R v Fiak [2005] EWCA Crim 2381
The Court of Appeal upheld Engin Fiak’s convictions for criminal damage and assaulting a police officer with intent to resist lawful apprehension or detention. Soaking a police blanket and flooding cells amounted to damage because the property was temporarily unusable. The officer’s delay in saying that Fiak was under arrest did not make her conduct unlawful in the circumstances.
Facts
Police officers found Fiak sitting in the driver’s seat of a stationary car outside his home, vomiting by the roadside. He smelled of alcohol and was unsteady on his feet. He said he had been drinking at home and had gone outside for fresh air, but had not been driving. The officer already had reasonable grounds for believing that he was in charge of the vehicle after consuming excess alcohol.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
PC Smith told Fiak he was being detained while she checked his account with his wife. He repeatedly tried to enter his house. During the ensuing struggle, the prosecution alleged that he trapped PC Smith’s leg between his own, twisting her knee. Once he was brought under control, she expressly told him why he was being arrested. Fiak denied resisting arrest or injuring her in that way.
At the police station, Fiak put his blanket into the lavatory and flushed repeatedly, flooding his cell, two adjoining cells and the passage. The blanket was wet but not visibly soiled, and clean water covered waterproof floors. Nevertheless, the blanket and cells were unavailable for use until they were dried or cleaned. A jury convicted him on both counts, and he was fined £750 for each offence.
Issues
Fiak argued that he had been unlawfully restrained before the officer used the word “arrest”, so the assault conviction could not stand. He also argued that wetting a blanket and cell floors did not constitute damage under the Criminal Damage Act 1971. He challenged the judge’s directions on damage and lawful excuse.
Decision and reasoning
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on 11 October 2005.
The arrest and assault
The court treated the officer’s actions as one continuing process. She had sufficient grounds to arrest when she first detained Fiak, but briefly checked his explanation before formally completing the arrest. Her conduct did not become unlawful merely because she had not yet used the word “arrest”. Fiak knew why he was being detained, and the reasons for arrest were expressly communicated as soon as reasonably practicable.
There was therefore a case for the jury on the assault count. The disputed accounts were for the jury to resolve, and the criticisms of the judge’s directions did not undermine the conviction’s safety.
Damage and lawful excuse
Drawing on Morphitis v Salmon and R v Whiteley, the court explained that damage could include temporary impairment of property’s value or usefulness. The fact that the effects could be remedied did not prevent the blanket and cells from being damaged while they were unusable.
Whether damage occurred would normally be left to the jury. Here, however, a finding that the uncontested flooding and soaking caused no damage would have been untenable. The judge’s direction on that point did not make the conviction unsafe.
Fiak’s explanation that he acted to obtain his rights provided no lawful excuse on these facts. The court expressly left open any question that might arise where a prisoner was unlawfully detained; it did not decide that different situation.
Judgment: R v Fiak [2005] EWCA Crim 2381.