Willis v Hoare (1999) 77 P & CR D42
LAND LAW – PROPRIETARY ESTOPPEL – CERTAINTY OF INTEREST
Facts
The claimant was the head-tenant of a third-party’s land, and had granted a four-year sub-lease to the defendant. When the sub-lease expired, negotiations for a new lease broke down and the claimant sought possession of the land. The defendant argued that there was an understanding that the defendant would be offered a new sub-lease on the expiry of the existing sub-lease. However, there was no understanding as to what the terms of that new sub-lease would be.
Issues
Proprietary estoppel can arise where a person relies to their detriment on an assurance or encouragement concerning rights in land, in circumstances making it unconscionable to withdraw that assurance. The difficulty here was identifying what future right had been promised and what obligation the court could enforce.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The issue in this case was the degree of certainty which was required as to the proprietary interest the defendant believed himself to be entitled to.
Decision/Outcome
The Court of Appeal held in the claimant’s favour.
Auld LJ explained that uncertainty could affect both whether the conduct had caused the relevant detriment and whether its nature and extent allowed equity to devise an appropriate remedy. Those difficulties could overlap. The court could not overcome the problem simply by describing the conduct as unconscionable.
Chadwick LJ emphasised that, before restraining a party from exercising a clear legal right, the court had to be able to identify what that party must do to satisfy the claimed equity. An obligation which could not be defined could not fairly justify that restriction. An expectation of further negotiations, without sufficiently identifiable terms for the proposed sub-lease, did not supply an enforceable obligation in this case.
Judicial reference: Parker v Parker [2003] EWHC 1846 (Ch), paragraphs 229–231.