Brady v Brady [1989] AC 755; [1988] 2 WLR 1308; [1988] 2 All ER 617
The maintenance of share capital is an important principle in company law. [1] Paid-up share capital cannot simply be returned to shareholders outside the procedures permitted by company law. Capital maintenance rules protect creditors by restricting returns of capital to members. A shareholder may sell shares to another investor, but a company may also buy back its own shares if the statutory requirements are met. [2]
As a consequence of the maintenance of share capital, a company’s purchase of its own shares and the provision of financial assistance for an acquisition of shares are subject to distinct statutory rules and exceptions. [3] The statutory definition of financial assistance includes gifts, loans, guarantees and certain assignments.[4] Under the 1985 Act, other financial assistance fell within s 152(1)(a)(iv) where it materially reduced the company’s net assets or the company had no net assets. [5]
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The case and the House of Lords’ decision
In Brady v Brady [6] a company with an established business in haulage and drinks ran into difficulties because of disagreements between the two brothers who were majority shareholders. In order to save the business an agreement was reached to divide it between them: one would keep the haulage business and the other one the drinks business. To effect this, a scheme of corporate reorganisation was formulated: the businesses were to be divided equally but the main company was left in existence. The defendants felt that the assets had not been distributed equally and they refused to complete the transaction, claiming that the financial operation involved unlawful financial assistance; the claimants started an action for specific performance.[7]
The Court of Appeal ruled in favor of the defendants and stated that the scheme, which required financial assistance for the purchase of its own shares was not in the interest of the company.[8] Furthermore, they considered the way in which the scheme was carried out by creating indebtedness of Motoreal, Brady’s holding company, to Brady, was ‘worthless and incapable of amounting to consideration’.[9]
The House of Lords overruled the decision of the Court of Appeal, and stated that there was no misfeasance and furthermore, the interests of the creditors would improve in the long term. The transaction was therefore in good faith and in the interest of the company. However the House of Lords gave a narrow meaning to ‘some larger purpose’ and therefore severely restricted the use of the provision.[10]
The House considered ss 151–153 of the Companies Act 1985 (CA 1985), which consolidated the relevant provisions of the Companies Act 1981. Section 151 prohibited financial assistance for acquiring shares in the company or reducing or discharging a liability incurred for that acquisition, subject to statutory exceptions.[11] Exemptions are provided in s 153. There was also a statutory procedure under ss 155–158 for private companies, often called a ‘whitewash’. It required the applicable net-asset or distributable-profit condition, directors’ solvency declarations and auditors’ reports, together with approval and filing requirements. A special resolution was unnecessary for a wholly owned subsidiary giving assistance to its holding company, as in this case.[12]
The appeal ultimately succeeded because the agreed scheme could be completed lawfully by using that private-company procedure. Good faith and commercial benefit did not by themselves satisfy the ‘larger purpose’ exception: ending the deadlock was the reason for the scheme, but acquiring the shares was its essential purpose. Specific performance was conditional on compliance with the statutory procedure, and the defendants were given 28 days to reinstate their abandoned defences. The action was remitted to the High Court.
Later law and statutory changes
Under the Companies Act 2006, the relevant prohibitions are in ss 678–679 (CA 2006). Section 678(1) concerns assistance for acquiring shares in a public company before or at the acquisition; s 678(3) also covers assistance to reduce or discharge an acquisition liability after the acquisition. [13] There are two exceptions from s 678(1) under s 678(2): (a) where the company’s principal purpose in giving assistance is not the acquisition of shares, and (b) where the financial assistance is incidental to some larger purpose. The assistance must be given in good faith in the interest of the company.[14] The general prohibition was removed for assistance by a private company to acquire shares in a private company. This is not a blanket exemption for every private-company transaction: s 678 can also apply to assistance by a private subsidiary for acquiring shares in its public parent, and s 679 restricts assistance by a public subsidiary for acquiring shares in its private holding company.[15]
In applying the statutory provisions, the courts looked at financial assistance in a more liberal way after Brady, particularly in borderline cases.[16] In Parlett v Guppys (Bridport) Ltd[17], assistance involving a commitment to future payments was assessed when the commitment was entered into, rather than only when money was paid. The relevant question concerned its effect on net assets, not whether particular ‘main assets’ had been removed. The courts took a similar view regarding the infringement of s 151 if there were two ways of effecting the transaction and only one of them would infringe s 151 as seen in Grant v Lapid Development Ltd.[18]
In more recent cases, the courts have considered in detail the commercial transaction per se in order to decide whether there is financial assistance for the purpose of acquiring shares. [19] In MT Realisations Ltd (in liquidation) v Digital Equipment Co Ltd [20] the Court of Appeal did not find financial assistance. This case concerned inter-company loans payable on demand which were secured by fixed and floating charges. The arrangement redirected sums owed to the company to discharge existing secured debt. The Court of Appeal held that the secured creditor received nothing it was not already entitled to enforce against the company’s assets; it was not receiving financial assistance out of the company’s free resources.[21]
The legal position of companies regarding financial assistance has changed since the enactment of the CA 2006. The Act also permits financial assistance in certain cases involving public companies. Section 682(2)(b) concerns assistance given in good faith in the interests of the company or its holding company for an employees’ share scheme. For a public company giving such assistance, s 682(1)(b) requires that its net assets are not reduced, or that any reduction is covered by distributable profits. [22]
Finally, the CA 2006 has codified the duties of directors under ss 171-177; these duties must be complied with when directors are considering giving financial assistance, particularly the duty to act within the powers given to them by the constitution under s 171 and the duty to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members under s 172. Section 172(3) also preserves enactments and rules of law requiring directors, in certain circumstances, to consider or act in the interests of the company’s creditors. Removal of a financial-assistance prohibition does not remove directors’ duties.[23]
In conclusion, the CA 2006 has simplified transactions for private companies, for instance, entering into certain kinds of loans, guarantees, indemnities and funding arrangements, but public companies are under a more stringent regime within the Act and must ensure that they do not contravene the financial assistance provisions in the legislation.
Footnotes
[1] Alexis Mavrikakis, Helen Watson, Christopher Morris, Nick Hancock, Business Law and Practice (College of Law Publishing 2013) 189
[2] Ibid, 190
[3] Ibid
[4] Anthony Arlidge, Jacques Parry, Arlidge and Parry on Fraud (Sweet & Maxwell 2013) Chapter 14, Company Fraud, Financial assistance for the acquisition of shares, 14-045. Available through Westlaw UK> search books> Arlidge and Parry on Fraud. Accessed on 13 September 2015
[5] Mavrikakis (n 1) 196
[6] Brady v Brady [1989] AC 755 (HL); [1988] 2 WLR 1308; [1988] 2 All ER 617. Original report.
[7] D L Morgan, Brady v Brady – a family feud (1988) Journal of Business Law, 412-415
[8] Ibid
[9] Ibid
[10] Mavrikakis (n 1) 196
[11] Mavrikakis (n 1) 196
[12] Natalie Smith, Sarah Spencer, Financial Assistance under CA 2006 (2009) 993 Tax Journal, 2
[13] Ibid
[14] Mavrikakis (n 1) 196
[15] Smith (n 12)
[16] David Milman, Financial assistance in the acquisition of shares: a continuing concern (2003) 11 Company Law Newsletter 1-4
[17] [1996] BCC 299; see the explanation in Paros plc v Worldlink Group plc [2012] EWHC 394 (Comm), [67].
[18] [1996] BCC 410
[19] Mavrikakis (n 1) 196
[20] [2003] EWCA Civ 494
[21] Mavrikakis (n 1) 197
[22] Smith (n 12)
[23] Smith (n 12)
Statutory references: Companies Act 2006, s 678, s 679, s 682 and s 690.