Hotson v East Berkshire Area Health Authority [1987] AC 750; [1987] 2 All ER 909
House of Lords, 1987
A claimant had to establish that delayed treatment caused or materially contributed to his permanent hip injury before damages for that injury could be assessed. On the trial judge’s findings, the original fall was its sole cause. The House of Lords removed the award for a lost chance of recovery, while leaving compensation for the additional pain caused by the delay untouched.
Facts
Stephen Hotson was thirteen when he fell about twelve feet from a rope attached to a tree at school in April 1977. He fractured the upper end of his left femur. Staff at St Luke’s Hospital failed to diagnose the injury and sent him home.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Five days later, after severe pain, he returned to hospital. X-rays revealed the fracture, and treatment followed. He developed avascular necrosis: inadequate blood supply damaged the growing bone at the hip, causing deformity and lasting disability, with osteoarthritis expected to follow.
The health authority admitted negligence in failing to diagnose the fracture promptly. The dispute was whether the delay caused the permanent condition, as distinct from the extra pain during those five days.
The decisions below
Simon Brown J awarded £150 for the avoidable pain. He also assessed a 75% probability that the original injury would have produced the same permanent damage even with prompt treatment. He described the delay as removing the remaining 25% chance of avoiding that outcome.
The judge valued the damage attributable to the avascular necrosis at £46,000 and awarded one quarter, £11,500, for the lost chance. The Court of Appeal upheld that award. The health authority appealed to the House of Lords.
Issue
Was the uncertainty a question of causation, to be resolved on the balance of probabilities, or a question of valuing a lost chance after an actionable loss had already been established?
The decisive medical question concerned Hotson’s condition before the hospital’s negligence began: had the fall already ruptured so many blood vessels that avascular necrosis was inevitable?
Decision and reasoning
The House of Lords unanimously allowed the appeal concerning the £11,500 award.
A disputed past fact had to be decided
Lord Bridge explained that the claimant needed to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the delayed treatment was at least a material contributory cause of the permanent condition. The judge’s findings meant that it was more likely than not that the fall had already left too few intact blood vessels to keep the affected bone alive. On those findings, the fall was the sole cause.
Lord Mackay emphasised that the 75:25 assessment expressed uncertainty about an existing condition. If too few vessels had survived the fall, prompt treatment could not prevent the necrosis. If enough had survived, the judge’s findings indicated that immediate treatment would have avoided it. The court had to determine which state of affairs existed, rather than treat its uncertainty as a separate asset worth 25% of full damages.
Causation came before valuation
Lord Ackner distinguished proof that negligence caused an injury from the assessment of damages once that connection had been established. A claimant who proved causation was not restricted to a percentage of compensation reflecting how confidently the court had reached that finding.
Equally, the separate award for five days’ pain did not establish causation for the hip deformity. Each alleged consequence required its own causal connection to the admitted negligence.
The broader question was left open
The House did not decide that loss-of-chance evidence could never support a claim in medical negligence. Lord Bridge considered this an unsuitable case for settling that wider question, and Lord Mackay expressly cautioned against such a general rule. The appeal was resolved on the particular findings about the injury sustained in the fall.
Outcome
The damages were reduced by £11,500 and the interest attributable to that sum. The undisputed £150 award for additional pain remained. The decision illustrates why a court must first identify and resolve the causal question before using percentages to value an alleged loss.