Legal Case Summary
R v Quick and Paddison [1973] EWCA Crim 1; [1973] QB 910; [1973] 3 WLR 26; [1973] 3 All ER 347
Diabetes and defences – automatism or insanity in hypoglycaemia cases
Facts
The appellant (a nurse at a hospital) was a diabetic who suffered from hypoglycaemia (low blood sugar). He had taken insulin in the morning for his condition but had not eaten much during the day and had imbibed alcohol. The prosecution alleged that he attacked a patient, who suffered black eyes, bruising and a fractured nose. A witness described his collapse after the assault, and he said he had no recollection of the events. At trial he was charged with assault occasioning Actual Bodily Harm contrary to s.47 Offences Against The Person Act 1861. He had attempted to rely on the defence of automatism, but the trial judge ruled that only the defence of insanity would be available. Following that ruling, he pleaded guilty and was convicted.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
On appeal, the issue was whether Quick’s medical evidence permitted the defence of automatism to be left to the jury, or raised only the defence of insanity.
Decision / Outcome
Quick was entitled to have automatism left to the jury. His alleged mental condition, if it existed, was caused by the insulin prescribed by his doctor, an external factor, rather than by the underlying diabetes. The trial judge’s ruling was wrong, and Quick’s conviction was quashed as unsatisfactory. The court did not find automatism proved as a fact.
The court cautioned that self-induced incapacity, or incapacity which could reasonably have been foreseen from something done or omitted, would not excuse the conduct. The jury would have had to consider whether Quick’s condition resulted from hypoglycaemia or alcohol, whether he had followed advice about regular meals, and whether he recognised the episode and failed to take sugar as advised.
Paddison’s conviction for aiding and abetting was also quashed. The court recognised that an accomplice could in principle be guilty despite the principal’s acquittal, but found this verdict unsatisfactory on its particular facts: the allegation was that Paddison knew what Quick would do and encouraged him by clearing other patients out of the ward. If Quick acted without conscious volition, it was unlikely that Paddison knew what he intended to do.
Also reported at (1973) 57 Cr App R 722. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.