing was secured on the company’s properties and supported by personal guarantees from Mr Barton and Mr and Mrs Amos, with security over their homes.
Before the transaction was completed, the bank’s manager represented that a valuation meeting the bank’s requirement for a forced-sale value of at least £3.5 million had been obtained. That statement was untrue. When the company failed to repay, the bank sought payment under the guarantees.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The guarantors challenged their liabilities on the ground that misrepresentations had induced them to enter the transaction. The trial judge nevertheless gave judgment for the bank, finding that the guarantors had not relied on the statements.
Reliance and the burden of proof
The appeal concerned whether the manager’s statement was fraudulent, whether it was intended to be acted upon and whether it had induced the guarantees.
Morritt LJ explained that, where a material fraudulent statement was likely to influence a reasonable person’s decision to enter the transaction, reliance would be presumed unless the person responsible for the statement established otherwise. This was a rebuttable presumption of fact. Its effect on the burden of proof did not disappear merely because the person who received the statement gave evidence.
The guarantors suggested particular ways in which the bank might rebut the presumption, including showing that they did not know of the statement, knew it was false, or demonstrated that it had not influenced them. The court did not treat these as an exhaustive legal checklist. The presumption could be rebutted by sufficient evidence, without restricting the possible facts capable of doing so.
A statement can reinforce an existing decision
The misrepresentation did not have to be the sole reason for proceeding. It could also induce someone to persist in a decision already made.
The valuation mattered because the guarantors depended on the bank’s finance. Confirmation that the bank’s valuation condition had been satisfied could influence their decision to continue, even if they already believed the purchase was attractive.
Decision
The Court of Appeal found that the bank manager had made the misrepresentation fraudulently and that it had induced the guarantors to enter their guarantees. Their appeal was allowed and the judgment against them was set aside.
The case distinguishes a rebuttable presumption of reliance from automatic liability for every false statement. The statement’s materiality and effect on the transaction remained essential.
Other citation: [2002] 4 All ER 494 (Note).
Sources: Barton v County NatWest Ltd, Court of Appeal, 14 July 1999; Morritt LJ’s paragraphs 55–56 reproduced at paragraph 106 of Parabola Investments Ltd v Browallia CAL Ltd [2009] EWHC 901 (Comm), and paragraphs 57–58 reproduced at paragraph 293 of Marme Inversiones 2007 SL v NatWest Markets plc [2019] EWHC 366 (Comm). The appeal outcome is recorded at paragraph 32 of Regent Leisuretime Ltd v NatWest Finance Ltd [2003] EWCA Civ 391.