R v Brown (Vincent Edward Patrick) [1985] EWCA Crim 3; [1985] Crim LR 212
Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), 18 January 1985
Entry for the purposes of burglary did not require the defendant’s whole body to be inside a building. The Court of Appeal upheld Brown’s convictions where there was evidence that his upper body had been inside a shop’s window display. Whether there had been an effective entry was a question of fact for the jury.
Facts
Shortly after midnight in November 1983, a witness heard breaking glass and saw men at an Argos shop in Hendon. He identified Brown as a man whose upper body was inside the shop-front display, rummaging about. His view was partly obscured, and he assumed that Brown’s feet were on the ground outside.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The witness later saw goods being placed into a briefcase. Brown and another man, Peerless, returned to the shop window before the police arrived. Brown was arrested there. He denied taking anything and disputed the witness’s identification and account.
Brown was convicted of two burglaries involving goods from the window display on separate occasions. The items charged were a briefcase and travel set on one count and an electric razor on the other. He was fined £50 on each count and ordered to pay £80.97 compensation.
Issue
Did the trial judge misdirect the jury by explaining that putting a hand, arm or the upper body through a broken shop window could amount to entering the building under section 9 of the Theft Act 1968?
Brown argued that burglary required his entire body to have entered. He relied particularly on the reference to an effective and substantial entry in R v Collins. His counsel accepted that, even if the burglary appeal succeeded, convictions for theft would have to be substituted.
Decision and reasoning
Watkins LJ, delivering the court’s judgment, dismissed the appeal. The jury had been adequately directed and had properly found an entry as a trespasser.
The whole body did not have to enter
The court rejected the proposed requirement of complete bodily entry as an incorrect reading of the statutory language. A jury could find that inserting a hand, arm or upper body through a broken shop window to take goods amounted to entry. A person did not avoid burglary merely by keeping part of his body outside.
Brown also relied on R v Parkin, which concerned an older offence of being found in a building at night with criminal intent. The court distinguished that wording from entering a building: the earlier decision did not determine the meaning of the Theft Act provision.
Collins did not impose the proposed requirement
The central question in Collins had been whether the defendant entered as a trespasser, knowing he lacked permission or being reckless about it. The court found nothing in that judgment requiring the defendant to be wholly inside.
Watkins LJ considered that adding the word substantial did not help determine whether entry had occurred. Effective entry was the useful direction. The trial judge had not used that exact word, but his examples had properly explained the issue in the circumstances of Brown’s case.
Outcome
Both burglary convictions stood. The decision left entry to the jury on the facts, with appropriate directions, and rejected a rule requiring the whole body to cross into the premises. It did not replace effective entry with an alternative test of substantial entry.
Source: Original Court of Appeal judgment.