Law Society v KPMG Peat Marwick and others [2000] EWCA Civ 5563; [2000] 1 WLR 1921
Court of Appeal, 29 June 2000
Accountants preparing statutory reports on a solicitors’ firm’s accounts owed a duty of care to the Law Society as trustee of its Compensation Fund. The reports helped the Society decide whether to intervene to protect clients and the Fund. The fact that intervention was a public regulatory function did not prevent a private law duty from arising.
Facts
KPMG and two of its partners prepared annual accountants’ reports for the solicitors’ firm Durnford Ford. The firm retained and paid the accountants; the reports were sent to the Law Society under the statutory reporting arrangements.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
In 1992, the Law Society investigated the firm, which subsequently stopped practising. Two partners had defrauded clients. About 300 clients made claims on the Compensation Fund, and approximately £8.5 million was paid out.
The Law Society alleged that the reports for 1989 and 1990 should have contained stronger qualifications. It said that proper warnings would have led it to intervene earlier and stop further dishonesty. It attributed approximately £7.4 million of the Fund’s payments to the alleged negligence concerning those reports. A separate action concerned the 1991 report.
The accountants denied negligence, causation and any duty to the Society as trustee of the Fund. The Vice-Chancellor decided the preliminary duty issue in the Society’s favour. The accountants appealed; the parties agreed that the determination would also bind the later action.
Issues
The question was whether the accountants owed the Society a duty of care capable of supporting recovery for losses to the Compensation Fund. This required attention to both the purpose of the reports and the capacity in which the Society claimed.
The accountants distinguished the Society’s regulatory functions from its role as trustee. They also distinguished the Council, which took intervention decisions, from the Society, which administered the Fund, and argued that recognising liability would improperly transfer losses from the solicitors’ profession to the accountants.
Decision and reasoning
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. Lord Woolf CJ gave the leading judgment; Ward and Clarke LJJ agreed.
Why the reports created a sufficiently close relationship
The court applied the Caparo criteria of foreseeable damage, proximity, and whether imposing the duty was fair, just and reasonable. It did not treat the duty as self-evident merely because the reports resembled professional advice supplied under a contract.
The reporting system enabled the Society to identify failures to comply with the solicitors’ accounts rules and take protective action. Intervention could protect both clients and the Compensation Fund. The accountants knew the purpose for which their reports were required, and it was foreseeable that an inadequate warning could leave the Fund exposed to further claims.
Public functions and a private law duty
The Council was the Society’s governing organ, not a separate recipient whose reliance could be divorced from the Society’s loss. However, the Society’s different functions still mattered: a duty relating to one function did not automatically extend to every other function.
On these facts, the relevant duty protected the Society in its capacity as trustee of the Fund. There was no obstacle in principle to a private professional owing a private law duty whose performance assisted a public body in carrying out regulatory responsibilities. The anticipated response to a report did not have to be a commercial transaction.
Limits on potential liability
The court rejected the argument that litigation costs and the Fund’s financing by solicitors justified denying the duty. Those considerations did not deprive the Society of a claim for loss for which accountants might be responsible.
Recognising the duty did not establish unlimited recovery. The accountants could rely on fault by the Society that had contributed to the loss. They could also argue that the scale of particular losses was beyond what they could reasonably have foreseen from the accounts on which they reported. Questions about the causal chain remained open.
Outcome and significance
The appeal was dismissed with costs and permission to appeal was refused. The decision upheld the duty of care; it did not find that the accountants had breached it, establish that earlier intervention would have prevented particular losses, or award the sums claimed.
The case illustrates how the known purpose and recipient of a professional report can support a duty concerning financial loss even when the report is commissioned by someone else and is intended to prompt regulatory action.