Legal Case Summary
R v Savage; DPP v Parmenter [1991] UKHL 15; [1992] 1 AC 699
The mental elements of unlawful wounding or inflicting grievous bodily harm under section 20, and assault occasioning actual bodily harm under section 47.
Facts
In the first case, Ms. Savage threw beer over her husband’s ex-girlfriend in a bar. The glass broke and cut the victim’s wrist. The jury’s verdict left open whether she had thrown the glass deliberately or accidentally let it slip while deliberately throwing the beer. She claimed that she had no intention to harm the victim with the glass, yet was convicted of unlawful wounding under section 20. The Court of Appeal quashed that conviction for misdirection and substituted assault occasioning actual bodily harm under section 47. In the second case, Mr. Parmenter had injured his new-born son, yet claimed that he had done so accidentally as he had no experience with small babies. Mr. Parmenter was convicted on four counts under section 20. The Court of Appeal quashed those convictions because the jury had been directed to consider whether he ought to have foreseen harm, rather than whether he actually foresaw it. The Director of Public Prosecutions appealed.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
The issue pertained as to whether it was necessary to establish that the defendant intended the infliction of grievous bodily harm in order to establish the crime of malicious infliction of grievous bodily harm under s 20 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. The House also had to decide whether section 47 required foresight of bodily harm in addition to the mental element for the assault, and whether that offence was an available alternative verdict on a section 20 charge.
Decision/Outcome
It is unnecessary that the accused should either have intended or have foreseen that his unlawful act might cause grievous bodily harm under s 20 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. To satisfy the mens rea element of “maliciously,” it is not necessary to demonstrate that the defendant intended the level of harm inflicted. It is sufficient that the accused foresaw that some physical harm to some person, no matter of how minor a character envisaged, might result from the conduct. The test is subjective: proof that a defendant merely ought to have foreseen harm is insufficient.
For section 47, the prosecution had to prove intention or recklessness as to the assault, and that the assault caused actual bodily harm. It did not also have to prove that the defendant intended or foresaw bodily harm. In Savage’s case, the intentional throwing of beer supplied the assault, and the cut was a consequence of it. Section 47 was a permissible alternative verdict on the unlawful-wounding count.
The House dismissed Savage’s appeal, leaving her substituted section 47 conviction in place. It allowed the prosecution’s appeal in Parmenter’s case only to the extent of substituting four section 47 convictions for the quashed section 20 convictions.