British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd [1912] AC 673
Contract damages, reasonable mitigation and benefits obtained from replacing defective machinery.
Facts
British Westinghouse contracted to supply and erect eight steam turbines and eight turbo-alternators for Underground Electric Railways. The machinery failed to meet the agreed requirements for economy and steam consumption. The railway company used it for several years, incurring additional operating costs while reserving its claim for damages.
It then replaced the turbines with Parsons machines. These had greater capacity and were substantially more efficient, even compared with the performance the original turbines should have delivered under the contract.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
When British Westinghouse claimed the unpaid balance of the contract price, the railway company counterclaimed in arbitration. Its alternative claims included projected losses from continued use of the defective machinery, or the cost of installing the replacements together with operating losses already incurred.
The arbitrator found the replacement commercially reasonable and prudent. He also found that the Parsons machines were so advantageous that replacing the original machines would have been worthwhile at the railway company’s own expense even if British Westinghouse had performed its contract properly.
Issue
In assessing damages, should the benefits obtained from the replacement turbines be brought into account? The railway company argued that it could recover their purchase and installation costs as expenditure incurred in mitigating its loss, without deducting the advantages from their superior performance.
Decision and reasoning
The House of Lords allowed British Westinghouse’s appeal. It reversed the decision below and sent the award back to the arbitrator with directions about the correct approach to damages.
Compensation and reasonable mitigation
Viscount Haldane LC explained that damages should, so far as money could do so, place the injured party in the position it would have occupied had the contract been performed. Compensation was for the financial loss flowing from the breach.
That principle was qualified by the need to take reasonable steps to mitigate loss. A claimant could not recover loss attributable to an unreasonable failure to take such steps. It was not, however, required to do anything beyond what a reasonable and prudent businessperson would ordinarily do.
Actual benefits could not be ignored
Where the claimant had in fact taken reasonable business action arising from the breach, the resulting reduction in its loss could be considered even if it had not been obliged to take that particular step. The railway company did not have to buy machines with a greater capacity, but the financial consequences of its actual choice remained relevant.
The purchase formed part of its continuing response to the defective equipment. It was not an independent transaction unrelated to the breach. The arbitrator therefore had to consider the transaction as a whole, balancing its cost against its advantages.
On the findings made, the new turbines’ efficiency eliminated the remaining loss and left the railway company financially better off. Their cost could not simply be added to the damages while the resulting savings were ignored. The company remained entitled to compensation for the additional operating costs caused by the defective machines during the period before replacement; those earlier losses were not in dispute.
Principle illustrated
The case shows why the reasonableness of mitigation expenditure does not by itself settle the amount recoverable. The court must also consider whether the same response has reduced or eliminated the loss claimed. The judgment distinguished benefits arising naturally from the response to the breach from benefits under independent arrangements, such as an unrelated insurance contract.
Source: House of Lords judgment, 19 July 1912, also reported at 50 SLR 617.