The Supreme Court held that the Scottish courts’ approach to excluding evidence in sexual offence trials could infringe the right to a fair trial under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. It dismissed the joined appeals of Daly and Keir because the exclusion of evidence did not make either trial unfair.
Background
Mr Daly was convicted of sexual offences against two complainers. The first complainer had also alleged a separate, later rape that she said led to a pregnancy and birth. The Crown did not charge him with that allegation. Medical evidence indicated that a full-term birth was highly unlikely, but could not establish whether she had been pregnant and miscarried. Mr Daly wanted to challenge her credibility by asking about that allegation. His counsel did not apply for permission to do so. The High Court of Justiciary refused him leave to appeal at both sift stages.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Mr Keir was convicted of offences arising from an incident at his house. The prosecution alleged that he sexually assaulted the complainer while she was asleep and raped her after she awoke. His defence was that her account of being asleep and waking was untrue. He sought to rely on evidence of sexual activity earlier that evening. The trial judge refused permission, and the High Court of Justiciary upheld that ruling.
The issues
The appeals concerned compatibility with Article 6. The Court considered whether the Scottish approach to admitting evidence relevant to a complainer’s credibility, reliability or consent risked violating the right to a fair trial, and whether either appellant’s trial was unfair. Mr Daly also argued that his counsel’s failure to apply under section 275 amounted to defective representation.
The Court’s reasoning
The Scottish approach to admissibility
Evidence must first be relevant at common law. In sexual offence trials, sections 274 and 275 of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 impose a further filter. The Court held that the recent Scottish approach to relevance could exclude material that, if accepted, would significantly strengthen the defence. A rigid rule against evidence treated as collateral could prevent the defence from effectively challenging a witness whose credibility was central to the prosecution case.
Courts may protect a complainer’s privacy and keep out evidence whose probative value is outweighed by the risk of distorting the jury’s assessment. Where evidence is important to the defence, courts should consider whether measures such as careful jury directions can address that risk. The Court held that Scottish courts had a duty under section 6(1) of the Human Rights Act 1998 to modify their approach to comply with the Convention.
Daly
The failure to make an application did not bar Mr Daly’s Article 6 complaint because an application would have been bound to fail under the approach the Scottish courts then took. Whether the uncharged allegation was false or deliberately invented remained uncertain. Investigating it would have required the jury to consider a separate alleged offence. The defence had other opportunities to challenge the first complainer’s credibility, and the jury could assess her evidence in light of the second complainer’s account.
Keir
Earlier sexual activity gave the jury little help in deciding whether the complainer had been asleep at the house or whether her account of what happened there was true. Evidence of her high intoxication and CCTV showing her unsteadiness weakened any inference from her earlier behaviour. The risk of prejudice outweighed the limited probative value of the evidence. The defence could cross-examine the complainer, and the jury heard Mr Keir’s account from his police interview, apart from the excluded references.
Decision
The Supreme Court dismissed both appeals on the grounds before it. The Crown had accepted a separate Article 6 disclosure breach in Daly’s case. That was a matter for the appeal court.
Reported citations: [2025] 1 WLR 5360; [2025] WLR 5360; [2025] WLR(D) 586.
Source: Daly and Keir v His Majesty’s Advocate [2025] UKSC 38