Disclaimer: This problem question has been written by a law student and not by our expert law writers. View examples of our professional work here.

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not reflect the views of LawTeacher.net. You should not treat any information in this problem question as being authoritative.

Job Termination, Sick Pay and Reviews

Info: 3,604 words (15 pages) Problem Question Example
Published: 02 Feb 2018

Reference this

Jurisdiction / Tag(s): UK Law

Scenarios including job termination, sick pay and reviews.

Question

Peter started work at The Beach House, a five-star restaurant in Oxford, in November 2007 as a waiter. He was good at his job and was rapidly promoted to become the senior waiter.

The Beach House prided itself on providing a healthy working environment for its employees. However, in the spring of 2014 there was a shortage of competent waiting staff and Peter became very stressed due to overwork. The working relation was not helped by a difficult relationship with the restaurant manager, Mr Rico. Peter developed stress-induced eczema and took six weeks’ unpaid leave to visit his parents in Germany.

Law Teacher writing support

Working on a law problem question?

We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.

Send us the scenario and any marking criteria. We’ll write an answer to your instructions, identifying the legal issues and applying the law to the facts.

On his return his difficulties continued. He burnt his hand whilst serving a customer and was off for three weeks but received no sick pay. Peter repeatedly asked Mr Rico about it but he refused to authorise it.

Company policy required a six-monthly appraisal for each employee. Peter has not had one for the last two years. Whenever he asked Mr Rico about it he was always met with excuses.

At the beginning of December 2014, during a busy shift, Peter removed a pre-purchased but unopened bottle of wine from a table which had just been vacated by a party of diners and took it to the kitchen. He was confronted by the assistant manager and told that he should have obtained permission to do this and received a written warning about his conduct.

At the end of January 2015 Peter was confronted by Mr Rico when eating food from the metal cooking tray he was taking to the washing up station in the kitchen. He was told that it was a new rule that staff were not to eat in the kitchen during working hours. Peter lost his temper and, using a few choice expletives, shouted that he had not been told about the new rules and anyway other staff had eaten food during work time and had not been reprimanded.

Peter was sent home immediately. The next day he received a phone call from Mr Rico telling him not to come back to work as he was being dismissed for gross misconduct.

Advise Peter on whether he can bring any claims against his employer and what remedies he would be entitled to if successful.

Answer

Peter, a former Senior Waiter at The Beach House (“BH”), requires advice on claims he could bring against BH, and the remedies he would be entitled to, if successful. Peter’s employment commenced in November 2007. He was summarily dismissed at the end of January 2015 for alleged gross misconduct. The claims are assessed under the law applicable to the events in 2014 and 2015.

Qualification on period of employment

As will be shown below, Peter’s period of employment affects the claims he is entitled to bring in the Employment Tribunal. It also affects the amount he is entitled to recover in remedy in both the Tribunal and civil courts. Factors affecting his period of employment will therefore be discussed at the outset.

Section 212 (1) Employment Rights Act 1996 (“ERA”) states “any week during the whole or part of which an employee’s relations with his employer are covered by a contract of employment counts in computing the employee’s period of employment”.

In spring 2014, Peter developed stress-induced eczema due to overwork and took six weeks’ unpaid leave to visit his parents in Germany. He also had three weeks’ leave following an injury at work where he burnt his hand.

Peter’s contract appears to have continued during both absences. Authorised unpaid leave does not by itself terminate employment. If the contract continued, the weeks count under section 212(1). If a week was not covered by the contract, section 212(3)(a) can count it if Peter was incapable of work in consequence of sickness or injury[1]. The burn appears to have made him incapable of his work as a senior waiter. Whether the eczema did so during the six weeks in Germany would depend on the evidence.

Section 212(3)(c) ERA can also count a week of absence where, by arrangement or custom, the employee is regarded as continuing in employment for any purpose[2]. Peter’s continuity is likely to run from November 2007. It would restart on his return from Germany only if the contract ended, there was a break of a whole statutory week and no provision preserved continuity. If disputed, continuity is presumed unless the contrary is shown under section 210(5).

Unfair Dismissal

Section 94(1) ERA gives qualifying employees the right not to be unfairly dismissed. The qualifying period applicable to employment which began before 6 April 2012 was one year[3]. Peter is likely to qualify on the basis of employment from November 2007. If his continuity broke and restarted in 2014, the two-year rule would apply and he would not qualify for ordinary unfair dismissal.

Section 98 (1) ERA states that “it is for the employer to show the reason…for the dismissal, and that it is either a reason falling within subsection (2) or some other substantial reason…”. With regard to this, Iceland Frozen Foods Ltd v Jones [4] established the concept of the band of reasonable responses. Browne-Wilkinson J explained that the Tribunal asks whether the decision fell within the band of reasonable responses open to a reasonable employer[5]. Under s98(2)(b) “conduct” is a potentially fair reason. However, the reasonableness of the decision to dismiss based on Peter’s alleged conduct is questionable.

In Laws v London Chronicle (Indicator Newspapers) Ltd[6], the Court of Appeal considered when disobedience of an instruction was serious enough to justify summary dismissal. Peter says he was not aware of the new rule forbidding eating in the kitchen during work hours. BH should investigate whether it communicated the rule and whether it enforced the rule consistently, including Peter’s account that other staff had eaten without reprimand. Lack of notice weighs against dismissal for breaking the rule.

In Wilson v Racher[7] an employee was summarily dismissed for using obscene language towards his employer. However, the employee’s conduct did not amount to gross misconduct because the swearing was a one-off incident, in the context of the employer’s conduct towards him. These facts are similar to Peter’s. He had a difficult working relationship with the restaurant manager Mr Rico and his use of “choice expletives” was in an aggravated situation. Dismissal for this particular conduct is likely to be too harsh and not within the band of reasonable responses.

In Auguste Noel v Curtis[8], the EAT found that the substance of previous warnings and the number of them can be relevant to considering an employee’s conduct and the decision to dismiss. Peter had received a written warning from the assistant manager because he removed an unopened bottle from a table after the diners had left and took it to the kitchen, without asking permission. We do not know whether the previous written warning given to Peter was within Mr Rico’s knowledge at the time of the dismissal. In any event, the Tribunal would need to know whether the warning was still live, what it said, how it was issued and whether Mr Rico relied on it. The facts mention a written warning, with no indication that it was a final warning. It is unlikely that even a combination of Peter’s alleged past behaviour would amount to conduct justifying dismissal and the decision to dismiss remains outside the band of reasonable responses.

If BH establishes conduct as the reason, section 98(4) ERA requires the Tribunal to decide whether BH acted reasonably in treating it as sufficient for dismissal. BH needs a genuine belief in misconduct, reasonable grounds for that belief and a reasonable investigation. In Polkey v A E Dayton Services Ltd[9], the House of Lords confirmed that procedural failings can make a dismissal unfair even where a fair procedure might have led to dismissal. The range of reasonable responses applies to the investigation as well as to the sanction[10].

Paragraph 22 of the Acas Code of Practice in force in January 2015 states “a fair disciplinary process should always be followed before dismissing for gross misconduct”[11]. In McLaren v National Coal Board [12], the Court of Appeal made a finding of unfair dismissal because the employee was not granted the opportunity to explain his conduct prior to his dismissal. Sir John Donaldson states at page 377 “…the standards of fairness which required an employer to afford an employee the opportunity of explaining his conduct prior to dismissal were immutable and applied notwithstanding the exceptional circumstances of the miners’ strike…”. The failure to investigate, hold a hearing, and give Peter an opportunity to respond to the allegations against him would fall outside the band of reasonable responses on the facts of this case. BH should also have offered an appeal and allowed Peter to be accompanied at a disciplinary hearing if he reasonably requested it[32].

S112 ERA 1996 sets out the remedies for unfair dismissal complaints. Peter would be entitled to request that he be reinstated[13] (treated as if he had not been dismissed) or re-engaged (employed on comparable terms as determined by the Tribunal)[14]. It is unlikely that either of these options would appeal due to Peter’s difficult relationships at work. If the Tribunal makes a compensation order, it consists of a Basic Award[15] and Compensatory Award[16]. The Basic Award is a calculated formula designed to reward length of service. It takes into account the employee’s age, length of service and weekly pay. For a dismissal in January 2015, the maximum week’s pay for this calculation was £464[33].

Dunnachie v Kingston-upon-Hull CC[17] confirmed that the Compensatory Award refers to financial losses only. The leading authority on losses recoverable under section 123, Norton Tool Co v Tewson[18], outlines the major heads of claim: (1) losses up to the date of the hearing; (2) future loss; (3) loss of accrued rights; (4) loss due to the manner of dismissal; and (5) loss of pension rights. Loss attributable to the manner of dismissal must be financial. Peter must mitigate his loss. The ordinary compensatory award was capped at the lower of £76,574 and 52 weeks’ pay[33].

These awards are subject to a consideration of contributory fault[19]. Peter’s use of “choice expletives” may justify a reduction if the Tribunal finds that it was culpable and contributed to his dismissal. The statutory tests for reducing the basic and compensatory awards differ. In an extreme case the Tribunal may reduce the compensatory award to nil or a nominal amount, as explained in W Devis & Sons Ltd v Atkins[20]. The compensatory award may also be reduced to reflect the chance or timing of a fair dismissal after a proper process under Polkey. Conversely, unreasonable failure by BH to follow the Acas Code can increase a qualifying award by up to 25%[32].

If BH’s real reason for dismissal was that Peter alleged an infringement of the statutory right not to suffer unauthorised deductions, section 104 ERA could make the dismissal automatically unfair without a qualifying period. The facts establish that Peter asked for sick pay, but do not establish that he alleged an infringement of that statutory right or that his requests caused the dismissal. If continuity is established, he could also have requested written reasons under section 92. An unreasonable failure to give them within 14 days can lead to an award of two weeks’ pay under section 93[34].

Breach of Contract/Wrongful Dismissal

Peter was dismissed without notice. The Employment Rights Act 1996 (“ERA”) s86, requires a minimum amount of notice to be given on termination of employment. If Peter had a written contract, a copy should be obtained to check his contractual entitlement, which may be more.

Section 86 (6) ERA provides “this section does not affect any right of either party to a contract of employment to treat as terminable without notice by reason of the conduct of the other party”. Gross misconduct can amount to a repudiatory breach justifying dismissal without notice[21]. For wrongful dismissal, the question is whether Peter actually committed a repudiatory breach. BH’s reasonable belief alone would not justify withholding notice pay. As discussed above, it is unlikely that Peter’s conduct would amount to gross misconduct and on this basis, he has grounds to bring a breach of contract claim (also known as wrongful dismissal) against BH. The Employment Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear a breach of contract claim[22] where it arises or is outstanding on termination, subject to a £25,000 limit. Peter could alternatively bring this claim in the civil courts.

By way of remedy, Peter would be entitled to damages to put him in the position he would have been had the breach not occurred and he could recover the pay and contractual benefits he would have received during the notice period, subject to mitigation. He cannot recover the same loss twice through wrongful and unfair dismissal. Any accrued statutory holiday pay outstanding at termination is payable independently of the reason for dismissal[35].

Under section 86 ERA, statutory notice entitlement is calculated in relation to the employee’s period of employment. If his continuous employment dates from November 2007, Peter would be entitled to seven weeks’ notice pay – that is a week for each year he was employed, which is the entitlement prescribed under s86(1)(b) ERA his period of continuous employment being “two years or more but less than twelve years”. If not, under s86(1)(a) ERA, his entitlement would be one week’s notice pay.

Statutory Sick Pay/Unlawful Deduction from Wages

Section 151 of the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992 imposed the obligation to pay statutory sick pay (SSP) where the qualifying conditions were met. In 2014–15 a period of incapacity normally required at least four consecutive days of incapacity and normal weekly earnings of at least £111. SSP was normally payable after the first three qualifying days at £87.55 a week, apportioned by qualifying days. Periods of incapacity within eight weeks could be linked[36]. Peter’s three weeks off with a burnt hand are likely to satisfy the incapacity requirement. If the eczema also made him incapable of work, he should check whether that absence qualified and whether the periods linked. His contract may provide more generous sick pay.

Peter could self-certify for the first seven calendar days of absence. BH could ask for medical evidence after that[23]. BH may be entitled to withhold SSP for a day not properly notified, subject to the statutory rules and exceptions[24]. A manager’s refusal to authorise payment does not itself establish that SSP was not due.

Section 13 ERA gives workers the right not to suffer unauthorised deductions, and section 23 provides for complaints to the Tribunal. SSP is included in the definition of wages[25]. Where entitlement to SSP is disputed, HMRC decides the dispute. A deduction claim can concern SSP that is due and undisputed but unpaid. A claim for contractual sick pay may be brought as an unlawful deduction or, where appropriate, a breach of contract[37].

If Peter met the statutory requirements and BH disputed entitlement, he could have asked HMRC for a formal decision, normally within six months of the earliest day in dispute[37]. Where an unlawful deduction complaint succeeds, the Tribunal orders payment of the amount unlawfully deducted and can award attributable financial loss under section 24 ERA. The amount of SSP is calculated from the statutory earnings and qualifying-day rules. Length of continuous employment does not determine it.

Appraisals and injury at work

There is no general statutory right to a six-monthly appraisal. If the wording and status of the appraisal policy make it a term of Peter’s contract, the failure to hold the appraisals may be a breach. He would need to identify any loss it caused, such as a missed opportunity for a pay increase where the policy or evidence supports it. The missed appraisals may also matter if BH relies on performance concerns or says it followed its own procedures[38].

Peter may have a negligence claim if BH failed to take reasonable care for his safety and that caused the burn or eczema. The burn alone does not show a breach. Evidence of unsafe equipment, instructions or working practices would be relevant. For the eczema, Peter would need medical evidence of the link to workload and evidence that injury to health was reasonably foreseeable and BH could reasonably have acted to prevent it. If proved, he can claim damages for injury and resulting financial loss[39].

If the eczema had a substantial and long-term adverse effect on normal day-to-day activities, Peter might be disabled under the Equality Act 2010. The facts do not establish that threshold, BH’s knowledge or a link between disability and the dismissal or other treatment. If those matters are supported by evidence, a claim for discrimination arising from disability or failure to make reasonable adjustments may be available, with compensation that can include injury to feelings[40].

Time-limits

In the Tribunal

In 2015 the ordinary Tribunal time limit for unfair dismissal and breach of contract was three months beginning with the effective date of termination[26]. Peter’s effective date would ordinarily be the date he was told on the telephone that he was dismissed, which was at or shortly after the end of January 2015[27]. The ordinary deadline would therefore fall around the end of April 2015, subject to the exact date and any extension for Acas early conciliation. Time for a deduction claim ran from the date of the underpayment or the last deduction in a series. Peter would ordinarily have needed to notify Acas before presenting the claim[41].

The Tribunal could extend those time limits if it was not reasonably practicable to bring the claim in time and Peter presented it within a further reasonable period[28]. Ignorance of a right or of the deadline can be relevant if it was reasonable in the circumstances[29]. A discrimination claim was ordinarily due within three months from the act complained of, subject to Acas conciliation, any continuing act and the Tribunal’s just and equitable extension power[40].

In Schultz v Esso Petroleum Co Ltd[30], the Court of Appeal recognised that disabling illness may make it not reasonably practicable to bring a claim in time. Peter’s eczema by itself would not establish that he was prevented from acting. He would need evidence of its effect on his ability to present the claim and of the reason for any further delay.

In the civil courts

A simple contract claim in England and Wales is normally subject to a six-year time limit from breach[31]. A personal injury claim is ordinarily subject to three years from accrual of the cause of action or later date of knowledge, with a discretion to disapply that limit[39]. The ordinary time limits for the 2014–15 events have now expired.

Changes to the law since the events in the question

From 6 April 2026, SSP is payable from the first qualifying day of incapacity and the lower earnings limit no longer applies. For 2026–27 the weekly rate is the lower of £123.25 and 80% of normal weekly earnings, subject to transitional rules for some ongoing absences[42].

For relevant events from 1 October 2026, the ordinary Tribunal time limit in England and Wales is six months for unfair dismissal, unlawful deductions, employment contract claims and discrimination. The transitional provisions preserve the earlier limits for earlier events. For dismissals from 1 January 2027 the ordinary unfair dismissal qualifying period falls to six months and the ordinary compensatory award cap is removed[43].

Footnotes

[1] Pearson v Kent County Council [1992] ICR 20 (EAT). See Employment Rights Act 1996, s 212(1), (3)(a).

[2] Booth v United States of America [1999] IRLR 16 (EAT); Employment Rights Act 1996, s 212(3)(c).

[3] Employment Rights Act 1996, s 108(1); SI 2012/989, arts 3–4.

[4] [1983] I.C.R. 17 EAT

[5] Iceland Frozen Foods Ltd v Jones [1983] ICR 17, 24–25.

[6] [1959] 1 W.L.R 698

[7] [1974] I.C.R 428

[8] [1990] I.C.R 604 [1990] I.R.L.R 326 EAT

[9] [1988] ICR 142, [1987] IRLR 503, HL

[10] [2001] ICR 699 (CA); British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell [1980] ICR 303.

[11] ACAS Code of Practice 1 “Disciplinary and grievance procedures” April 2009

[12] [1988] ICR 370, [1988] IRLR 215, CA

[13] s114 Employment Rights Act 1996

[14] s115 Employment Rights Act 1996

[15] s119 Employment Rights Act 1996

[16] s123 Employment Rights Act 1996

[17] [2004] UKHL 36, [2004] ICR 1052, [2004] IRLR 727.

[18] [1973] 1 All ER 183, [1972] ICR 501, [1972] IRLR 86

[19] Employment Rights Act 1996, ss 122(2), 123(6).

[20] [1977] AC 931, [1977] ICR 662, [1977] IRLR 314.

[21] Boston Deep Sea Fishing and Ice Co v Ansell (1888) 39 Ch D 339.

[22] Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994, arts 3 and 10.

[23] Regulation 7(4) of the Statutory Sick Pay (General) Regulations

[24] s156 Social Security Contributions And Benefits Act 1992

[25] s27(1) (b) Employment Rights Act 1996

[26] s111(2) (a) Employment Rights Act 1996, 7(a) Employment Tribunals (Extension of Jurisdiction) Orders 1994, SI 1994/1623 (England and Wales) and s23 (2) Employment Rights Act 1996 respectively

[27] Employment Rights Act 1996, s 97(1)(b). See also Gisda Cyf v Barratt [2010] UKSC 41.

[28] s111 (2) (b) Employment Rights Act 1996 s7(c) Employment Tribunals (Extension of Jurisdiction) Orders 1994, SI 1994/1623 (England and Wales) and s23(4) Employment Rights Act

[29] Porter v Bandridge Ltd [1978] IRLR 271; Dedman v British Building and Engineering Appliances Ltd [1973] IRLR 379

[30] [1999] EWCA Civ 1015, [1999] IRLR 488.

[31] s5 Limitation Act 1980

[32] Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, ss 207 and 207A; Employment Relations Act 1999, s 10.

[33] Employment Rights (Increase of Limits) Order 2014; Employment Rights Act 1996, ss 124(1ZA) and 227.

[34] Employment Rights Act 1996, ss 92–93, 104 and 108(3); SI 2012/989, arts 2 and 4.

[35] Working Time Regulations 1998, reg 14.

[36] Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992, ss 151–157 and Sch 11, as in force in 2014–15; SI 2014/569.

[37] Social Security Contributions (Transfer of Functions, etc.) Act 1999, s 8; Statutory Sick Pay and Statutory Maternity Pay (Decisions) Regulations 1999, regs 2–3; Taylor Gordon & Co Ltd (t/a Plan Personnel) v Timmons [2004] IRLR 180 (EAT).

[38] Keeley v Fosroc International Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 1277.

[39] Wilsons & Clyde Coal Co Ltd v English [1938] AC 57; Barber v Somerset County Council [2004] UKHL 13; Limitation Act 1980, ss 11, 14 and 33.

[40] Equality Act 2010, ss 6, 15, 20–21, 39, 123–124 and Schs 1 and 8.

[41] Employment Tribunals Act 1996, s 18A; Employment Rights Act 1996, s 207B; Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994, art 8B.

[42] Employment Rights Act 2025, ss 10–11; SI 2026/373, regs 2–5; Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992, s 157.

[43] Employment Rights Act 2025, ss 25 and 152 and Sch 12; SI 2026/559, regs 3–4; SI 2026/954, regs 3–4 and Sch; SI 2026/759.

Last updated: 13 November 2026

LawTeacher

LawTeacher

LawTeacher.net is the UK’s leading provider of academic legal support, offering both writing services and an extensive collection of law study resources for students in the UK and overseas.

Founded in 2003 by Grey’s Inn graduate Barclay Littlewood, the Company was built on a commitment to excellence, with unique guarantees and a high standard of service from day one.

The team includes over 500 UK legally qualified writing experts, with many practising solicitors and barristers, and several former lecturers.

Areas of Legal Expertise

Contract Law Criminal Law Constitutional and Administrative Law EU Law Tort Law Property Law Equity and Trusts Jurisprudence Company Law Commercial Law Family Law Human Rights Law Employment Law Evidence Public International Law Legal Research and Methods Dispute Resolution Business Law and Practice Civil Litigation Criminal Litigation Professional Conduct Taxation Wills and Administration of Estates Solicitors’ Accounts

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.

Related Services

View all

Related Content

Jurisdictions / Tags

Content relating to: “UK Law”

UK law covers the laws and legislation of England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. Essays, case summaries, problem questions and dissertations here are relevant to law students from the United Kingdom and Great Britain, as well as students wishing to learn more about the UK legal system from overseas.

Related Articles

DMCA / Removal Request

If you are the original writer of this problem question and no longer wish to have your work published on Lawteacher.net then please click the following link to email our support team:

Request essay removal
Prices from

£ 99

Estimated costs for: Undergraduate 2:2 • 1000 words • 7 day delivery

Place an order

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report