Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130
High Court, King’s Bench Division — 18 July 1946
Facts
In 1937, Central London Property Trust Ltd granted its subsidiary, High Trees House Ltd, a 99-year lease of a block of flats at an annual ground rent of £2,500. The companies were closely connected. The block was not fully occupied when war broke out, and the income from the flats was insufficient to meet the rent in the conditions then prevailing.
Following discussions, the landlord confirmed in a letter of 3 January 1940 that the annual ground rent would be reduced to £1,250. The tenant subsequently paid the reduced rent.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
By early 1945, the flats were fully let, but the tenant continued paying at the lower rate. In September 1945, the landlord’s receiver demanded payment at the full rate and asserted that arrears were due.
The claim and defence
The companies brought a test case to establish their legal position. The claim in the reported action was for £625: the difference between the reduced rent and the original rent for the quarters ending 29 September and 25 December 1945.
The tenant argued that the agreement fixed the lower rent for the entire lease. Alternatively, it relied on estoppel or waiver to prevent recovery at the higher rate, including an argument that the landlord had waived its right to additional rent until its September demand.
Decision
Denning J gave judgment for the landlord for the amount claimed. The rent reduction was a temporary arrangement directed at the conditions under which the flats were only partly let. Those conditions had ended by early 1945, so the promise no longer applied to the two quarters in issue.
Reasoning: the promise and its scope
There were difficulties with treating the reduction as an ordinary contractual variation. The lease was made by deed, and the agreement to accept less rent was not supported by fresh consideration. Traditional estoppel also concerned representations of existing fact, whereas this promise concerned future enforcement of rent.
Denning J drew on earlier decisions in which a promise was intended to create legal relations, was known by its maker to be likely to be acted upon, and was actually acted upon. In those circumstances, the courts had prevented the promisor from acting inconsistently with the promise despite the difficulty of identifying consideration.
He distinguished that restraint from awarding damages for breach of the promise itself. His discussion supplied the equitable basis associated with promissory estoppel: the promise could constrain enforcement of existing rights without operating as an ordinary bargain supported by consideration.
The decisive question was how far this particular promise extended. Denning J found that the parties intended a temporary reduction while wartime conditions left the flats substantially unlet. They had not agreed to halve the rent for the remaining decades of the lease. Once the flats became fully let, the original rate applied again.
What the judgment did and did not decide
Denning J said that the reduction bound the landlord for the earlier period to which it applied. However, rent for that period was not being recovered in this action. His observations about preventing recovery of the earlier shortfall went beyond the claim he had to determine.
The actual result was that the landlord recovered the balance for the two quarters of 1945. Resumption of the full rate followed from the limited scope of the promise; the judgment did not establish that every promise to accept less merely postpones collection of the unpaid balance.