Case summary
Canada Steamship Lines Ltd v The King [1952] UKPC 1; [1952] AC 192
Exclusion and indemnity clauses: whether general contractual wording protected the Crown against the consequences of its employees’ negligence.
Facts
Canada Steamship Lines leased land and a freight shed at Montreal from the Crown for twelve years from May 1940. Under clause 8, the Crown was responsible for maintaining the shed at its own expense. Clause 7 stated broadly that the company could not claim against the Crown for damage to the premises or property kept there. Clause 17 required the company to indemnify the Crown against specified claims connected with the lease.
In May 1944, Crown employees repairing a shed door used an oxy-acetylene torch to enlarge a bolt hole. Sparks reached nearby bales of cotton waste and started a fire which destroyed the shed and its contents. The company claimed $40,713.72 for its own property. Other owners also claimed for goods destroyed.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The Crown relied on clause 7 to defeat the company’s claim. It also used clause 17 to seek reimbursement from the company for the claims brought by five other owners. By the time of the Privy Council appeal, the Crown accepted that its employees had been negligent.
Proceedings and issue
The trial judge awarded the agreed damages and rejected the Crown’s indemnity claims. He found gross negligence and considered that Quebec law prevented the clauses from protecting the Crown against it. The Supreme Court of Canada rejected the finding of gross negligence and construed the clauses in the Crown’s favour.
On the company’s appeal, the Privy Council first considered the meaning of the clauses. The question was whether they covered damage caused by the Crown’s own employees’ negligence. If they did not, the further questions about gross negligence would not need to be decided.
The three-part approach
Lord Morton of Henryton, delivering the Board’s judgment, set out the following approach to the wording:
- Express coverage: if a clause expressly exempted a party from the consequences of its employees’ negligence, effect should be given to that provision.
- Sufficiently wide words: without an express reference to negligence, the court should ask whether the words, in their ordinary meaning, were wide enough to cover it. Doubt at this stage should be resolved against the party relying on the exemption.
- Another possible basis of liability: even if the words were wide enough, the court should ask whether the relevant kind of damage could arise on a ground other than negligence. If so, the general wording should be confined to that other ground. The alternative must be a realistic possibility, not something so fanciful or remote that the party could not have intended protection against it.
Why clause 7 failed
The wording was broad enough, on its face, to cover damage to goods in the shed. However, it could operate on claims arising from the Crown’s obligations as lessor under the Civil Code without extending to negligence. One example was liability for an unknown defect in the leased premises. The Board rejected the suggestion that such possibilities were too remote to matter.
Clause 7 also had to be read alongside the Crown’s express maintenance obligation in clause 8. It was unlikely that the company had accepted that the Crown could perform that obligation so negligently as to destroy the shed and its contents without liability. The company’s separate obligation to insure the shed did not refer to goods inside it. The Crown had not excluded liability for negligence in sufficiently clear terms.
Why clause 17 failed
The indemnity began with broad language, but the words which followed limited its scope. The reference to execution of the lease meant signing and sealing it, rather than performing every obligation it contained. The remaining wording was more naturally directed at claims connected with the rights granted to, and acts done by, the company under the lease.
The Board preferred that interpretation to one requiring the company to pay for destruction caused by the Crown’s own negligent repairs. Imposing such a substantial obligation required clear words, and the clause did not clearly do so.
Outcome and significance
The appeal was allowed and the trial judge’s orders were restored. The Crown’s defence to the company’s claim and its claims for indemnity both failed. The Board resolved the appeal by interpreting the lease and did not decide whether the conduct amounted to gross negligence or what consequences Quebec law would attach to that finding.
The decision illustrates why broad language about damage or indemnity must be read in context. The important question was whether the clauses clearly covered this source of liability, taking account of other liabilities on which the wording could operate and the obligations elsewhere in the lease.
Source: Privy Council judgment, 21 January 1952, on appeal from Canada.