Legal Case Summary
R v Morris; Anderton v Burnside [1984] AC 320
Dishonest supermarket label switching could amount to theft before payment: assuming any one of the owner’s rights was sufficient.
Facts and background
The House of Lords heard two appeals together. In the first, Morris removed goods from supermarket shelves and replaced their price labels with labels showing lower prices. He paid those lower prices at the checkout and was then arrested. In the second, Burnside transferred a price label from one joint of pork to another, more expensive joint. He was stopped at the checkout before paying.
Morris was convicted on two theft counts. A further count of obtaining property by deception under section 15 of the Theft Act 1968 was left on the file without a verdict. Burnside was convicted of theft in the magistrates’ court. Their challenges had failed in the Court of Appeal and Divisional Court respectively, and both appealed to the House of Lords.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The issue: what counted as appropriation?
Section 1 of the Theft Act 1968 required a dishonest appropriation of property belonging to another with an intention permanently to deprive. Section 3(1) described appropriation in terms of assuming an owner’s rights. The disputed question was whether the defendants had appropriated the goods before payment, rather than merely preparing to deceive the cashier.
The defendants argued that appropriation required the assumption of all the owner’s rights. They accepted that Morris’s completed transaction could support an offence of obtaining property by deception, but contended that neither defendant had committed theft before reaching that stage.
The House of Lords’ reasoning
Lord Roskill, with whom the other four Law Lords agreed, rejected the suggested requirement to assume every right of ownership. Read as a whole, section 3 showed that assuming any one of those rights could be enough. The supermarket’s right to have its goods sold and paid for at the correct price was one such right.
The removal and relabelling of the goods interfered with that right. Their order did not matter: switching the label before removing the goods from the shelf could have the same effect as doing those things in reverse. Placing the relabelled goods in a trolley, bag or basket provided further evidence of appropriation. On the facts of these appeals, the other elements of theft were established, so the offence did not depend on successful payment of the lower price.
Lord Roskill distinguished this conduct from an honest customer taking goods from a shelf to pay the correct price. In his reasoning, that customer acted with the shop’s implied authority. He described appropriation as adverse interference with, or usurpation of, an owner’s rights. His answer to the certified questions allowed that dishonest label switching, either alone or combined with other acts, could supply the necessary interference.
Decision and the separate deception offence
The House unanimously dismissed both appeals. The theft convictions stood even though one defendant had paid and the other had not.
The judgment also distinguished the time at which theft was committed from the later obtaining of property by deception under section 15. In Morris’s case, the earlier appropriation and subsequent deceptive payment supported separate offences. The counts were therefore cumulative rather than alternatives, and Lord Roskill considered that verdicts should have been taken on every count left to the jury.
He nevertheless suggested that prosecutors might simplify cases involving completed deceptive purchases by charging only the section 15 offence. Where a shopper was stopped before obtaining the goods by deception, theft remained the appropriate charge if all its ingredients were proved. This was a distinction between the offences and charging choices considered in the judgment, rather than a requirement that every shoplifting case result in two convictions.
Judgment: R v Morris; Anderton v Burnside, House of Lords, 13 October 1983; reported at [1984] AC 320, [1983] 3 WLR 697 and [1983] 3 All ER 288.