Linden Gardens Trust Ltd v Lenesta Sludge Disposals Ltd and others [1993] UKHL 4; [1994] 1 AC 85
Assignment of contractual rights; consent clauses; accrued causes of action.
The House of Lords held that a building contract’s prohibition on assignment without the contractor’s written consent covered both rights to future performance and existing claims for breach. The attempted assignment to Linden Gardens was ineffective against the contractor. The restriction was not invalid on public-policy grounds.
Facts
Stock Conversion and Investment Trust held leasehold interests in premises in Jermyn Street, London. In 1979 it engaged McLaughlin & Harvey to remove blue asbestos. Lenesta Sludge Disposals was the nominated subcontractor.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Clause 17 of the building contract prohibited the employer from assigning the contract without the contractor’s written consent. When further asbestos was found after completion, Stock Conversion engaged another contractor, Ashwell Construction, to remove it.
Stock Conversion transferred its leasehold interests to Linden Gardens in stages during 1985 and 1986. In January 1987 it also purported to assign its rights of action concerning the works. McLaughlin & Harvey had not consented to that assignment. More asbestos was subsequently discovered, and Linden Gardens paid for further removal work.
Linden Gardens was substituted as claimant in proceedings originally brought by Stock Conversion. It claimed as assignee against the contractors. The trial judge held the assignment ineffective. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision, treating existing causes of action differently from rights to future performance. McLaughlin & Harvey appealed to the House of Lords.
Issues
The principal questions were what the prohibition on assigning the contract meant, whether it included claims for breaches which had already occurred, and whether public policy prevented such a restriction from taking effect. Linden Gardens also argued that an assignment in breach of the clause could still transfer the rights, leaving only a claim for breach of the restriction.
Decision and reasoning
The House of Lords allowed McLaughlin & Harvey’s appeal. Lord Browne-Wilkinson explained that, although a contract’s burdens cannot simply be assigned without the other party’s consent, references to assigning a contract commonly mean assigning its benefit. Clause 17 restricted that transfer.
The restriction also covered accrued rights of action. In a building contract, a contractor can have a legitimate interest in dealing only with the employer it selected, including when resolving disputes about payment and defective work. Splitting existing claims from rights to future performance could force the contractor to deal with different parties and create uncertainty over settlement or termination.
The court did not rule that every restriction must always have that scope. Different wording could distinguish future performance from accrued benefits. Clause 17, properly construed, did not make that distinction.
The public-policy challenge failed. The court saw no sufficient reason to invalidate a contractual restriction designed to prevent an unwanted third party from acquiring direct rights against the contractor. This was different from deciding whether the original parties to an assignment could arrange between themselves to account for money received under the contract.
Finally, the prohibition had substantive effect: the attempted assignment did not vest the contractual rights in Linden Gardens as against McLaughlin & Harvey. It was not merely an effective transfer accompanied by a separate breach of contract.
Outcome and related appeal
Linden Gardens could not enforce the purportedly assigned rights against McLaughlin & Harvey. Because the assignment failed, the question of the damages Linden Gardens could have recovered under a valid assignment did not arise.
The same judgment also decided St Martin’s Property Corporation Ltd v Sir Robert McAlpine & Sons Ltd. That appeal concerned the different question whether the original contracting party could recover substantial damages for loss suffered after the property had been transferred to someone else.
Judgment: Linden Gardens and St Martin’s [1993] UKHL 4, 22 July 1993.