Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1984] UKHL 9
House of Lords, 22 November 1984 — the GCHQ case: prerogative powers, legitimate expectation and national security.
Facts
Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) provided signals intelligence and protected the security of official and military communications. Since 1947, its staff had been permitted and encouraged to join national trade unions. There was an established practice of consulting staff representatives before important changes to employment conditions.
Industrial action between 1979 and 1981 disrupted GCHQ’s work. The Government subsequently decided that staff should no longer belong to national trade unions. They could instead belong to a departmental staff association approved by GCHQ’s director.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The Minister for the Civil Service, who was also the Prime Minister, gave an oral instruction on 22 December 1983. The change was announced on 25 January 1984 without prior consultation. The instruction was made under article 4 of the Civil Service Order in Council 1982, an instrument deriving its authority from the royal prerogative rather than an Act of Parliament.
Proceedings and issues
The unions and employees sought judicial review. Glidewell J declared the instruction invalid because the Minister had failed to consult. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision.
The appeal to the House of Lords raised three connected questions: whether a power derived from the prerogative could be reviewed; whether the established consultation practice created a legitimate expectation; and whether national-security considerations justified departing from that practice.
The challenge concerned the procedure used to make the decision. The House was not being asked to decide whether restricting national trade-union membership was the best policy. An earlier challenge to separate statutory certificates affecting employment protections had been abandoned.
Decision
The House of Lords unanimously dismissed the appeal. The power was reviewable in principle, and the history of consultation would ordinarily have required consultation before this change. However, the evidence established that the Minister had reasonably considered prior consultation a risk to national security. That justified the procedure followed.
Why the source of the power did not settle the question
Lords Scarman, Diplock and Roskill rejected the proposition that a decision was immune from judicial review simply because its power came from the prerogative. The important question was whether its subject matter was suitable for determination by a court.
Lord Roskill distinguished the management of civil servants’ conditions from powers whose nature made them unsuitable for judicial adjudication. His examples included treaty-making and decisions about the disposition of the armed forces. Reviewability therefore did not mean that judges could reconsider every exercise of executive power on its merits.
Lords Fraser and Brightman reached the same result on the narrower ground that the power here had been delegated by the Order in Council. They left open the broader question of reviewing a direct exercise of prerogative power.
Legitimate expectation of consultation
The employees had no private-law right requiring their conditions to remain unchanged. Nevertheless, a regular practice of consultation could give them a legitimate expectation protected through public law.
The longstanding arrangements at GCHQ were sufficient to create that expectation. Without the national-security issue, changing the conditions without consulting the unions or staff would have been procedurally unfair. The expectation concerned an opportunity to be consulted; it did not give the unions a veto over the eventual decision.
Why national security justified the departure
The Government’s case was that advance consultation risked provoking the very disruption it was trying to prevent. Sir Robert Armstrong’s affidavit described the earlier industrial action and the vulnerability of GCHQ’s operations.
The Lords considered whether the evidence supported that explanation. They accepted that the decision to proceed without consultation had actually been based on national-security concerns, and that a reasonable minister could have taken that view.
This was not a rule that merely mentioning national security ended the court’s inquiry. Evidence was required to establish the factual basis of the Government’s position. Once that basis was established, the assessment of what national security required was for the responsible executive authorities, rather than for the court to substitute its own judgment.
Lord Diplock’s grounds of review
Lord Diplock grouped the established grounds of judicial review under three headings:
- Illegality: the decision-maker must understand and apply the law governing the power.
- Irrationality: a decision may be challenged for Wednesbury unreasonableness, a demanding standard rather than ordinary disagreement with its merits.
- Procedural impropriety: the decision-maker must comply with applicable procedural rules and requirements of fairness.
The consultation complaint fell within procedural impropriety. Lord Diplock did not present the three headings as permanently exhaustive: he mentioned proportionality as a possible future development, without adopting it as an additional ground in this case.
Legal principle
The case separates the existence of judicial control from success on a particular challenge. A prerogative source did not itself prevent review, and a settled administrative practice could create a legitimate expectation. Here, however, the established national-security reason justified withholding prior consultation.
Judgment: Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1984] UKHL 9; also reported at [1985] AC 374, [1984] 3 WLR 1174, [1984] 3 All ER 935, [1985] ICR 14 and [1985] IRLR 28.