R v Bailey [1983] EWCA Crim 2
Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), 11 March 1983 — hypoglycaemia, self-induced automatism and recklessness.
Facts
John Graham Bailey, who had diabetes and used insulin, visited Michael Harrison after Bailey’s former partner began a relationship with him. During the visit Bailey said he felt unwell and drank sugar and water supplied by Harrison. Later, when Harrison bent down to look for a supposedly missing glove, Bailey struck him on the head with an iron bar.
Bailey claimed that he had acted during a temporary loss of awareness caused by hypoglycaemia, having failed to eat enough after taking insulin. He said that he remembered asking about his glove and then finding himself holding the bar, but not the attack itself.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The prosecution relied on his earlier accounts to the police, in which he described bringing the bar and deliberately striking Harrison because of the relationship. His doctor accepted that a temporary loss of awareness was theoretically possible, but considered the sudden episode alleged extremely unlikely after Bailey had taken sugar and water.
Trial and issues on appeal
Bailey was convicted of wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm under section 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. The jury did not need to return a verdict on the alternative count of unlawful wounding under section 20.
The trial judge had directed the jury that automatism was unavailable where the incapacity was self-induced, including through failure to eat after taking insulin. On appeal, the court considered whether that direction was correct for either count and whether the errors required the conviction to be overturned.
Decision
The Court of Appeal found misdirections in relation to both offences but dismissed the appeal. Even with a proper direction, the jury would inevitably have rejected the claimed automatism on the evidence. The court was therefore satisfied that there had been no miscarriage of justice.
Specific intent under section 18
The trial direction was wrong because self-induced incapacity could still prevent the prosecution from proving the specific intent required by section 18. The court referred to DPP v Majewski: even incapacity caused by voluntarily consuming alcohol or drugs could negative the specific intent to kill or cause grievous bodily harm.
It followed that the jury could not simply be told to disregard Bailey’s claimed condition because his failure to eat had contributed to it. They still had to consider whether the prosecution had proved the required intent.
Basic intent and prior recklessness
The court also rejected a blanket rule excluding all self-induced automatism from offences of basic intent. It distinguished voluntary intoxication through alcohol or dangerous drugs from failure to eat after an insulin injection.
For an assault offence, the relevant question was whether the accused knew that his conduct or failure to act was likely to make him aggressive, unpredictable or uncontrolled, creating a risk of injury to others, and nevertheless persisted or failed to take necessary remedial action. In those circumstances, the jury could find recklessness.
The court did not assume that every person with diabetes knew that missing food could produce aggressive behaviour. Knowledge of a risk of losing consciousness did not, by itself, establish awareness of a risk of injuring someone else. The prosecution had to prove the necessary recklessness. Bailey’s jury had received no adequate direction on that issue.
Why Bailey nevertheless lost
The court doubted whether the defence had a sufficient evidential foundation to be left to the jury at all. More decisively, Bailey’s detailed descriptions to the police were inconsistent with the sudden loss of awareness he later claimed. There was substantial evidence that he had armed himself and visited Harrison intending to attack him.
The medical evidence also made his account extremely unlikely. The legal availability of automatism in principle therefore did not establish that Bailey had actually acted automatically.
Legal principle
Self-induced automatism unrelated to voluntary intoxication was not automatically excluded as a defence to a basic-intent assault. Prior recklessness required attention to the accused’s knowledge of the risk. For a specific-intent offence, the prosecution still had to prove that intent. Bailey’s conviction stood because the evidence defeated his factual defence despite the incorrect directions.
Judgment: R v Bailey [1983] EWCA Crim 2; also reported at [1983] 1 WLR 760 and [1983] Crim LR 353.