Disclaimer: This problem question has been written by a law student and not by our expert law writers. View examples of our professional work here.

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not reflect the views of LawTeacher.net. You should not treat any information in this problem question as being authoritative.

Shareholder Action Against Company Directors

Info: 2,438 words (10 pages) Problem Question Example
Published: 02 Feb 2018

Reference this

Jurisdiction / Tag(s): UK Law

Possible action by shareholders against companies or directors in response to company policy

Question

Eco Cars Ltd is a company that makes and sells electric cars, and was set up in 2008 by millionaire and environmental campaigner Mr Daniel. Mr Daniel is also one of the directors. The articles of the company state the company is for the development, production and sale of electric vehicles.

Since the company was set up, millions of pounds have been invested in research. At the start of 2015, the research department coincidentally discovered a method to make diesel engines 10% more efficient. Due to the amount of money invested, Mr Daniel and the other directors agreed that they should start producing diesel cars.

Law Teacher writing support

Working on a law problem question?

We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.

Send us the scenario and any marking criteria. We’ll write an answer to your instructions, identifying the legal issues and applying the law to the facts.

Mrs Sarah is a shareholder in the company and a green activist. Having heard the recent news about diesel car emissions, she is against the company producing diesel cars, as are a number of other shareholders.

Mrs Sarah has come to you for advice, including whether they can prevent the company producing diesel cars and whether any action can be taken against the directors.

Answer

Constitution

The company was set up in 2008[1]. The provisions of Part 3 of the Companies Act 2006 (CA 2006) relevant to its objects and constitution were brought generally into force on 1 October 2009[2]. The transitional provisions govern how the company’s pre-existing memorandum and articles are treated[3].

Mr Daniel appears to have been the promoter of Eco Cars Ltd, the person who incorporated the company, and is likely to have influenced its constitution. The suffix ‘Ltd’ reveals that Eco Cars Ltd is a private limited company.[4] The facts indicate that the company is limited by shares and that Mrs Sarah is a member. They do not say how many shares or votes Mr Daniel holds.

The constitution of Eco Cars Ltd includes its articles and any resolutions and agreements affecting the constitution within section 17 CA 2006[5]. An objects clause in its pre-October 2009 memorandum would now generally be treated as part of its articles under section 28.

The articles state the company is “for the development, production and sale of electric vehicles”. The articles are interpreted objectively, giving the words their ordinary meaning in the context of the document as a whole.[6] The words ‘development, production and sale’ limit the actions of the company and the words ‘electric vehicles’ limit the product of the company. On the facts, the statement is an objects clause. Its effect depends on the articles, not on Mr Daniel’s personal reasons for setting up the company.

“Unless a company’s articles specifically restrict the objects of the company, its objects are unrestricted”.[7] The relationship between the constitution of the company and its members is such that it “binds the company and its members to the same extent as if there were covenants on the part of the company and of each member to observe those provisions”.[8] The company is therefore restricted by the clause. Whether the objects clause appeared in the original articles or is treated as part of them under section 28 does not change its effect.[9]

The constitution of Eco Cars Ltd therefore restricts the business that can be carried out.

Directors’ Duties

As a private company, Eco Cars Ltd must have at least one director.[10] A director is “any person occupying the position of director, by whatever name called”.[11] The facts state that Mr Daniel is a director. The directors’ actions will be scrutinised to determine whether they have incurred any liability by engaging in the production of non-electric cars.

Mr Daniel and any other directors owe several duties to Eco Cars Ltd.[12] The common law duties have to a certain degree been codified in the CA 2006.[13] Mrs Sarah should be advised that the common law rules and equitable principles should be considered when interpreting the CA 2006.[14]

Mr Daniel has a duty to “act in accordance with the company’s constitution, and only exercise powers for the purposes for which they are conferred”.[15] The directors must ensure that the objects clause is followed. It therefore needs to be ascertained whether the production of diesel cars falls within the objects clause.

Diesel cars do contain a battery which is required to start the car and run the electronics. There is the possibility of a hybrid; a diesel car with an electric motor. However, Eco Cars Ltd appears not to be producing hybrids, but a pure diesel car and the courts are unlikely to consider this to be an ‘electric vehicle’, and there is no evident commercial absurdity in limiting the business to electric vehicles.[16]

The directors of Eco Cars Ltd authorised the production of diesel cars and would have exercised many of their powers in enabling production. Whilst producing cars is within their powers and would fall within the purposes for which the powers were given, the production of diesel cars is excluded from the directors’ powers as it is in contravention of the constitution of Eco Cars Ltd. Mr Daniel and the other directors therefore appear to have breached section 171(a) by acting outside the constitution. Section 171(b), which concerns using a power for an improper purpose, is a separate question. The facts do not identify an ulterior purpose[34].

The directors also had a duty to “act in the way he considers, in good faith, would be most likely to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole”.[17] To determine whether this duty has been breached, the factors that directors must have regard to when making decisions should be considered.

The first is the “likely consequences of any decision in the long term”[18]. The facts indicate that a large investment has been made in research. The prospect of obtaining a return on the research is a relevant commercial consideration. The facts do not establish that Eco Cars Ltd was in financial distress. Producing diesel cars using the more efficient engine could enable the company to make money from the discovery. Publicity could also affect the company’s reputation, including how its existing customers and shareholders would respond to the change.

The directors must also have regard to “the impact of the company’s operations on the community and the environment”.[19] An improvement in diesel efficiency does not answer the wider question about environmental impact. Section 172(2) applies where the company’s purposes include purposes other than the benefit of its members. To that extent, the duty is to promote the achievement of those purposes. An objects clause identifying the company’s permitted business does not by itself establish a separate environmental purpose. The full constitution would need to be checked.[20]

The court ordinarily respects the directors’ genuine commercial judgment and the weight they give to the section 172 factors[21]. The duty of good faith also applies to how a director acts. In Saxon Woods Investments Ltd v Costa, the Supreme Court held that a director could not covertly subvert the board’s strategy on the basis that he genuinely thought his own approach was better[22]. Here, the board agreed to pursue the new business. It had a commercial reason for doing so, but the facts do not establish whether it considered the environmental and reputational effects. Disagreement with the board’s assessment alone is insufficient to establish a breach of section 172.

The directors are required to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence[23]. Section 174 sets an objective minimum based on the functions carried out by the director, and raises the standard if that director has greater knowledge, skill or experience. Failing to check a clear restriction in the articles before committing the company to a new line of business could breach this duty. The financial reasons for the decision are relevant but do not show what checks the directors made[24].

Mrs Sarah should be advised that there appears to have been a breach of at least one duty owed to Eco Cars Ltd by the directors.

Remedies

Mrs Sarah has raised two issues; firstly, whether the production of diesel cars can be stopped, and secondly, whether any action can be taken against the directors.

Mrs Sarah may be unable to prevent production required by contracts already entered into. Section 39 prevents an act of the company being challenged for lack of capacity arising from the constitution. Section 40 protects a person dealing with the company in good faith against constitutional limits on the directors’ authority. Good faith is presumed, and knowledge of the restriction does not by itself amount to bad faith[25]. A binding contract with such a party is not invalid simply because it concerns diesel cars. This does not remove the directors’ liability to the company.

However, Mrs Sarah may apply in her own right as a member for an injunction to stop further acts beyond the directors’ powers. Section 40(4) preserves that right but excludes acts required to fulfil a legal obligation arising from a previous act of the company[26]. If she seeks an interim injunction before trial, the court will consider whether there is a serious issue to be tried, whether damages would be adequate and where the balance of convenience lies[35].

Whilst an injunction could be obtained, the members of Eco Cars Ltd can ordinarily change the articles to allow the production of diesel cars by special resolution[27]. At a meeting the threshold is normally 75% of the votes cast, calculated under the applicable voting method. A private company may also use a written special resolution, which requires at least 75% of the total voting rights of eligible members[28]. An amendment to the company’s objects takes effect only when notice is entered on the register. Any applicable entrenchment provisions would also need to be complied with[36].

Mrs Sarah may therefore obtain an injunction against future acts outside the articles. A valid amendment could permit those acts going forward and provide grounds to vary or discharge an injunction. It would not itself ratify an earlier breach.

The company may have a claim against the directors for breach of duty. Section 178 preserves the applicable common-law and equitable consequences. Depending on the breach and its consequences, the company may seek to restrain it or recover loss it caused[29].

A breach of directors’ duties is a wrong against the company and the company is normally the proper claimant[30]. Mrs Sarah cannot recover the company’s loss personally merely because she holds shares. She can ask the company to act. Members with at least 5% of the relevant voting rights can generally require the directors to call a general meeting, and members can remove a director by ordinary resolution at a meeting, subject to special notice and the director’s right to be heard. The outcome depends on the voting rights and the articles[37].

Mrs Sarah may bring a derivative claim as a member in respect of a cause of action vested in the company, seeking relief on the company’s behalf[31]. An actual or proposed breach of duty can qualify. She must apply for permission to continue and first show a prima facie case for permission, which may be possible in respect of section 171(a)[32].

The court must refuse permission if no director acting in accordance with section 172 would seek to continue the claim. Prior authorisation or subsequent ratification of an act, or prior authorisation of a proposed act, can also require refusal under section 263(2)[33]. In deciding whether to give permission the court also considers the applicant’s good faith, the importance a director acting under section 172 would attach to the claim, possible authorisation or ratification, any decision by the company not to sue, any personal cause of action and the views of disinterested members. Where section 239 applies to ratification, the votes of the director concerned and connected members are excluded in the manner the section prescribes[38]. The court would consider the value to the company of enforcing its objects, any loss already suffered and the likely benefit and cost of proceedings. The board’s view that diesel production might be profitable does not by itself decide whether the claim should continue.

Mrs Sarah may also petition under section 994 CA 2006 if the proposed departure from the articles is unfairly prejudicial to her interests as a member. Breach of the articles may support unfairness, but she must also show prejudice to those interests. Her personal objection to diesel production is insufficient on its own. If the petition succeeds, section 996 allows the court to regulate the company’s affairs, restrain a proposed act or order a buy-out. The Supreme Court confirmed in Zedra that sections 8 and 9 of the Limitation Act 1980 do not impose a time limit on a section 994 petition[39].

Mrs Sarah may wish to consider selling her shares as taking action against the company is an expensive option and may fail.

Conclusion

The directors’ actions appear to show a breach of duty as the constitution contains an objects clause. However, the commercial reality of taking action against the directors and seeking an injunction against the production of diesel cars may lead Mrs Sarah to invest in a company more attuned to her principles.

Footnotes

[1] Reasonable assumptions will be made as to the nature of the company in order to provide initial advice.

[2] Companies Act 2006, s 1300(1)–(2); Companies Act 2006 (Commencement No. 8, Transitional Provisions and Savings) Order 2008, art 3.

[3] SI 2008/2860, Sch 2; Companies Act 2006 (Part 35) (Consequential Amendments, Transitional Provisions and Savings) Order 2009, SI 2009/1802.

[4] S.59(1) CA 2006

[5] Companies Act 2006, ss 17, 28 and 257.

[6] Investors Compensation Scheme Ltd v West Bromwich Building Society [1998] 1 WLR 896

[7] S. 31(1) CA 2006

[8] S. 33 CA 2006

[9] S. 28(1) CA 2006

[10] Companies Act 2006, ss 154(1) and 155.

[11] S. 250 CA 2006

[12] Companies Act 2006, s 170(1); Foss v Harbottle (1843) 67 ER 189.

[13] Companies Act 2006, s 170(3).

[14] S. 170(4) CA 2006

[15] S. 171 CA 2006

[16] Thompson v Goblin Hill Hotels Ltd [2011] 1 BCLC 587

[17] S.172 CA 2006

[18] S. 172(1)(a)

[19] S. 172(1)(d)

[20] Companies Act 2006, s 172(2). See also A-G Lord Goldsmith, Department of Trade and Industry compilation of ministerial statements on duties of company directors, (June 2007)

[21] Margaret Hodge, Minister of State for Industry and the Regions, Department of Trade and Industry compilation of ministerial statements on duties of company directors, (June 2007)

[22] Saxon Woods Investments Ltd v Costa [2026] UKSC 21, [51]–[63]. See also ClientEarth v Shell plc [2023] EWHC 1897 (Ch).

[23] S. 174 CA 2006

[24] Re Westmid Packing Services Ltd [1998] 2 All ER 1240

[25] Companies Act 2006, ss 39–40.

[26] S. 40(4) CA 2006

[27] S. 21 CA 2006

[28] S. 283 CA 2006

[29] Companies Act 2006, ss 178–179.

[30] Foss v Harbottle (1843) 2 Hare 461

[31] S. 260 CA 2006

[32] S. 261(2) CA 2006, Iesini v Westrip Holdings Ltd [2011] 1 BCLC 498

[33] Companies Act 2006, s 263(2); Iesini v Westrip Holdings Ltd [2009] EWHC 2526 (Ch), [2011] 1 BCLC 498.

[34] Eclairs Group Ltd v JKX Oil & Gas plc [2015] UKSC 71, [14]–[16]; Companies Act 2006, s 171.

[35] American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396, 407–409.

[36] Companies Act 2006, ss 22, 26 and 30–31.

[37] Companies Act 2006, ss 168–169, 282, 288(2), 303–305 and 312.

[38] Companies Act 2006, ss 239 and 263(3)–(4); Iesini v Westrip Holdings Ltd [2011] 1 BCLC 498; ClientEarth v Shell plc [2023] EWHC 1897 (Ch).

[39] Companies Act 2006, ss 994 and 996; O’Neill v Phillips [1999] 1 WLR 1092; THG plc v Zedra Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd [2026] UKSC 6, [158]–[172].

Last updated: 13 November 2026

LawTeacher

LawTeacher

LawTeacher.net is the UK’s leading provider of academic legal support, offering both writing services and an extensive collection of law study resources for students in the UK and overseas.

Founded in 2003 by Grey’s Inn graduate Barclay Littlewood, the Company was built on a commitment to excellence, with unique guarantees and a high standard of service from day one.

The team includes over 500 UK legally qualified writing experts, with many practising solicitors and barristers, and several former lecturers.

Areas of Legal Expertise

Contract Law Criminal Law Constitutional and Administrative Law EU Law Tort Law Property Law Equity and Trusts Jurisprudence Company Law Commercial Law Family Law Human Rights Law Employment Law Evidence Public International Law Legal Research and Methods Dispute Resolution Business Law and Practice Civil Litigation Criminal Litigation Professional Conduct Taxation Wills and Administration of Estates Solicitors’ Accounts

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.

Related Services

View all

Related Content

Jurisdictions / Tags

Content relating to: “UK Law”

UK law covers the laws and legislation of England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. Essays, case summaries, problem questions and dissertations here are relevant to law students from the United Kingdom and Great Britain, as well as students wishing to learn more about the UK legal system from overseas.

Related Articles

DMCA / Removal Request

If you are the original writer of this problem question and no longer wish to have your work published on Lawteacher.net then please click the following link to email our support team:

Request essay removal
Prices from

£ 99

Estimated costs for: Undergraduate 2:2 • 1000 words • 7 day delivery

Place an order

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report