Legal Case Summary
Lloyds Bank Ltd v Bundy [1974] EWCA Civ 8; [1975] QB 326
Undue influence; guarantee; bank owing duty of fiduciary care
Facts
Mr Bundy was an elderly farmer. He and his son were long-time customers at Lloyds Bank – the son’s company also banked there. Mr Bundy guaranteed the company’s overdraft and charged the farm as security. As the overdraft increased, Lloyds needed more security, which – as per the son – Mr Bundy could provide. An assistant manager visited Mr Bundy with his son and left the documents for consideration and advice. Mr Bundy sought legal advice and was told that £5,000, about half the value of his home, was the utmost he should risk in his son’s affairs. He then executed the further guarantee and charge. The son’s business was unsuccessful so he told Lloyds that his father would give further security. Subsequently, the son went to Mr Bundy with a Lloyds assistant manager with a further guarantee and charge, for even higher sums than before. Mr Bundy, trying to help his son, signed these deeds as well. The son’s company ceased to trade; Lloyds attempted to sell Mr Bundy’s house.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
The assistant manager gave evidence that – in his view – Mr Bundy relied on him for advice about the transaction. Mr Bundy himself said that he simply did what the manager and his son said. The assistant manager also admitted to knowing that Mr Bundy did not have any other assets except for his house. Mr Bundy claimed that the final guarantee and charge should be set aside. Nevertheless, the judge gave an order for possession. Mr Bundy appealed.
Decision / Outcome
The Court found for Mr Bundy. The nature of the relationship between Lloyds and Mr Bundy was such – i.e. that of confidentiality – that the Court could intervene in the event of its abuse. There was a conflict of interests in Mr Bundy’s signing of the final guarantee and legal charge as he could lose his only asset to the bank. In the unusual circumstances, the bank’s duty of fiduciary care required it to insist on independent advice before obtaining the final documents. It had not done so. This was distinct from a common law duty of care, and the court did not impose such a fiduciary duty in every ordinary bank guarantee transaction. Consequently, the final guarantee and charge were set aside based on undue influence.
Lord Denning MR also proposed a broader principle based on inequality of bargaining power. Cairns LJ and Sir Eric Sachs decided the appeal on the established doctrine of undue influence, and Sachs expressly declined to express an opinion on that wider approach.