St Albans City and District Council v International Computers Ltd [1996] EWCA Civ 1296; [1996] 4 All ER 481
Court of Appeal, 26 July 1996. Defective software, contractual liability limits and recoverable loss.
ICL supplied software which overstated the number of community-charge payers in St Albans. The Court of Appeal upheld its liability and the rejection of a £100,000 contractual cap. However, it reduced the damages because part of the council’s initial shortfall had subsequently been collected from chargepayers. The decision therefore concerned both the quality of contractual performance and the proper measure of compensation.
The contract and the software error
In December 1988 the council contracted with ICL for a computer system to administer the community charge. The agreement incorporated the council’s invitation to tender, ICL’s tender and ICL’s standard conditions. The community-charge program, COMCIS, was still being developed.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The council had to submit a population return by 8 December 1989. Figures extracted from the software on 4 December overstated the relevant population by 2,966. The council consequently set the charge too low, expecting to collect money from more chargepayers than there actually were.
The agreed losses comprised a £484,000 shortfall in community-charge receipts and £685,000 in net additional expenditure and funding adjustments. The latter figure included an increased county-council precept, but also reflected changes to grants and other contributions; it was not simply the amount of the extra precept. With interest, the trial judge awarded £1,314,846. ICL appealed.
What ICL had promised to provide
ICL argued that the council had accepted a system still under development and that it was not obliged to provide accurate figures in early December. The Court of Appeal rejected that interpretation.
Knowing that development was continuing did not mean that the council accepted software incapable of performing the function required at the relevant stage. The invitation to tender required a firm commitment to meet the statutory requirements for registration, billing, collection, recovery and financial management.
That commitment covered the population return, even though the particular requirement arose from legislation enacted after the original contract. Once ICL knew of the December deadline, it was expressly obliged to provide software enabling an accurate return.
The fault was ICL’s. A release prepared for the relevant statistics was not delivered, and a later release was installed only after the figures had been extracted. The council’s operation had in practice needed to take place over the preceding weekend. Installing a new release did not itself warn the council that its figures were wrong. The court also rejected arguments that subsequent discrepancies required it to take different action, taking account of ICL’s assurances.
Software and an implied fitness obligation
The express contractual promise was sufficient to establish liability. Sir Iain Glidewell nevertheless explained an alternative basis through an implied term.
He distinguished a physical disc from the intangible program recorded on it. The disc was goods within the relevant statutory definitions; the program itself was not. In his view, selling or hiring a disc carrying a defective program could engage statutory quality and fitness obligations. Here, however, ICL staff had transferred program releases into the council’s computer without transferring the discs themselves. That did not amount to a transfer of goods attracting those statutory terms.
That did not leave the council without protection. At common law, he would have implied a term that the program was reasonably capable of achieving the purpose both parties intended, absent an express term or contrary provision. Nourse LJ agreed with that alternative analysis. It should be distinguished from the express obligation on which the breach finding rested.
Why the liability cap failed
Clause 9(c) limited liability in the relevant category to the price of the item concerned or £100,000, whichever was lower. Section 3 of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 subjected that restriction to the requirement of reasonableness.
The council was not dealing as a consumer, but it had contracted on ICL’s written standard terms. ICL argued that negotiations prevented the council from having dealt on those terms. The court disagreed. Negotiations did not automatically prevent section 3 from applying, and the trial judge had found that ICL’s conditions remained effectively untouched.
That brought the cap within the statutory test; it did not automatically make the cap unreasonable. The trial judge had separately assessed reasonableness and rejected the clause. Applying George Mitchell (Chesterhall) Ltd v Finney Lock Seeds Ltd, the Court of Appeal would interfere only if that assessment involved an erroneous principle or was plainly and obviously wrong. It found no such error, and Nourse LJ said he would have reached the same conclusion.
Why some damages were reduced
The council’s ability to recover was not defeated by the argument that its inhabitants ultimately bore the loss. Although not strictly their trustee, it administered funds for their benefit and could recover damages on that basis.
The £685,000 net outgoing loss remained recoverable. Without the software fault, those additional outgoings would not have arisen. Passing their cost to chargepayers did not remove the underlying loss.
The £484,000 shortfall was different. Chargepayers paid in 1991/92 what they ought to have paid in 1990/91. Recovering that principal again from ICL would give them a benefit beyond compensation. The council could still recover interest for the year’s delay in receiving the money.
Outcome
The appeal succeeded only in part. ICL remained liable for breach, and the £100,000 cap remained unenforceable. The award was reduced by £484,000 and the interest on that sum for 1991/92. The £685,000 loss remained recoverable with interest, as did interest on the £484,000 for 1990/91. The judgment left consequential matters to a later hearing.
Source: Full judgment (BAILII).