Legal Case Summary
R v Clinton, Parker and Evans [2012] EWCA Crim 2; [2013] QB 1; [2012] 3 WLR 515; [2012] 2 All ER 947; [2012] 1 Cr App R 26; [2012] Crim LR 539
MURDER, DIMINISHED RESPONSIBILITY, LOSS OF CONTROL, DEFENCE, SEXUAL INFIDELITY
Facts
In the first case, Clinton killed his wife in their family home after their marriage broke down and he discovered her affair. He claimed to have lost control following her alleged taunts about suicide and statements about the children, in the context of her infidelity. He was convicted of murder and arson by the Crown Court. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum specified term of 26 years. The verdict was returned by the jury after considering the defence of diminished responsibility. The judge ruled that there was insufficient evidence of loss of control for this issue to be considered by the jury. Clinton appealed.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
In the second case, Parker killed his wife in their family home after she said she wanted to separate and asked him to leave. He had not known of her brief affair before her death. The jury at the Crown Court rejected the loss of control defence and convicted him of murder. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum specified term of 17 years.
In the third case, Evans killed his wife in their family home following an argument. He claimed that she had stabbed him before he stabbed her. The prosecution alleged that his wounds were self-inflicted and that he acted out of revenge rather than a loss of control. The jury at the Crown Court rejected the loss of control defence and convicted him of murder. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum specified term of 11 years.
Issue
What was the scope of the exclusion of sexual infidelity as a qualifying trigger under s.55(6)(c) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009, and had the trial judges correctly dealt with the loss of control defence in the three cases?
Decision/Outcome
(1) If sexual infidelity was the only potential qualifying trigger for the loss of control, s.55(6)(c) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 has to be applied.
(2) Where sexual infidelity was integral to the context in which a potentially permissible trigger under s.55(3) or (4) had to be evaluated, it was not excluded from that evaluation. The statutory requirements still had to be satisfied; infidelity could not itself supply the qualifying trigger. Once a qualifying trigger was established, infidelity could also be considered among the defendant’s circumstances under ss.54(1)(c) and 54(3).
Clinton’s appeal was allowed because the judge misdirected herself as to the relevance of infidelity and wrongly did not leave the matter to the jury. A new trial was ordered; the court did not substitute a manslaughter conviction.
Parker’s appeal was dismissed because the directions, read as a whole, properly placed the burden of disproving the defence on the prosecution and fairly presented the evidence. The court also rejected his challenge to the admission of evidence about his previous behaviour.
Evans’ appeal was dismissed because the judge had accurately directed the jury on a “considered desire for revenge”. The statutory language was clear and did not require further reformulation.