Clark Fixing Ltd v Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council [2001] EWCA Civ 1898
Court: Court of Appeal (Civil Division). Decision: 12 December 2001.
Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council was liable in negligence after a fire started by intruders spread from its vacant premises to neighbouring factories. The decision depended on the council’s knowledge of the developing danger and its failure to take reasonable, inexpensive precautions against it.
Facts
The council acquired industrial premises for a bypass scheme. After the former occupier left, the property stood empty beside factories occupied by Clark Fixing Ltd and Dudley Section Benders Ltd. A combustible timber “Belfast roof” extended across the premises.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
A large timber sectional office building had been left inside the council’s property. Trespassers repeatedly entered and started fires, apparently to burn insulation off copper cables they wanted to steal. Following an earlier fire, plasterboard had been removed from the office structure to prevent concealed smouldering. That work also left the timber more susceptible to ignition.
The council received complaints about the intrusions and previous fires, including concern that fire could spread through the shared roof. Its arrangements for recording complaints and allocating responsibility for vacant-property safety were inadequate. The concerns were not brought together and acted on by someone responsible for assessing the fire risk.
On 19 May 1996, a fire ignited the timber office structure, spread to the roof and devastated the neighbouring premises. The parties agreed that the office structure provided the route by which the fire reached the roof.
Issue and procedural history
The trial judge found for the claimants on liability and causation, leaving damages to be assessed. The council appealed. The central question was whether it should have identified and removed the timber structure as a foreseeable means by which fire could spread to its neighbours.
The applicable duty
The court applied Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd [1987] 1 AC 241. An occupier was not automatically responsible for fire deliberately or carelessly started by trespassers. A duty could arise where the occupier knew, or had the means of knowing, that third parties were creating a real fire risk and failed to take reasonable steps to prevent damage to neighbouring property.
The precautions required depended on the circumstances and had to be proportionate to the risk. The trial judge had rejected a broader proposed duty to carry out a risk assessment simply because an organisation acquired an empty building. The claimants did not pursue that wider argument in the Court of Appeal.
Reasoning and outcome
The appeal was principally a challenge to the trial judge’s factual findings. The Court of Appeal found no basis to overturn them. The council knew that intruders were entering and setting fires, that neighbouring occupiers feared fire spreading, and that the properties shared a timber roof.
Those warnings called for a proper investigation. The fact that some fire officers and council staff had not identified the particular hazard did not answer the claim: they had not been asked to assess that risk in the relevant circumstances. The judge was entitled to find that a person responsible for fire-safety assessments should have recognised it.
The timber office structure could have been dismantled and removed for a modest sum. That would have removed the route by which the smaller fires being lit inside could reach the high roof. The council should have investigated and removed readily movable combustible material; the office structure plainly fell within that description.
The appeal was dismissed, leaving the finding of liability and causation in place. Damages remained to be assessed.
Significance
The case illustrates a duty arising from knowledge of a specific danger created by third parties. Liability rested on the warnings, the physical features of the premises and the practical means of avoiding the harm. It did not follow merely from the council owning the vacant property or from trespassers having started the fire.
Source: Original Court of Appeal judgment.