R v Wilson [1997] QB 47; [1996] 3 WLR 125; [1996] 2 Cr App R 241
Consent to actual bodily harm, personal adornment and the limits of R v Brown.
Facts
At his wife’s request, Alan Wilson used a hot knife to brand his initials on her buttocks. She had wanted a tattoo bearing his name, but he did not know how to tattoo. They agreed on branding as an alternative. A medical examination revealed the marks, including bruising and an incompletely healed burn.
Wilson admitted making the marks when interviewed by police. His account was undisputed, and his wife did not give evidence. He was prosecuted for assault occasioning actual bodily harm under section 47 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The trial judge considered that R v Brown and R v Donovan required him to rule that her consent was no defence. Following that ruling, Wilson gave no evidence and his counsel made no submissions to the jury. He was convicted and conditionally discharged for 12 months. He appealed against conviction.
Issue
Did Brown prevent reliance on consent whenever actual bodily harm was deliberately inflicted, or could the branding be treated in the same way as consensual tattooing?
Decision and reasoning
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and quashed the conviction. Russell LJ delivered the court’s judgment on 29 February 1996.
The court distinguished the facts from Donovan and Brown. Mrs Wilson had instigated the activity as well as consented to it. Her husband had no aggressive intent: he was helping her obtain what she regarded as personal adornment. The court did not equate that activity with the beatings or extreme sadomasochistic conduct in those cases.
Brown did not establish an absolute rule excluding consent in every prosecution under section 47 involving deliberate bodily harm. The speeches recognised exceptions, including tattooing performed with an adult’s consent. The Court of Appeal could see no logical distinction between the branding in this case and tattooing. It had no evidence entitling it to assume that the chosen method was more dangerous or painful.
The court also considered public policy. It concluded that criminal prosecution was not justified for this consensual activity between husband and wife in their home. Its reasoning depended on the circumstances, including the purpose of the act and the comparison with tattooing. It favoured development through individual cases rather than broad propositions.
Principle illustrated
The decision illustrates why the nature and context of the activity matter when assessing consent to bodily harm. Consent succeeded here because the court treated the branding as comparable to an accepted form of personal adornment. The judgment should not be reduced to a general rule that all consensual injury in private is lawful, or that the absence of extreme injury alone provides a defence.
Judgment: Read the reported Court of Appeal judgment.