Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd [1980] UKHL 2; [1980] AC 827; [1980] 1 All ER 556
House of Lords, 14 February 1980 — exclusion clauses, fundamental breach and the effect of termination.
Facts
Photo Production engaged Securicor to provide patrol visits to its factory. The agreement, made in 1968, required visits at night and at specified times over the weekend. The weekly charge was £8 15s, a modest price for the service.
During a Sunday-night visit, Securicor’s employee Musgrove deliberately threw a lighted match onto cartons inside the factory. The fire spread and caused agreed loss and damage of £615,000. The trial judge could not determine Musgrove’s motive or whether he intended only a small fire or more extensive damage. It was therefore not a finding that he intended to destroy the factory.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The contract excluded Securicor’s responsibility for an injurious act or default by an employee unless it could have been foreseen and avoided through due diligence by Securicor as employer. Other provisions addressed particular losses and limited the amount recoverable. No negligence in employing or supervising Musgrove was alleged, and it was not suggested that the relevant act could have been foreseen and avoided by due diligence.
Procedural history and issues
MacKenna J held that Securicor could rely on the contractual provisions. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision, treating the destruction of the factory as a fundamental breach which prevented reliance on the exclusion clause.
The House of Lords had to decide whether a rule of law automatically deprived Securicor of the clause’s protection and, if not, whether the wording covered the employee’s conduct. These were distinct questions: rejecting an automatic rule did not itself establish that the particular clause applied.
Decision
The House unanimously allowed Securicor’s appeal and restored the trial judge’s order. The clause excluded liability for this loss. Whether an exclusion clause covered a breach depended on construing the contract, rather than attaching the label of fundamental breach and treating the clause as ineffective regardless of its wording.
Why fundamental breach did not invalidate the clause
Lord Wilberforce explained that Suisse Atlantique had already rejected an automatic rule disabling exclusion clauses. Harbutt’s Plasticine Ltd v Wayne Tank and Pump Co Ltd, on which the Court of Appeal had relied, had misunderstood that decision and was overruled.
Termination following a serious breach did not erase the contract as though it had never existed. It generally released the parties from further performance. A claim for damages nevertheless arose from the contract, so its provisions governing damages could remain relevant.
Lord Diplock explained this through the distinction between primary and secondary obligations. Primary obligations concerned the promised performance, such as providing the patrol service. A breach ordinarily generated a secondary obligation to pay compensation. Where a sufficiently serious breach justified termination, further performance could end while obligations concerning compensation remained. Contractual terms could qualify those obligations, subject to applicable legal limits.
This reasoning did not deny that a breach could justify termination. It rejected the further proposition that calling the breach fundamental automatically destroyed an otherwise applicable exclusion or limitation clause.
Why this clause covered the fire
The words covering any injurious act or default by an employee were sufficiently clear to include Musgrove’s deliberate act. Lord Wilberforce recognised that clear wording was needed to escape responsibility for one’s own wrongdoing or that of an employee. Whether the wording extended beyond negligence to deliberate conduct was still a matter of interpretation.
The commercial setting supported that reading. Securicor supplied periodic visits for a small charge, rather than taking over every risk associated with the factory. Photo Production knew the premises and their value. The parties could allocate the risk of damage between themselves and arrange insurance accordingly.
Because the employee-liability exclusion applied, the House did not need to decide whether the separate monetary limits would also have restricted recovery.
Scope of the ruling
The contract predated the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, so the appeal was decided under the common law. References in the speeches to that Act were not an application of its reasonableness controls to this agreement.
The ruling established that a serious breach did not automatically defeat an exclusion clause. It did not make every exclusion clause effective: the contract’s wording still had to cover the loss, and the legal controls applicable to the agreement still mattered.
Judgment: Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd [1980] UKHL 2.