Stockdale v Hansard  9 Ad & E1; 112 ER 1112
Privilege of a single House of Parliament and court’s authority to review privilege
During the course of a prison inspection, a pair of inspectors found a used copy of a book named On Diseases of the Generative System by John Roberton, which had been edited by John Joseph Stockdale (who was a known pornographer). Sometime later, Hansard published a report for the use of and by order of the House of Commons, which noted that this book was in circulation in Newgate prison. While this was normally only for internal consumption at the House of Commons, certain reforms lead to it being published to the public. In that report the book was treated not as a scientific text but as an obscene book. The report stated specifically: “This last is a book ” (meaning the said physiological and anatomical book) “of a most disgusting nature; and the plates are indecent and obscene in the extreme”. The claimant sued in libel. At trial he was unsuccessful. Hansard had argued that the publication is privileged since it was by the House of Commons, but this was not accepted by the court. However, the jury found that the publication had been indecent and obscene, which caused the claimant’s action to fail. The Claimant sued again however, the second time on the grounds of a response to the Hansard report by the city aldermen at Newgate who asserted the scientific nature of the book.
The issues in this case included whether each House of Parliaments is free to set the limits of their own privilege free from court interference.
The court held that an individual house of Parliament cannot make resolutions which are not subject to the authority of the courts. This is an authority reserved for the Crown in Parliament. In addition, the courts will in any event have the power to interpret the nature of the relevant privilege in cases where that privilege affects the rights of persons not connected to Parliament. The House of Commons could not therefore publish defamatory publications outside of Parliament (if the report had remained for internal consumption only this would not have amounted to libel). This case prompted the promulgation of the Parliamentary Papers Act 1840c. 9 (Regnal. 3_and_4_Vict) which laid out that publications made under the authority of the House of Commons will also be privileged.
“To speak of a contempt of the House, if “we assume to decide this question inconsistently with its determination,” argues what I should call, if the language had not been used by those whom I am bound to revere, a strange obliquity of understanding. The cause is before us; we are sworn to decide it according to our notions of the law; we do not bring it here; and, being here, a necessity is laid upon us to deliver judgment; that judgment we can receive at the dictation of no power: we may decide the cause erroneously; but we cannot be guilty of any contempt in deciding it according to our consciences” (Lord Denman CJ).
Cite This Work
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:
Related ServicesView all
Related ContentJurisdictions / Tags
Content relating to: "UK Law"
UK law covers the laws and legislation of England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. Essays, case summaries, problem questions and dissertations here are relevant to law students from the United Kingdom and Great Britain, as well as students wishing to learn more about the UK legal system from overseas.
The Calgarth 
The Calgarth was the stern tug of a large steam ship, the Otarama, which was assisting the larger vessel in entering onto the Manchester Ship Canal. Whilst manoeuvring, the Calgarth ran aground on the bank of the entrance channel to the canal which was constructed and maintained by the Canal Company. ...
Miscarriage of Justice Case: Sally Clark
This paper has looked at miscarriages of justice, specifically related to the case of Sally Clark and the expert witness evidence used in her trial. The paper has aimed to show that despite their increasing use expert witness come with inherent problems....