Legal Case Summary
R v Prince (1875) LR 2 CCR 154
Mistake about age – statutory interpretation – abduction under section 55 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861
Facts
Henry Prince took Annie Phillips, an unmarried girl under sixteen, out of her father’s possession and against his will. She went willingly and had told Prince that she was eighteen. The jury accepted both that he honestly believed her and that his belief was reasonable: she appeared considerably older than sixteen.
Prince was convicted under section 55 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. That provision made it an offence unlawfully to take an unmarried girl under sixteen out of the possession, and against the will, of her parent or another person having lawful care or charge of her. Denman J reserved the legal question whether Prince’s reasonable mistake about her age provided a defence.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issue
Did section 55 require proof that Prince knew the girl was under sixteen, or could he be convicted despite an honest and reasonable belief that she was eighteen? The question concerned mistake about the statutory age limit, rather than whether he had deliberately taken her away.
Decision
The conviction was affirmed by fifteen judges, with Brett J dissenting. Prince’s honest and reasonable mistake about age was no defence to this offence. The majority judgments reached that conclusion through related but distinct approaches.
Why the majority upheld the conviction
Blackburn J, delivering a judgment supported by nine other judges, relied on the purpose and context of the legislation. Section 55 belonged to a group of provisions protecting women and the guardians of young women. In his view, Parliament intended liability to depend on the girl’s actual age, rather than the defendant’s estimate of it. He compared the neighbouring statutory age limits and the earlier legislation from which section 55 derived. On the case as reserved, Prince knew he was interfering with the father’s rights and had no other excuse for taking the girl.
Bramwell B emphasised the wrongfulness of knowingly taking a girl from another person’s care against that person’s will. He distinguished something being morally wrong from its necessarily being independently criminal. In construing this particular provision, he considered that someone who deliberately undertook the wrongful taking bore the risk that the girl was below the statutory age. His reasoning did not eliminate every possible mistake defence: he distinguished a belief that the father had consented, or ignorance that the girl was in anyone’s care.
Denman J, agreeing with both judgments, added that the word “unlawfully” mattered. It allowed for a lawful excuse or justification, such as authority from a competent court. A mistaken belief that the girl was eighteen did not, in his view, justify Prince’s knowing interference with her father’s custody.
Brett J’s dissent
Brett J would have quashed the conviction. He considered that an honest and reasonable mistake should excuse a defendant where the facts, if they had been as he believed them to be, would have made his conduct no criminal offence at all. On that approach, Prince’s belief that the girl was eighteen prevented the necessary criminal state of mind. Brett J distinguished this from deliberately committing an offence while being mistaken about a circumstance that made it more serious.
What the case establishes
The decision imposed strict liability as to the girl’s age under section 55. It should not be reduced to a general rule that statutory silence always removes the need for mens rea, or that any morally objectionable act is criminal. The disagreement concerned the construction of this offence and the effect of a reasonable factual mistake within it.
Original report: R v Prince (1875) LR 2 CCR 154.