Marc Rich & Co AG v Bishop Rock Marine Co Ltd [1995] UKHL 4, also known as The Nicholas H, concerned whether a ship classification society owed a duty of care to cargo owners. By a majority of four to one, the House of Lords held that no duty arose on the assumed facts, despite the foreseeable risk of physical damage to the cargo.
Facts and the claim
The Nicholas H was carrying lead and zinc concentrate from South America in 1986 when cracks developed in its hull. The ship’s classification society, Nippon Kaiji Kyokai (NKK), sent a surveyor to inspect it near San Juan, Puerto Rico. Classification confirmed that a ship met the society’s standards and was commercially important for insurance and trading.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The surveyor initially recommended permanent repairs in dry dock. After the shipowners objected, temporary repairs were carried out and he changed his recommendation, allowing the vessel to retain its classification for the voyage. The repairs failed and the ship sank, losing its cargo. No lives were lost.
The cargo was worth more than US$6 million. The cargo owners settled their claim against the shipowners for about US$500,000, reflecting the applicable tonnage limit on liability. They sought approximately US$5.7 million from NKK.
The question before the court
The proceedings determined a preliminary question of law: whether NKK owed the cargo owners a duty of care capable of supporting a damages claim. For that purpose, the parties assumed that the surveyor had been careless, that his carelessness caused the loss, and that physical damage to the cargo was foreseeable. Those assumptions were not findings made after a trial of negligence.
Hirst J answered the duty question in the cargo owners’ favour. The Court of Appeal reversed his decision, and the cargo owners appealed to the House of Lords.
Why foreseeable physical damage was not enough
Lord Steyn gave the majority’s substantive reasons. He rejected the argument that foreseeable physical damage automatically established a duty. The nature of the parties’ relationship and whether imposing a duty was fair, just and reasonable remained relevant. These considerations overlapped and had to be assessed in the particular circumstances.
He was prepared to assume, without deciding, that sufficient proximity existed. The decisive question was whether recognising the proposed duty would be fair, just and reasonable.
The majority attached particular weight to the established allocation of responsibility between shipowners and cargo owners. Their dealings operated within a system of contracts, the Hague Rules, tonnage limits and insurance. Shipowners had primary responsibility for seaworthiness and the cargo, while cargo owners could insure against losses exceeding the shipowners’ limited liability.
Liability against NKK could undermine that arrangement. Classification societies might pass increased insurance costs to shipowners or demand indemnities, exposing shipowners indirectly to costs beyond the agreed system. NKK would face potentially extensive liability without the limitation protections available to shipowners.
The majority also considered NKK’s independent, non-profit public-safety role. Extensive cargo claims could encourage defensive practices, complicate settlements and divert resources from surveying ships. It was the combined force of these considerations, rather than any one factor alone, which defeated the claim.
No assumed responsibility to these cargo owners
The alternative argument that NKK had voluntarily assumed responsibility also failed. There had been no contact between NKK and the cargo owners, who did not even know that the society had been called in. They had relied on the shipowners’ undertakings.
The judgment did not give classification societies blanket immunity from negligence claims. Lord Steyn recognised that different facts, including direct dealings capable of establishing an assumption of responsibility, could require a different analysis.
Lord Lloyd’s dissent
Lord Lloyd would have allowed the appeal. In his view, ordinary negligence principles supported a duty where the surveyor’s careless work foreseeably caused physical damage to cargo already aboard the vessel. He considered the relationship sufficiently close and rejected the suggestion that the shipowners’ contract displaced a separate duty owed by the surveyor.
He also questioned the evidential basis for predictions about insurance costs and the consequences for classification societies. His disagreement concerned the application of negligence principles to this survey; it did not deny the agreed assumptions about the loss.
Decision
The House dismissed the appeal on 6 July 1995. The Court of Appeal’s ruling that NKK owed no duty of care on these facts stood. The decision shows why the majority considered the commercial and institutional context significant even where the alleged harm was physical damage rather than purely financial loss.
Report citations: [1996] 1 AC 211; [1995] 3 WLR 227; [1995] 3 All ER 307; [1995] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 299; [1995] CLC 934; [1996] ECC 120.
Source: House of Lords, full judgment in Marc Rich & Co AG v Bishop Rock Marine Co Ltd.