DSND Subsea Ltd v Petroleum Geo Services ASA [2000] EWHC 185 (TCC); [2000] BLR 530
Technology and Construction Court, 28 July 2000. Economic duress, misrepresentation and contractual termination.
Dyson J rejected PGS’s attempt to avoid a contract variation for economic duress or misrepresentation. He also held that its subsequent termination notice was invalid. The case distinguishes illegitimate pressure from commercial bargaining and shows why termination must comply with the particular contractual procedure invoked.
The contract and dispute
DSND contracted with PGS Offshore Technology AS to perform subsea work at the Banff oilfield. Although Petroleum Geo Services ASA appears first in the case title, the contracting party was PGS Offshore Technology AS, referred to as PGS in the judgment.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The work included installing flexible risers connecting the seabed to a floating production vessel. The parties changed their installation plans, leaving payment and insurance issues to be resolved. On 25 September 1998 they signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) revising payment arrangements, the work schedule and protection against risks associated with the riser interface equipment. An October memorandum of agreement (MOA) provided for another vessel, Rockwater’s Semi 2, to assist.
PGS later alleged that the September agreement resulted from a misrepresentation about DSND’s vessel, the Fennica, and economic duress. On 19 November it purported to terminate the contract for failing to provide a suitable diving support vessel from 10 November. Dyson J determined preliminary issues at trial.
Why the misrepresentation claim failed
PGS relied on a statement that the Fennica could operate in a significant wave height of three metres. Dyson J found that DSND’s representative had expressed an expectation, based on experience rather than calculations, and had qualified it by reference to buoyancy sections and crew safety and comfort. PGS’s technically qualified representatives would have understood that further work was required before a reliable conclusion could be reached.
The statement was therefore not an actionable representation in the circumstances. The judge also found that PGS had not relied on it when entering the MOU. By then, PGS knew that substantial parts of the operation required conditions of no more than two metres. The September negotiations principally concerned payment and insurance. The later communications relied on did not establish the alleged repeated representation.
PGS also failed to establish that the vessel lacked the relevant capability. Alternatively, even if an inducing misrepresentation had been proved, rescission would have been barred. PGS had affirmed and relied on the MOU after learning of the alleged problem, while DSND incurred substantial obligations to Rockwater. These were distinct reasons for rejecting PGS’s case.
Economic duress and commercial pressure
Dyson J identified three requirements for actionable duress: pressure producing compulsion or a lack of practical choice; illegitimacy of that pressure; and a significant causal connection between the pressure and entering the agreement.
Relevant factors included an actual or threatened breach of contract, good or bad faith, realistic alternatives, protest and subsequent affirmation. The existence of commercial pressure did not by itself establish duress.
DSND had suspended assembly of the riser interface units while seeking adequate insurance or indemnity protection. Its concern was genuine and reasonable. The equipment was untried, and a failure during installation could have serious consequences. Dyson J said that, even if the suspension amounted to a breach, it did not constitute illegitimate pressure in these circumstances.
That did not establish a general right to suspend work. The contract contained no suspension provision. Nor did the judge accept that DSND had refused to resume work until PGS met its payment demands. The negotiations involved concessions on both sides and were ordinary commercial bargaining.
The judge was also unpersuaded that PGS lacked a realistic alternative. It had access to legal advice and contractual termination options. Its principal negotiator had not explored alternative vessels, and there was no contemporaneous written protest supporting the alleged duress.
Alternatively, PGS had affirmed the MOU after any pressure had ceased. It continued to insist on compliance with that agreement and eventually relied on an alleged breach of it to terminate. The court would therefore have refused to set it aside even if duress had initially been established. The dependent challenges to the October agreement consequently did not arise.
Why the termination was invalid
The termination notice relied specifically on the absence of a suitable diving support vessel from 10 November. The court found no relevant breach. The agreed schedule had contractual effect, but its dates were indicative, and diving work was to follow completion of riser installation. That installation was not completed until about 20 November.
DSND had also taken reasonable steps to obtain a vessel. The market was tight, the programme uncertain, and booking an expensive vessel far in advance on standby would not have served PGS’s interests. The Semi 2 was suitable for diving work and had already performed some of it.
There was a separate obstacle to termination under article 16.1: PGS had to identify the situation and give DSND a reasonable opportunity to remedy it, with a warning of termination. Even assuming a relevant breach, that opportunity had not been given. The court treated this as an alternative ground, rather than a finding that DSND had breached the contract.
PGS could not recast its notice as termination without cause under article 16.3. The two routes carried fundamentally different financial consequences, and PGS had elected to use article 16.1.
Outcome
The challenges based on misrepresentation and economic duress failed, and the termination notice was invalid. As PGS conceded would follow from invalidity, its notice repudiated the contract. DSND was entitled to accept that repudiation and had done so. The judgment resolved preliminary issues rather than awarding a quantified sum of damages.
Source: Full judgment (BAILII).