Smith v Austin Lifts Ltd [1959] 1 WLR 100 concerned a lift fitter injured while entering a machine house on a customer’s premises. The House of Lords restored the judgment in his favour against both his employer and the occupiers.
Facts
Austin Lifts employed Smith and had contracted with the occupiers to maintain their lift. Its winding machinery was in a rooftop machine house reached by a fixed ladder. One of the entrance doors had a broken lower hinge. The employer had reported the defect to the occupiers on four occasions, but it remained unrepaired.
On an earlier visit, Smith had tied the doors together with wire because he could not secure them properly. When he returned on 14 May 1955, the right-hand door was open and the left-hand door had been wedged inside the machine house. Smith tugged the left door near its base and it appeared secure. However, when he grasped it higher up to pull himself into the opening, it gave way and he fell from the ladder.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Oliver J found both defendants liable. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision, disagreeing with the factual findings. Smith appealed to the House of Lords.
Why knowledge of the defect did not defeat the claim
The accident preceded the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957. The occupiers’ responsibility was considered under the common-law rules governing an occupier and an invitee.
Viscount Simonds distinguished the defective door Smith already knew about from the danger he encountered on his return. The door had been moved and wedged into a position which made it appear secure, although it could not safely support his weight. Simonds accepted the trial judge’s inference that the occupiers or their servant had altered its position. That alteration created an unusual danger for which the occupiers were responsible.
The important point was therefore the changed condition of the door. Knowing that its hinge was broken did not mean Smith appreciated the danger created by its apparently secure new position.
The employer’s responsibility
Austin Lifts’ responsibility was distinct from that of the occupiers. Sending an employee to somebody else’s premises did not remove the employer’s duty to take reasonable care for his safety.
Lord Denning explained that an employer must take reasonable care to provide a safe system of work and to protect employees against dangers on those premises which it knows, or ought to know, about. The precautions required depend on the circumstances. Here, the employer knew of the defective door and had repeatedly reported it.
The decision should not be reduced to an automatic requirement to inspect every customer’s premises. It concerned reasonable precautions in the circumstances of a known defect and the work the employee was required to undertake.
Decision
The House of Lords allowed Smith’s appeal, set aside the Court of Appeal’s order and restored Oliver J’s judgment. Both the employer and the occupiers remained liable. The House also ordered the appeal costs to be apportioned 20 per cent to Austin Lifts and 80 per cent to the occupiers.
Other citations: [1959] 1 All ER 81; [1958] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 583.
Sources: Smith v Austin Lifts Ltd, House of Lords, 18 December 1958; Lord Denning’s statement at page 117, reproduced in Berry v Ashtead Plant Hire Co Ltd [2011] EWCA Civ 1304.