Last updated: 10 November 2026
These notes concern criminal appeals in England and Wales.
APPEAL FOLLOWING SUMMARY TRIAL
FROM THE MAGISTRATES’ COURT
A) TO THE CROWN COURT
If the defendant entered a valid guilty plea, an appeal lies from the magistrates’ court to the Crown Court against sentence only. If the defendant pleaded not guilty, he can appeal to the Crown Court against either conviction or sentence or both (s108(1) Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980).
An appeal against conviction to the Crown Court takes the form of a complete rehearing of the case with witnesses but without a jury. An appeal against sentence concerns the sentence only. Permission to appeal is not required. For a conviction appeal, notice must normally be served within 15 business days after sentence, an order deferring sentence, or committal for sentence, whichever is earlier. For a sentence appeal, time runs from sentence. An extension of time may be sought (Criminal Procedure Rules 2025, r34.2).
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Powers of the Crown Court
The Crown Court has power to confirm, reverse or vary the decision under appeal, or to remit the case with its opinion thereon to the magistrates’ court which made the decision (s48(2) Senior Courts Act 1981). If the appeal is decided against the accused, the Crown Court has power to impose any sentence which the magistrates’ court could have imposed. This power is wide enough to allow the imposition of a punishment which is more severe, as well as one which is less severe, than that actually inflicted by the magistrates’ court (s48(4) Senior Courts Act 1981).
Further appeal
A further appeal lies, at the instance of either the defence or the prosecution, from the decision of the Crown Court by way of case stated to the Divisional Court of the King’s Bench Division, but only on the grounds that the decision is wrong in law or was given in excess of jurisdiction (s28(1) Senior Courts Act 1981).
B) TO THE KING’S BENCH DIVISIONAL COURT
As an alternative to appealing to the Crown Court, an appeal may sometimes be taken direct to the King’s Bench Divisional Court by way of case stated from the magistrates’ court. Either the defence or the prosecution may take advantage of this procedure where it is alleged that the justices’ decision is wrong in law or was given in excess of jurisdiction (s111(1) Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980).
Procedure
The procedure by way of case stated is set in motion when either the defendant or the prosecutor makes written application to the magistrates’ court to ‘state a case’ for the opinion of the Divisional Court. The application must be made within 21 days after the decision; where sentencing follows an adjournment after conviction, time runs from sentence. Making the application ends the applicant’s right to appeal that decision to the Crown Court (s111(2)–(4)). The application must include a statement of the point of law on which the opinion of the Divisional Court is required. The case stated by the magistrates will usually include a statement of the original information laid against the defendant, the facts as found by the justices, the submissions of the parties, the cases cited (if any), the decision of the justices and the question for decision by the Divisional Court.
The magistrates can refuse a competent application to state a case if in their opinion the application is frivolous, but not if it is made by or under the direction of the Attorney-General. However, refusal to state a case may enable the applicant to seek, by way of judicial review, an order to compel the magistrates to state a case (s111(5) and (6) Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980).
An appeal to the Divisional Court is not a rehearing. The case is decided on the documents and after considering arguments on points of law put forward by counsel for the parties.
Powers of the K.B.D.C.
The Divisional Court may affirm, reverse or amend the magistrates’ decision, or remit the case to the magistrates’ court with its opinion, or make such other order in relation to the matter, including costs, as it thinks fit, eg order a re-hearing by the same or a different bench (s28A Senior Courts Act 1981, replacing s6 Summary Jurisdiction Act 1857).
C) POWERS OF MAGISTRATES’ COURTS TO RE-OPEN CASES TO RECTIFY MISTAKES
A magistrates’ court may vary or rescind a sentence or other order imposed or made by it when dealing with an offender if it appears to the court to be in the interests of justice to do so (s142(1) Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980, as amended by s26 Criminal Appeal Act 1995). Where a conviction should be reconsidered in the interests of justice, the court may direct a rehearing before different justices (s142(2)). These powers cannot be used after the relevant conviction or sentence has been determined on appeal to the Crown Court or by the High Court on a case stated.
D) TAINTED ACQUITTALS
Section 54 of the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996 provides that where a defendant has been acquitted of an offence, and a person has been convicted of an administration of justice offence involving interference with or intimidation of a juror or a witness (or potential witness) in proceedings which led to the acquittal, the High Court must grant an order quashing the acquittal if the certification requirement and the four conditions below are satisfied. Proceedings may then be taken against the acquitted person for the offence of which he was acquitted (s54(4)). This procedure applies where that offence is alleged to have been committed on or after 15 April 1997.
Where it appears to the court before which the person is convicted of an administration of justice offence that (a) there is a real possibility that, but for the interference or intimidation, the acquitted person would not have been acquitted, and (b) it would not be contrary to the interests of justice to take proceedings against the acquitted person for the offence of which he was acquitted, the court shall certify that it so appears (s54(2)).
An application may then be made to the High Court for an order quashing the acquittal if the four conditions in s55 are satisfied (s54(3)). The conditions for making an order, in s55, are:
(1) It appears to the High Court likely that, but for the interference or intimidation, the acquitted person would not have been acquitted.
(2) It does not appear to the Court that, because of lapse of time or for any other reason, it would be contrary to the interests of justice to take proceedings against the acquitted person for the offence of which he was acquitted.
(3) It appears to the Court that the acquitted person has been given a reasonable opportunity to make written representations to the Court.
(4) It appears to the Court that the conviction for the administration of justice offence will stand.
FROM THE K.B.D.C. TO THE SUPREME COURT
A further appeal may be taken by either party from the King’s Bench Divisional Court to the Supreme Court. This is so whether the case reached the Divisional Court via the Crown Court or direct from the magistrates’ court. But the appeal to the Supreme Court will only be possible if:
(a) the Divisional Court has certified that the case involves a point of law of general public importance; and
(b) the Divisional Court or the Supreme Court has given leave to appeal on it appearing that the point is one which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court (s1 Administration of Justice Act 1960).
Procedure in the Supreme Court
An appeal to the Supreme Court is normally heard by an uneven number of judges, numbering at least three. In practice, five of them usually sit together to form a court. Each judge may deliver his own separate judgment. The hearing of the appeal is not a retrial. The judges read the documents in the case and listen to counsel’s arguments; fresh evidence requires the Court’s permission. The majority decision prevails. The Supreme Court may exercise any powers of the court below or remit the case to that court (s1(4) Administration of Justice Act 1960).
APPEAL FOLLOWING TRIAL ON INDICTMENT
FROM THE CROWN COURT TO THE COURT OF APPEAL
A) APPEALS BY THE DEFENDANT
(i) Appeal against conviction
The defendant may appeal against conviction on indictment in the Crown Court to the Court of Appeal, criminal division, with leave of the Court of Appeal or a certificate from the trial judge that the case is fit for appeal. The certificate must be granted within 28 days of conviction. These requirements apply whether the grounds concern law, fact, or both (s1 Criminal Appeal Act 1968, as amended by the Criminal Appeal Act 1995). Notice of appeal or application for leave must normally be served within 28 days of conviction; an extension may be sought (Criminal Procedure Rules 2025, rr36.3 and 39.2).
Where leave is required it may be granted by a single judge of the Court of Appeal. If the single judge refuses leave, the appellant can have his application considered by the court itself (s31 Criminal Appeal Act 1968).
Procedure in the Court of Appeal
The actual appeal against conviction must be heard by at least three judges in the Court of Appeal. The hearing of appeal by the Court of Appeal is not a retrial. The appeal is determined after reading the documents in the case and hearing counsel’s arguments, together with any fresh evidence admitted under s23 Criminal Appeal Act 1968. In the criminal division, normally only one judgement is delivered, either by the presiding judge or by another member of the court on his direction. Separate judgements can be delivered in the criminal division only where the presiding judge states that in his opinion the case involves a question of law on which it is convenient that separate judgements should be pronounced. This rule is designed to prevent the regular recording of dissenting judgements on the criminal law where certainty is of especial importance.
Powers of the Court of Appeal
The Court of Appeal’s powers to dispose of an appeal are mainly set out in s2(1) of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968 (as amended by the Criminal Appeal Act 1995).
The Court of Appeal:
(a) shall allow an appeal against conviction if they think that the conviction is unsafe; and
(b) shall dismiss such an appeal in any other case.
Proviso Power
Section 2(1) also contained, before it was abolished by the Criminal Appeal Act 1995, what was known as the “proviso”: “that the court may, notwithstanding that they are of opinion that the point raised in the appeal might be decided in favour of the appellant, dismiss the appeal if they consider that no miscarriage of justice has actually occurred.” It seems from the decided cases that the proviso would be applied mainly where the Court of Appeal considered that a properly directed jury would have reached the same verdict of guilty; or where a material irregularity (such as the admission in evidence of an inadmissible confession or hearsay) did not produce a miscarriage of justice.
Substitute Convictions
The Court of Appeal has an additional power. Where the jury could have found the defendant guilty of some other offence, and must have been satisfied of the facts proving him guilty of that other offence, the court may substitute a conviction of that other offence and sentence the defendant accordingly, provided that the substituted sentence is not more severe (s3(1)–(2) Criminal Appeal Act 1968).
Fresh Evidence
At the hearing of an appeal, the Court of Appeal has power to admit fresh evidence (even though it was available but not called at the trial) if to do so is necessary or expedient in the interests of justice (s23(1) Criminal Appeal Act 1968). Admission is discretionary. In deciding whether to receive the evidence, the Court must have regard in particular to:
(a) whether the evidence appears capable of belief; (b) whether it may afford any ground for allowing the appeal; (c) whether it would have been admissible at the trial on an issue which is the subject of the appeal; and (d) whether there is a reasonable explanation for the failure to adduce it at the trial (s23(2) Criminal Appeal Act 1968, as amended by the Criminal Appeal Act 1995).
Retrial
The Court of Appeal also has a general power to order a retrial. This discretion is not limited to fresh evidence cases but is exercisable whenever the Court of Appeal allows an appeal against conviction under s2(1) of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968 and the interests of justice require the defendant to be retried (s7 Criminal Appeal Act 1968).
(ii) Appeal against sentence
The defendant may appeal against the sentence of the Crown Court (other than a sentence fixed by law), to the Court of Appeal with leave of the Court of Appeal (ss9(1) and 11(1) Criminal Appeal Act 1968).
Leave may be granted by a single judge of that court or, if he refuses it, by the full court. Leave of the Court of Appeal to appeal against sentence is not required if the Crown Court judge who passed the sentence grants, within 28 days of sentence, a certificate that the case is fit for appeal against sentence (ibid.). Notice of appeal or application for leave must normally be served within 28 days of sentence, subject to an extension of time (Criminal Procedure Rules 2025, rr36.3 and 39.2). A mandatory life sentence itself is fixed by law, but its minimum term may be appealed (s9(1A)).
The actual appeal against sentence only may be heard by two judges. On an appeal by the defendant against sentence, the Court of Appeal may quash the sentence and substitute any lawful sentence which it considers appropriate, but must ensure that, taking the case as a whole, the defendant is not dealt with more severely (s11(3) Criminal Appeal Act 1968). The Court of Appeal will not interfere merely because it would have passed a different sentence: the sentence must be unlawful, wrong in principle or manifestly excessive.
B) THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL’S REFERENCE
The prosecution has no ordinary right of appeal against a jury’s acquittal on indictment. Statutory exceptions concerning tainted acquittals and new and compelling evidence are considered below. The prosecution may also appeal certain rulings made before the judge begins summing up to the jury, with leave of the trial judge or the Court of Appeal, under Part 9 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003; this requires an agreement to acquittal on the affected charges if leave is not obtained or the appeal is abandoned before determination. Separate statutory appeals are available against specified rulings at preparatory hearings (s9 Criminal Justice Act 1987 and s35 Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996). There is also provision for a “reference” to be made by the Attorney-General following an acquittal. By s36(1) of the Criminal Justice Act 1972:
The Attorney-General may, if he desires the opinion of the Court of Appeal on a point of law which has arisen in the case, refer that point to the court, and the court shall, in accordance with this section, consider the point and give their opinion on it.
The acquittal of the defendant is not affected by the opinion of the Court of Appeal. The Attorney-General’s reference to the Court of Appeal is a useful procedure for clearing up doubtful points in the criminal law, where certainty is particularly important. The Court of Appeal may refer the point of law to the Supreme Court if of the opinion that it ought to be considered there (s36(3) Criminal Justice Act 1972).
C) THE A-G’S REFERENCE OF UNDULY LENIENT SENTENCES
The prosecution has no general right to appeal to the Court of Appeal against the sentence imposed on the defendant. The Attorney-General’s power to refer an unduly lenient sentence applies to indictable-only offences and specified either-way offences sentenced in the Crown Court (s35 Criminal Justice Act 1988). By s36(1) of that Act:
If it appears to the Attorney-General … that the sentencing of a person in a proceeding in the Crown Court has been unduly lenient … he may, with the leave of the Court of Appeal, refer the case to them for them to review the sentencing of that person; and on such a reference the Court of Appeal may-
(i) quash any sentence passed on him in the proceeding; and
(ii) in place of it pass such sentence as they think appropriate for the case and as the court below had power to pass when dealing with him.
Notice of the application for leave must normally be given within 28 days from the day when the sentence, or the last of the sentences in the case, was passed. Since 29 June 2026, where the Attorney-General receives the first request to review the sentence in the last 14 days of that period, notice may instead be given within 14 days from receipt of that request (Schedule 3, paragraph 1, Criminal Justice Act 1988, as amended by s13 Victims and Courts Act 2026). The Court of Appeal has power to increase or decrease the sentence. The time spent by the defendant in custody pending the outcome of the review is taken into account. The term of any sentence of imprisonment imposed by the Court of Appeal as a result of the review begins to run, unless otherwise directed, from the time when it would have begun to run if passed originally by the Crown Court.
TAINTED ACQUITTALS
Section 54 of the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996 provides that where a defendant has been acquitted of an offence, and a person has been convicted of an administration of justice offence involving interference with or intimidation of a juror or a witness (or potential witness) in proceedings which led to the acquittal, the High Court must grant an order quashing the acquittal if the certification requirement and the four conditions below are satisfied. Proceedings may then be taken against the acquitted person for the offence of which he was acquitted (s54(4)). This procedure applies where that offence is alleged to have been committed on or after 15 April 1997.
Where it appears to the court before which the person is convicted of an administration of justice offence that (a) there is a real possibility that, but for the interference or intimidation, the acquitted person would not have been acquitted, and (b) it would not be contrary to the interests of justice to take proceedings against the acquitted person for the offence of which he was acquitted, the court shall certify that it so appears (s54(2)).
An application may then be made to the High Court for an order quashing the acquittal if the four conditions in s55 are satisfied (s54(3)). The conditions for making an order, in s55, are:
(1) It appears to the High Court likely that, but for the interference or intimidation, the acquitted person would not have been acquitted.
(2) It does not appear to the Court that, because of lapse of time or for any other reason, it would be contrary to the interests of justice to take proceedings against the acquitted person for the offence of which he was acquitted.
(3) It appears to the Court that the acquitted person has been given a reasonable opportunity to make written representations to the Court.
(4) It appears to the Court that the conviction for the administration of justice offence will stand.
RETRIAL FOR SERIOUS OFFENCES
Part 10 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 provides a further exception to the rule against double jeopardy for qualifying serious offences listed in Schedule 5. With the written consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions, a prosecutor may apply to the Court of Appeal to quash an acquittal and order a retrial. There must be new and compelling evidence and a retrial must be in the interests of justice. Evidence is new if it was not adduced in the earlier proceedings; it is compelling if it is reliable, substantial and highly probative of the case against the acquitted person. The Court must consider the possibility of a fair trial, delay and whether investigators or prosecutors failed to act with due diligence or expedition (ss76–79). This procedure can apply to acquittals predating the 2003 Act.
FROM THE COURT OF APPEAL TO THE SUPREME COURT
A further appeal may be taken by either the defendant or the prosecutor from the Court of Appeal, criminal division, to the Supreme Court. But this appeal will only be possible if:
(a) the Court of Appeal has certified that the case involves a point of law of general public importance; and
(b) the Court of Appeal or the Supreme Court has given leave to appeal on it appearing that the point is one which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court (s33(2) Criminal Appeal Act 1968). Where the prosecutor appeals and the defendant would remain liable to detention but for the Court of Appeal’s decision, the Court must order detention or release on bail, or release without bail if the statutory interests-of-justice test is met (s37 Criminal Appeal Act 1968).
Procedure in the Supreme Court
An appeal to the Supreme Court is normally heard by an uneven number of judges, numbering at least three. In practice, five of them usually sit together to form a court. Each judge may deliver his own separate judgment. The hearing of the appeal is not a retrial. The judges read the documents in the case and listen to counsel’s arguments; fresh evidence requires the Court’s permission. The majority decision prevails. The Supreme Court may exercise the same powers as those exercised by the Court of Appeal or remit the case to it (s35(3) Criminal Appeal Act 1968).
CRIMINAL CASES REVIEW COMMISSION
Before 31 March 1997, any person convicted on indictment could at any time apply to the Home Secretary, under s17 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968, asking him to refer the case for review by the Court of Appeal. Without such an application, the Home Secretary could still refer the case to the Court of Appeal at any time on his own initiative. The Home Secretary could refer the whole case or “any point arising in the case” (eg, the sentence imposed at first instance). It was possible for the Home Secretary to refer a case for review under this procedure even though there had already been an unsuccessful appeal. Although no such limitation was specified in s17 itself, the Home Office had a practice of referring cases only if there was fresh evidence or a new consideration of substance which might affect the safety of the conviction.
The Criminal Appeal Act 1995 repealed s17. The Criminal Cases Review Commission took over responsibility for referring possible miscarriages of justice to the Court of Appeal, on March 31 1997. The powers of the Commission (under the 1995 Act) include the following:
(a) At any time to refer to the Court of Appeal the conviction and/or sentence of any person convicted on indictment in the Crown Court, excluding a sentence fixed by law (s9). The Commission can also refer verdicts of not guilty by reason of insanity and findings of unfitness to plead and that the person did the act or made the omission charged (s9(5)–(6)).
(b) At any time to refer to the Crown Court the conviction and/or sentence of any person convicted by a magistrates’ court (s11). On such a reference, the Crown Court cannot impose a more severe punishment (s11(6)).
(c) To investigate matters referred to it by the Court of Appeal (s23A Criminal Appeal Act 1968, see below).
(d) To consider any matter referred to it by the Secretary of State for Justice in connection with the exercise of the prerogative of mercy (s16).
A reference requires a real possibility that the conviction, verdict, finding or sentence would not be upheld. Normally, there must be an argument or evidence not previously raised (for a sentence, an argument on a point of law or information), and an appeal must already have been determined or leave refused. Exceptional circumstances can justify dispensing with the prior-appeal requirement and, for a conviction, verdict or finding, the new-argument-or-evidence requirement (s13 Criminal Appeal Act 1995).
On an appeal against conviction or an application for leave to appeal against conviction, the Court of Appeal is able to direct the Commission to investigate and report on any matter if: (i) the matter is relevant and ought, if possible, to be resolved before the appeal or application is decided; (ii) the matter is likely to be resolved by the court as a result of the Commission’s investigation; and (iii) the matter cannot be resolved without an investigation by the Commission. A single judge cannot give this direction (s23A Criminal Appeal Act 1968).