Scenario examining offer and acceptance for the sale of goods.
Example Contract Law Problem Question
Question
Due to petrol prices increasing dramatically in recent months, Aaron decides to sell his limited edition Range Rover Sport, and is considering buying a smaller vehicle. Aaron places an advertisement in his car window on 1st June stating:
‘Range Rover excellent condition, one owner £25,000 or nearest offer. Please contact Aaron on 07856953214 (evening) or 0205 4785 2365(during office hours 9-5pm).’
Scott (Aaron’s neighbour) on seeing the advert earlier that day, decides to contact Aaron that evening, and arranges to inspect the vehicle. After inspecting the vehicle Scott states that he will contact him, if he’s still interested.
Law Teacher writing support
Working on a law problem question?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us the scenario and any marking criteria. We’ll write an answer to your instructions, identifying the legal issues and applying the law to the facts.
On 3rd June, Chloe calls Aaron’s mobile number after inspecting the vehicle (the previous day), and offers £24,500. Aaron is delighted and says ‘how about £24,750?’ Chloe states that she will need to discuss this with her husband, Aaron tells her to call back at 6pm.
Chloe contacts Aaron on his mobile phone at 7.30pm; however the phone is switched off. As there is no facility to leave a message, Chloe tries his work number the following day, however Aaron is at a conference so she leaves a message on his answering machine, stating that she definitely wants the Range Rover for £24,750. Aaron doesn’t return to his desk until late that afternoon and fails to listen to his answering machine that day. Chloe then tries his mobile in the evening but it’s still switched off.
Vish, a dedicated car dealer, contacts Aaron on 4th June, on his mobile phone, stating that he’s really interested in the vehicle, and arranges to meet Aaron during his lunch break to inspect the vehicle. Aaron meets Vish, and accepts an offer of £26,000 from Vish.
Aaron is delighted with the sale and decides to purchase a pair of Gucci shoes. When he enters the shop, he sees a price tag by a pair of Gucci shoes for £89. He’s always wanted a pair but could never afford them, so thinking that the shoes are on sale, attempts to purchase them. When he gets to the till point, the cashier scans the barcode on the box and informs Aaron that the shoes are £210. Aaron refuses to pay £210, and demands he should have the shoes for £89.
Scott and Chloe contact Aaron the next day (5th June) demanding the vehicle for the advertised price.
Advise Aaron.
Answer
Aaron’s concern is that he may have formed an agreement with either Scott or Chloe for the car’s sale, prior to accepting Vish’s offer. If either agreement was binding and Aaron does not deliver the car, he may be liable for breach of contract.
Advertisements offering goods for sale, like Aaron’s sign in his car window, are usually invitations to treat. In Partridge v Crittenden[1] the defendant advertised bramblefinch hens and cocks for 25 shillings each. He was prosecuted under the Protection of Birds Act 1954 for offering a restricted bird for sale. One of his defences was that the advertisement was not an offer but an invitation to treat. The court agreed. A sufficiently definite advertisement can be an offer if it shows an intention to be bound on performance of its conditions, as in Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co[18]. In the United States, the Supreme Court of Minnesota applied similar reasoning in Lefkowitz v Great Minneapolis Surplus Store, Inc[2]. The store advertised fur items for $1 each on a first-come, first-served basis. The claimant arrived first and was refused the advertised goods because the store said its offer was for women only. The court held that the advertisement was sufficiently clear and definite to be an offer and that the store could not add a condition after acceptance.
Aaron’s advertisement is likely to be considered an invitation to treat following Partridge v Crittenden[3]. If a shopkeeper’s advertisement were an offer capable of acceptance by several buyers, the shopkeeper could become liable to supply more goods than were in stock. Here Aaron has one car and his words ‘or nearest offer’ indicate that bargaining may take place.
An offer is “An expression of willingness to contract on specified terms, made with the intention that it is to become binding as soon as it is accepted by the person to whom it is addressed.”[4] Scott’s statement after inspecting the vehicle, that he would contact Aaron if he was still interested, did not make an offer.
On 3rd June Chloe makes an offer on the car, after inspecting it. Aaron does not accept her offer of £24,500. His reply, ‘how about £24,750?’, is likely to be a counter-offer, though a mere enquiry would not reject Chloe’s offer. Under Hyde v Wrench[5], a counter-offer rejects the original offer, which cannot then be accepted unless renewed. Aaron tells Chloe to call back at 6pm. If a reasonable person would understand that as a deadline for acceptance or as prescribing a call at that time as the only valid means of acceptance, Chloe missed it and no contract was made. If it was simply a convenient time to speak, the counter-offer could remain open for a reasonable time[19].
If the counter-offer remained open, Chloe’s acceptance of £24,750 had to be communicated to Aaron. ‘Acceptance is a final and unqualified expression of assent to the terms of the offer.’[6] It is generally effective on communication to the offeror[7]. Where the postal rule applies, acceptance takes effect when the letter is posted[8], provided that use of the post was within the parties’ contemplation[9]. It does not apply here. In Entores v Miles Far East Corp[10] the Court of Appeal held that acceptance by instantaneous communication takes effect on receipt. The House of Lords followed Entores in Brinkibon[11]. It did not set fixed hours for the receipt of messages. In The Brimnes[12], a telex notice of withdrawal of a ship was effective when it could reasonably have been read in the recipient’s office, even though it was not read then. Lord Wilberforce in Brinkibon[13] said that cases about the receipt of messages are to be resolved by considering:
- The intention of the parties.
- Sound business practice.
- Where the risk lies.
Applied to the scenario:
- Aaron invited contact by telephone and gave his work number for use between 9am and 5pm. Chloe’s call to the switched-off mobile on 3 June did not communicate acceptance.
- Chloe’s message on the work answering machine on 4 June expressed an unqualified acceptance. The facts do not say when she left it. Aaron’s attendance at a conference does not fix the time of receipt.
- If the counter-offer was still open and the message was available at a time when Aaron could reasonably be expected to check the answering machine, his failure to listen to it need not prevent acceptance. If she used the work number outside the stated hours, or if it was not reasonable to expect Aaron to check it until later, acceptance may have taken effect later, if at all.
In Brinkibon, the parties were companies in different countries and the dispute concerned a contract for 20,000 metric tonnes of steel bars[14]. The same approach to receipt can help decide when Chloe’s voicemail took effect, but it must be applied to this private sale. In Thomas v BPE Solicitors, the High Court applied Brinkibon to an email and treated the hours when it was reasonable to expect receipt as a question of context[15]. On these facts, the time Chloe left her message and when it was reasonable for Aaron to check it matter.
On the facts, Vish made an offer of £26,000, which Aaron accepted. There was consideration and an intention to create legal relations. If Chloe’s voicemail took effect while Aaron’s counter-offer was still open, Aaron could be bound under both agreements. Merely agreeing to sell to Vish did not communicate a withdrawal to Chloe. There is no evidence that she learned of that agreement before her voicemail could take effect. If her message was ineffective, her demand on 5 June for the advertised price did not accept the £24,750 counter-offer. Scott’s demand to buy at the advertised price could only be an offer, and Aaron did not accept it[20].
Under the Sale of Goods Act 1979, ownership of this specific car generally passes when an unconditional contract is made if the car is in a deliverable state, unless the parties intended ownership to pass at a different time. If title passed to Chloe first, Vish could still acquire good title if Aaron retained possession and delivered the car to him and Vish received it in good faith without notice of the earlier sale. The facts do not say that any delivery took place. A buyer to whom Aaron wrongfully fails to deliver the car may claim damages for non-delivery and may ask for specific performance, which is discretionary. The limited edition may make a replacement harder to obtain[21].
Aaron thinks he is entitled to buy the shoes at the displayed price of £89.
The general rule is that displaying priced goods in a shop window is an invitation to treat, inviting customers to make offers[16]. In Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemists (Southern) Ltd[17], the Society brought an action alleging that a self-service chemist sold products containing listed poisons without the required supervision. The Court of Appeal held that the customer made an offer at the till, where a pharmacist could supervise the sale and prevent it if necessary. The same reasoning applies to Aaron’s shoes. He can offer £89 but the cashier can refuse the offer. As Aaron declined to pay £210, no contract was made. The shop must indicate the selling price clearly and unambiguously under the Price Marking Order 2004. The displayed price could also be a misleading commercial practice if it was false or deceptive and likely to cause the average consumer to take a different transactional decision. That includes the decision to take the shoes to the till. The rules on unfair commercial practices in the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 have applied since 6 April 2025 and do not give Aaron a right to buy the shoes for £89[22].
Footnotes
[1] Partridge v Crittenden [1968] 1 WLR 1204.
[2] Lefkowitz v Great Minneapolis Surplus Store, Inc, 86 NW 2d 689 (Minn 1957).
[3] Partridge v Crittenden [1968] 1 WLR 1204.
[4] Edwin Peel, Treitel: The Law of Contract (Sweet & Maxwell 2007).
[5] Hyde v Wrench (1840) 49 ER 132.
[6] Edwin Peel, Treitel: The Law of Contract (Sweet & Maxwell 2007).
[7] Taylor v Laird (1856) 156 ER 1203.
[8] Adams v Lindsell (1818) 106 ER 250.
[9] Henthorn v Fraser [1892] 2 Ch 27.
[10] Entores Ltd v Miles Far East Corporation [1955] 2 QB 327.
[11] Brinkibon Ltd v Stahag Stahl und Stahlwarenhandelsgesellschaft mbH [1982] 2 WLR 264 (HL).
[12] Tenax Steamship Co Ltd v The Brimnes (Owners) [1974] 3 WLR 613 (CA).
[13] Brinkibon [1983] 2 AC 34, 42 (Lord Wilberforce); [1982] 2 WLR 264.
[14] Brinkibon Ltd v Stahag Stahl und Stahlwarenhandelsgesellschaft mbH 1980 WL 148456, 3.
[15] Brinkibon [1982] 2 WLR 264; Thomas v BPE Solicitors [2010] EWHC 306 (Ch), [90].
[16] Fisher v Bell [1960] 3 WLR 919.
[17] Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemists (Southern) Ltd [1953] 2 WLR 427.
[18] Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256.
[19] Stevenson, Jaques & Co v McLean (1880) 5 QBD 346; Manchester Diocesan Council for Education v Commercial and General Investments Ltd [1970] 1 WLR 241, 246; Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co v Montefiore (1866) LR 1 Ex 109.
[20] Dickinson v Dodds (1876) 2 Ch D 463.
[21] Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 17, 18, 21, 24, 51 and 52.
[22] Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, ss 225, 226 and 245; SI 2025/272; Price Marking Order 2004, arts 4 and 7.
Last updated: 13 November 2026