E E Caledonia Ltd v Orbit Valve Co plc [1994] 1 WLR 1515
Wording and clarity of indemnity clauses, attempts to indemnify for own negligence
Facts
This case was linked to the Piper Alpha platform disaster. The Claimants made a settlement with the dependants of a deceased engineer, who had passed away as a result of the disaster which occurred on an oil platform owned by the Claimants. The engineer was not, however, an employee of the Claimants but rather of Orbit Valve, the Defendants. The Claimants sought to claim the cost of that payment/settlement from the Defendants under an indemnity clause, found in the contract between them. The relevant indemnity clause stated that it applied in respect of any claim, demand, cause of action, loss, expense or liability arising from the death of an employee of the indemnifying party, resulting from or in any way connected with performance of the contract. The clause did not, however, make any reference to negligence. The case proceeded on assumed facts that the Claimants’ employee’s negligence and the Claimants’ breaches of statutory duty were concurrent causes of the death.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
The issue was whether the clause could be interpreted to protect the claimant from his own negligence.
Decision/Outcome
The court observed how implausible it would be for anyone to willingly contract to indemnify someone else for their own negligence and that in order for that to happen, very clear language would have to be used. In this case, the clause was construed as leaving each party responsible for its own negligence. The absence of the word “negligence” was relevant, but interpretation depended on the wording in its contractual setting; it was not an automatic rule requiring that particular word. The court observed this to be particularly problematic for the claimant, since this was clearly a professionally drafted contract and therefore, there was no reason for negligence not to have been included in the wording if this had been intended by the parties. The concurrent breaches of statutory duty did not enable the Claimants to recover under the indemnity for a death also caused by their negligence. Consequently, the Court of Appeal dismissed their appeal.
Additional report: [1994] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 239.
Sources: Court of Appeal judgment; the court’s reasoning at p 1525 is reproduced in CST Cleaning, paragraph 33.