Legal Case brief
R v Jogee [2016] UKSC 8
Parasitic Accessory Liability, intention and foresight of principal’s act
Facts
This joint case involved two separate appellants who had been convicted for murder on the basis of joint enterprise, after a co-defendant had actually killed the victim. In Jogee’s case, the prosecution evidence was that he shouted encouragement to Hirsi, who fatally stabbed Fyfe. In Ruddock’s case, the prosecution alleged that he and Hudson had intended to rob Pete Robinson of his car and had killed him in the course of the robbery. Hudson pleaded guilty to murder. In Jogee, the judge made the direction that liability as an accessory would attach where the defendant participated in the attack while realising that the principal might stab the victim while intending to cause really serious harm. In the case of Ruddock, the judge made the direction that it was necessary to establish a shared common intention between the principal and the accessory and this could be proved where the defendant was shown to have known that there was a real possibility that the principal might intend to commit a given crime (in that case GBH or murder) and still continued with his participation in the joint enterprise.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
The court had to determine whether the principle of Parasitic Accessory Liability, as established in Chan Wing-Siu v The Queen [1985] 1 AC 168, is a correct exposition of the law.
Decision/Outcome
The court held that in order to prove accessorial liability, it was not sufficient to only prove the necessary mental element, but also the element of conduct. This could be discharged by proving that the accessory either assisted or at least encouraged the principal in committing the offence. The prosecution must prove that the accessory intended to assist or encourage the principal to commit the offence with the required mental element. That intention can be conditional. Foresight can be evidence of intent, but foresight alone does not establish it. Chan Wing-Siu v The Queen [1985] 1 AC 168 was wrong to equate foresight with intent. The court approved R v Collinson (1831) 4 Car & P 556, R v Smith (Wesley) [1963] 1 WLR 1200, CCA and R v Reid (Barry) (1976) 62 Cr App R 109, CA.
The Supreme Court held that Jogee’s murder conviction could not stand and invited submissions on whether to order a retrial or substitute a manslaughter conviction. In the companion appeal, Ruddock v The Queen [2016] UKPC 7, the Privy Council held that the misdirection required it to allow the appeal. It invited submissions on the order it should recommend.
Reported citations: [2017] AC 387, [2016] 2 WLR 681, [2016] 2 All ER 1, [2016] 1 Cr App R 31, (2016) 180 JP 313, [2016] WLR(D) 84