Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority
341 words (1 pages) Case Summary
29th Sep 2021 Case Summary Reference this In-house law team
Jurisdiction / Tag(s): UK Law
Legal Case Summary
Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority  AC 1074
Claimant always holds the burden of proving likely causation
An infant was delivered prematurely and shortly after was administered oxygen by a junior doctor, accidentally providing too much. The baby was later diagnosed with a retinal condition, which severely limited his sight. Five potential causes or factors were identified to explain the condition, four relating to his premature birth and the fifth being the junior doctor’s actions.
Whether the health authority for which the junior doctor worked could be held liable for his actions where it could not be definitively stated what the chief cause of the injury was. Moreover, should a junior doctor be held to the same professional standards as a fully qualified doctor. Further, should the burden of proof regarding the potential relationship between the negligent actions and the injuries fall to the claimant or the defendant.
At first instance the Court found the defendant, Essex Area Health Authority, liable for the infant’s injuries, citing McGhee v National Coal Board  1 WLR 1 as laying down the precedent that where there existed a plurality of possible causes, the burden fell to the defendant to prove that their actions had not been the but for or material cause of the injury.
The House of Lords subsequently allowed the defendant’s appeal and overturned the first instance judgment stating that whilst the health authority could be held liable for the junior doctor’s actions as junior doctors owed the same duty of care as a fully qualified doctor, the case of McGhee had been wrongly interpreted at first instance; regardless of the number of potential causes of injury, it always falls to the claimant to establish the likelihood of causation.
Cite This Work
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:
Related ServicesView all
Related ContentJurisdictions / Tags
Content relating to: "UK Law"
UK law covers the laws and legislation of England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. Essays, case summaries, problem questions and dissertations here are relevant to law students from the United Kingdom and Great Britain, as well as students wishing to learn more about the UK legal system from overseas.
Introduction of The Supreme Court in UK
The introduction of the Supreme Court in United Kingdom originated from constitutional reform which was proposed in 2003.The government abolished ......
A Critical Review of the Key Features, Personnel, Philosophy …
The Engineering and Construction Contract (ECC) is the third edition published by the Institution of Civil Engineers which is also referred to as t......