Fisher v Bridges (1854) 3 E & B 642 concerned a deed promising payment of money owed under an illegal land-sale agreement. The Exchequer Chamber held that putting the debt into a covenant did not make it enforceable. The security arose from the same unlawful transaction as the debt it secured.
The transaction
The seller agreed to transfer land to the buyer, who was to dispose of it by an unlawful lottery. The buyer’s plea alleged an agreement made for that illegal purpose, known to the seller, followed by a conveyance in pursuance of it. Part of the purchase money remained unpaid. The buyer later covenanted by deed to pay £630, with interest, to secure that outstanding amount.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The seller sued on the covenant. The buyer relied on the illegality of the underlying agreement. Although the jury found the relevant plea for the buyer, the Queen’s Bench entered judgment for the seller notwithstanding that verdict. The buyer then brought the case before the Exchequer Chamber.
The issue: a deed securing an illegal debt
The seller’s argument relied on the distinction between a simple promise and an obligation under seal: a deed did not need consideration to support it. The dispute was therefore not simply whether the later covenant lacked fresh consideration. It was whether the unlawful transaction which the covenant secured prevented enforcement.
There was also an issue about the meaning of the buyer’s plea. The court construed it as alleging an illegal agreement between the parties for the sale and conveyance of the land for the unlawful object. It was not deciding a general proposition that a seller’s awareness of any possible future misuse automatically invalidates an otherwise independent sale.
Decision and significance
The Exchequer Chamber reversed the Queen’s Bench. The covenant had been given to secure part of the purchase money due under the illegal agreement. As the law would not enforce that debt, it would not enforce the security given for it.
The important distinction was between an absence of consideration and illegality. The seller could not avoid the latter by relying on the formal character of the deed. On the transaction pleaded, the covenant remained dependent on the unlawful agreement from which it arose.
The case illustrates the need to examine what a later promise or security actually secures. Its holding concerned a covenant supporting the price of this illegal land transaction, rather than a rule that every subsequent agreement connected in some way with unlawful conduct must fail.
Report source
Case report (vLex). The decision was given by the Exchequer Chamber on 4 May 1854. Parallel citations include 118 ER 1283, 23 LJ QB 276 and 1 Jur NS 157.