Legal Case Summary
Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582
Medical negligence and the standard of care where responsible professional opinion differs.
Facts
John Hector Bolam was a voluntary patient at Friern Hospital receiving treatment for depression. During electro-convulsive therapy on 23 August 1954, he sustained serious fractures on both sides of his pelvis.
The treatment was given without muscle-relaxant drugs. His shoulders were held and his chin supported, with nurses beside the couch to prevent a fall, but his limbs were not restrained. Bolam alleged negligence in failing to use relaxants, failing to provide sufficient manual control and failing to warn him of the treatment’s risks.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The medical witnesses described differing practices. Some favoured relaxants or greater restraint. Others considered that relaxants carried their own risks and that restricting movement could increase the risk of fracture. The diagnosis and the decision to use electro-convulsive therapy were not themselves challenged.
Issues
The case concerned the standard by which the doctor’s conduct should be judged where competent practitioners disagreed about technique. It also raised whether a warning should have been given and whether Bolam would have refused treatment if warned.
Decision and reasoning
The jury returned a verdict for the defendants following McNair J’s directions, and judgment was entered for them.
McNair J explained that work involving a special skill was judged by the standard of an ordinarily competent practitioner of that skill. The law did not demand the highest expertise. A doctor was not negligent merely because another body of professional opinion favoured a different approach, provided the practice followed was accepted as proper by a responsible body of practitioners skilled in the relevant field. This formulation became known as the Bolam test.
The jury did not have to choose which of the competing practices was best. It had to assess whether the defendants’ practice met the required professional standard. Personal conviction alone was insufficient without reasonable grounds, and the test did not excuse persisting with an obsolete technique rejected by substantially the whole of informed medical opinion. Conduct had to be assessed against knowledge and practice in August 1954, when the treatment occurred.
On relaxants and restraint, the evidence identified recognised schools of thought supporting the defendants’ approach. The judge asked the jury to assess that evidence rather than infer negligence simply from the injury.
On the warning allegation, McNair J directed the jury to consider whether proper professional practice required a warning. If it did, Bolam also had to show that he would have declined treatment had he been warned. The judge noted that Bolam had not been asked what he would have done, leaving that response speculative. The verdict rejected the negligence claim; no damages were awarded.