Sample 2:1 Undergraduate Law Exam Answer
This sample law exam answer was written by one of our expert writers, to give you a taste of the work we produce.
See Our Seen Exam Answer Sample See Our Exam Revision Notes SampleTo what extent international law, designed to regulate relations between states, is hopeless at effectively regulating the Internet?
Introduction
Early advocates saw the Internet as a means to transcend national borders, bridge distances and create a borderless world,[1] while international law is built on the concepts of sovereignty and non-intervention, which are both linked to idea of territoriality and national borders.[2] One approach to applying international law to online activity has been to implement it without adaptation.[3] This does not always resolve which state may act when online conduct crosses borders. The rules designed to regulate day-to-day offline activity between states are not in the same way enforceable and do not bear the same consequences when applied to online activity.[4] Nevertheless, as it will be argued in this short essay, if international law is appropriately adapted to the new environment, it will not be completely hopeless at regulating the Internet. To prove this, the essay will be divided into four parts. Part I will look at the aspects of the Internet that require international regulation. Part II will explain the reasons why online conduct regulation is challenging for international law. Part III will focus on the three contemporary approaches to international regulation of the Internet and explore their drawbacks and potential. Part IV will briefly look at the future of international regulation of online activity.
Aspects of the Internet that Require International Regulation
There are three aspects of the Internet that necessitate some form of regulation:[5]
(1) Access – control of the opportunity for connecting and means to access the Internet, such as the machines using Internet technology (computers, smart phones, etc.) and Internet Service Providers (ISPs);
(2) Functionality – controlling the quality of Internet connection such as the physical infrastructure (its bandwidth and speed), the software used for communication (email clients, browsers, chat clients, cloud computing software, etc.);
(3) Activity – controlling how the Internet is used by various stakeholders, such as individual users, organisations and governments.
Out of the three aspects of the Internet that require regulation, the most difficult one to exercise control over is activity as control over activity has strong ethical and political considerations and includes a balance between competing values, e.g. privacy and security, which is achieved in a different manner by different states.
Reasons why Internet Regulation is Problematic for International Law
Firstly, international law is designed to regulate relations between states. At the same time, the states do not have complete control over the three aspects of Internet regulation.[6] Furthermore, the Internet blurs the traditional division in international law between public and private, e.g. Internet functionality is driven by private interests, but it is the states that regulate and monitor Internet infrastructure within their own territory.[7]
Secondly, the system of Internet protocols that the Internet works through, promotes distributed control, i.e. decision-making over protocols is no longer closely linked to political units. Moreover, the Internet led to the creation of new standard-setting institutions such as the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), regional internet address registries, etc. Thus, authority over technical standards is shared with bodies outside the state system.[8]
Thirdly, there is a perception that international law is hopeless at regulating the Internet because of the prevailing interpretation of sovereignty, on which international law is founded, as bound to the concept of territoriality.[9] This is not necessarily the case. There are different ways in which states exercise sovereignty and enforcing the law within their own territory is only one of them. Other ways include the exercise of extraterritorial jurisdiction or ceding sovereignty to international institutions.[10] For example, governments participate in ICANN through its Governmental Advisory Committee. The US Department of Commerce’s contract for the IANA functions expired in 2016, when stewardship passed to the global multistakeholder community.[11] States also exercise jurisdiction over online conduct with connections to more than one territory. The power to prescribe a rule does not itself confer power to enforce it on foreign soil.
III. The Reality of International Internet Regulation – Three Different Approaches
There has not been a single approach to Internet regulation in international law. Three approaches coexist in the national and regional rules that govern cross-border cases. They do not supply a single rule of international law.
The first one is the country of origin approach, under which the rules of the provider’s state of establishment govern the matters covered.[12] This may give providers an incentive to establish themselves in a state with less restrictive laws. The country of origin approach is exemplified by Art. 3(2) EU E-Commerce Directive[13] which generally prevents an EU Member State from restricting incoming information society services from another Member State for reasons within the coordinated field. Article 3(4) allows measures against a particular service under specified conditions. The Digital Services Act has a different scope: it applies to intermediary services offered to recipients in the EU even if the provider is established elsewhere. It can easily be inferred that such an approach is strongly supported by online publishers as it offers them greater certainty, but opposed by states insofar as it limits their ability to control activities taking place at their territory though originating by foreign providers.[14]
The second approach – the country of destination approach, is the exact opposite of the first one. According to it, the place where content is received can matter. Whether accessibility alone is enough depends on the particular rule and the remedy claimed.[15] The country of destination approach has traditionally been applied to Australian defamation cases such as Dow Jones v Gutnick,[16] where the material was downloaded and read in Victoria, and the claimant sued only for the harm alleged there. In the EU copyright case Pez Hejduk, accessibility in Austria gave its courts jurisdiction only over damage sustained there.[17] A different connection mattered in the landmark Google 'right to be forgotten' ruling,[18] where the Court of Justice of the European Union linked the processing of personal data to the advertising activity of Google’s Spanish establishment. A link may have to be removed from name-based search results where the personal information is no longer relevant. The decision also depends on the grounds for removal and the public interest in access. EU law does not generally require worldwide removal. US cases likewise turn on their particular jurisdictional basis. For example, in the CNN v CNNews,[19] the Virginia District Court ordered the transfer of the domain name under the US Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act[20] in proceedings against the domain name itself. Its registry was in Virginia. In the civil forfeiture case involving American Sports Ltd,[21] the US court upheld forfeiture of funds connected with an offshore betting business. Its New Jersey operation collected money from US bettors.
The third approach – targeting is the middle ground between the two approaches. Its main idea is that certain online conduct can be subjected to the laws in a particular country if it is directed towards it. Targeting the audience was not the basis for jurisdiction over the domain name in CNN v CNNews. By contrast, targeting has been applied in US defamation cases in which the tort originates in one US state but is directed at another. Such a case is Young v New Haven Advocate,[22] in which Virginia lacked personal jurisdiction over two Connecticut newspapers because their articles were aimed at a Connecticut audience, following the logic of the landmark 1945 case on minimum contacts - International Shoe Company v Washington.[23] Also, the targeting approach has been used in the UK in cases where UK trademarks are used by foreign websites – e.g. 1-800 FLOWERS.[24]
The existence of three approaches to regulating international online activity shows that international law has not completely given up on regulating international online activity. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of the three approaches varies significantly. The underlying philosophy of the country of origin and country of destination approaches is the idea of the common denominator – in the first case, a provider may seek a less restrictive home jurisdiction, and in the second it may choose to meet the strictest requirements of the markets it serves. The common denominator idea in both cases leads to an unfair balance between online publishers and states – the country of origin approach favours online publishers to the detriment of the ability of the state to control activity on its territory, while the country of destination does exactly the opposite – it favours state control to the detriment of online publishers. The only reasonable option then remains the targeting approach as it allows porous national borders – upholding national borders where necessary while reducing the incentives for Internet fragmentation, thus protecting the free flow of information across borders.
The three approaches differ in their level of jurisdictional self-restraint: the extent to which states refrain from exercising jurisdiction when they can legitimately do so under international law.[25] The country of destination approach may encourage too little jurisdictional self-restraint, which is dangerous as it may lead to incentivising geo-blocking and result in complete fragmentation of the Internet, while the country of origin approach can limit the options of countries with restrictive laws on online activity when faced with an activity which affects their territory, but comes from elsewhere. On this account, targeting also proves the most viable approach as it implies a modest jurisdictional self-restraint in which countries govern activity within there own borders as well as activity with strong connections with the country itself.
The Future of International Regulation of the Internet
The future of regulation of the Internet lies in defining the extent to which regulation ought to be national or international and defining whether it should be organised in a hierarchical manner or through network of stakeholders (networking).[26] This produces four competing theories of how the Internet should be regulated in the future:[27]
(1) Cyberconservatism (cyber reactionism) - a theory that promotes national regulation of the Internet together with hierarchy. In practice, this means subordinating global communications to the institutions of political authority and realigning them with the jurisdiction of the state.[28] While such an approach creates legal certainty, this is to the detriment of the user. The Chinese approach to Internet regulation exemplifies this approach. However, its imposition led Google in 2010 to redirect users of its mainland search site to its uncensored Hong Kong service, which is not a desirable outcome to the consumer.
(2) Networked nationalism – a theory that promotes national regulation combined with networking. According to this approach, the state remains the leading institution in Internet regulation, but it is reluctant to impose territorial hierarchy and thus, is more open to networking. It is willing to participate in institutions such as ICANN and in transnational networks.[29]
(3) Global governmentality – a theory that promotes hierarchical control of the internet through international institutions that transcend national borders.[30] The new institutions should be private with their own business interests to include the private aspect of internet governance. This idea is often phrased as the multi-stakeholder approach or public-private partnership.
(4) Denationalised liberalism – a theory that argues for transnational institutional regulation of the Internet, combined with networking.[31] According to this theory, Internet regulation should be entirely outside of the state system and what matters are not states, but individual network participants.
The best solution in terms of international law is networked nationalism because firstly, states retain a significant role even when they cooperate across borders. Hence, a solution needs to be found within the state system. Secondly, physical location of activity cannot be ignored as a factor in Internet regulation. The networked nationalism approach factors in physical location, while at the same time allows for transport of data between states and permits participation in international institutions when this benefits the state interest. The Budapest Convention on Cybercrime illustrates the point: its parties cooperate in obtaining electronic evidence, including through a network of contacts available around the clock. That helps investigators act across borders while leaving them dependent on other states for assistance. The UN Convention against Cybercrime, adopted in 2024, also provides for cooperation but has yet to enter into force.
Conclusion
To summarise the main points, firstly, there are three aspects of the Internet that require regulation – access, functionality and activity, out of which the most difficult to regulate is activity. Secondly, Internet regulation is a problem for international law because it blurs its traditional divisions between public and private, decision-making is no longer a prerogative of the state – the main unit of international law and because the main principle of international law – sovereignty, is mainly understood as the ability of the state to apply its own laws within its territory, which the Internet makes burdensome. Despite these challenges, national and regional authorities continue to address cross-border conduct using three different approaches – country of origin, country of destination and targeting. Taken to extremes, the first two risk producing a common denominator, thus creating an unfair balance between Internet users and states. The targeting approach offers a promise that international law can effectively deal with Internet regulation, but so far, it has been applied only in specific areas of Internet law. The future of Internet regulation depends solving two dilemmas – choosing between national and transnational regulation and between hierarchy and networking. International law has a place in this as it is the dominant way of regulating relations between states. However, it needs adaptation to the specifics of the online environment, rather than equivalent application as in the offline environment. The networked nationalism approach accounts for the challenges of Internet regulation, while at the same time preserving the core features of international law. It is therefore, a potential way in which it can achieve effective regulation of the Internet.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Legislation
EU Legislation
Directive 2000/31/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 June 2000 on certain legal aspects of information society services, in particular electronic commerce, in the Internal Market (E-Commerce Directive) [2000] OJ L 178 <http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:32000L0031:en:HTML> Accessed 16 July 2017
National Legislation
Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act 1999, 15 U.S.C. § 1125
Case Law
1-800 FLOWERS Inc v Phonenames Ltd [2001] EWCA Civ 721 <http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2001/721.html> Accessed 16 July 2017
Cable News Network LP v CNNews.com [2001] 177 F Supp 2d 506 (ED Va 2001) U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia <http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp2/177/506/2571196/> Accessed 16 July 2017
Dow Jones & Co. Inc. v Gutnick [2002] HCA 56 <http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/HCA/2002/56.html> Accessed 16 July 2017
C-131/12 Google Spain SL and Google Inc. v Agencia Española de Protección de Datos EU:C:2014:317 <http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:62012CJ0131&from=EN> Accessed 16 July 2017
International Shoe v State of Washington [1945] 326 U.S. 310 <https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/326/310/case.html> Accessed 16 July 2017
Case C-441/13 Pez Hejduk v EnergieAgentur.NRW GmbH EU:C:2015:28 <http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?text=&docid=161611&pageIndex=0&doclang=en&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=1758808> Accessed 16 July 2017
United States v $734,578.82 in United States Currency, 286 F 3d 641 (3d Cir 2002)
Young v New Haven Advocate [2002] 315 F3d 256 <http://www.internetlibrary.com/pdf/young-new-haven-advocate.pdf> Accessed 16 July 2017
Secondary Sources
Aron R, Peace and War:A Theory of International Relations (London, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1966)
Barlow J P, 'A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace', Davos, Switzerland, 8th February 1996 <https://homes.eff.org/~barlow/Declaration-Final.html> Accessed 16 July 2017
Cavelty M D, Mauer V, Krishna-Hensel S F, Power and Security in the Information Age: Investigating the Role of the State in Cyberspace (Aldershot, Ashgate, 2007)
Eriksson J, Giacomello G, 'Who Controls What, and Under What Conditions?', in Who Controls the Internet? Beyond the Obstinacy or Obsolescence of the State, edited by Johan Eriksson and Giampiero Giacomello (2009) 11 International Studies Review 205
Herz J H, Political Realism and Political Idealism: A Study in Theories and Realities (Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1951)
Hörnle J 'Country of Origin Regulation in Cross-Border Media: One Step beyond the Freedom to Provide Services?' (2005) 54(1) The International and Comparative Law Quarterly 89 < https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/3663358.pdf?refreqid=excelsior:6fb6877e032a60f2917653dfe169e124> Accessed 16 July 2017
Kohl U, Jurisdiction and the Internet: Regulatory Competence over Online Activity (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2007)
Lagerkvist J, The Internet and China: Unlocking and Containing the Public Sphere (Lund, Lund University Press, 2007)
Litfin K, 'The Greening of sovereignty: Introduction', in The Greening of Sovereignty in World Politics, edited by Karen T. Litfin (Cambridge, The MIT Press, 1998)
Mueller M, Networks and States: The Global Politics of Internet Governance (Cambridge, Massachusetts, London, MIT Press, 2010)
Raymond M, Smith G, 'Reimagining the Internet: The Need for a High-level Strategic Vision for Internet Governance', Internet Governance Papers (Paper No 1, July 2013) <http://www.cigionline.org/sites/default/files/no1_4.pdf> Accessed 16 July 2017
Smith G, 'Cyberborders and the Right to Travel in Cyberspace', in The Net and the Nation State: Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Internet Governance, edited by Uta Kohl (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2017) 110
[1] John Perry Barlow 'A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace', Davos, Switzerland, 8th February 1996 <https://homes.eff.org/~barlow/Declaration-Final.html> Accessed 16 July 2017
[2] Uta Kohl, Jurisdiction and the Internet: Regulatory Competence over Online Activity (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2007), p. 5
[3] Ibid., p. 7
[4] Graham Smith, 'Cyberborders and the Right to Travel in Cyberspace', in The Net and the Nation State: Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Internet Governance, edited by Uta Kohl (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2017) 110, p. 111
[5] Johan Eriksson, Giampiero Giacomello, 'Who Controls What, and Under What Conditions?', in Who Controls the Internet? Beyond the Obstinacy or Obsolescence of the State, edited by Johan Eriksson and Giampiero Giacomello (2009) 11 International Studies Review 205, pp. 206-207
[6] Myriam Dunn Cavelty, Victor Mauer, Sai Felicia Krishna-Hensel, Power and Security in the Information Age: Investigating the Role of the State in Cyberspace (Aldershot, Ashgate, 2007), p. 23
[7] Johan Lagerkvist, The Internet and China: Unlocking and Containing the Public Sphere (Lund, Lund University Press, 2007), p. 102
[8] Milton Mueller, Networks and States: The Global Politics of Internet Governance (Cambridge, Massachusetts, London, MIT Press, 2010), p. 4
[9] John H. Herz, Political Realism and Political Idealism: A Study in Theories and Realities (Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1951), p. 15
Raymond Aron, Peace and War:A Theory of International Relations (London, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1966), p. 6
[10] Karen Litfin 'The Greening of sovereignty: Introduction', in The Greening of Sovereignty in World Politics, edited by Karen T. Litfin (Cambridge, The MIT Press, 1998), p. 4
[11] Mark Raymond, Gordon Smith, 'Reimagining the Internet: The Need for a High-level Strategic Vision for Internet Governance', Internet Governance Papers (Paper No 1, July 2013) <http://www.cigionline.org/sites/default/files/no1_4.pdf> Accessed 16 July 2017. ICANN, Stewardship of IANA Functions Transitions to Global Internet Community as Contract with U.S. Government Ends (1 October 2016).
[12] Julia Hörnle 'Country of Origin Regulation in Cross-Border Media: One Step beyond the Freedom to Provide Services?' (2005) 54(1) The International and Comparative Law Quarterly 89 < https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/3663358.pdf?refreqid=excelsior:6fb6877e032a60f2917653dfe169e124> Accessed 16 July 2017
[13] Directive 2000/31/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 June 2000 on certain legal aspects of information society services, in particular electronic commerce, in the Internal Market (E-Commerce Directive) [2000] OJ L 178 <http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:32000L0031:en:HTML> Accessed 16 July 2017. Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, arts 2(1) and 3(d)-(e).
[14] Uta Kohl, Jurisdiction and the Internet, p. 147
[15] Graham Smith, 'Cyberborders and the Right to Travel in Cyberspace', p.129
[16]Dow Jones & Co. Inc. v Gutnick [2002] HCA 56 <http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/HCA/2002/56.html> Accessed 16 July 2017
[17] Case C-441/13 Pez Hejduk v EnergieAgentur.NRW GmbH EU:C:2015:28 <http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?text=&docid=161611&pageIndex=0&doclang=en&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=1758808> Accessed 16 July 2017
[18] C-131/12 Google Spain SL and Google Inc. v Agencia Española de Protección de Datos EU:C:2014:317 <http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:62012CJ0131&from=EN> Accessed 16 July 2017. Regulation (EU) 2016/679, art 17. Case C-507/17, Google v CNIL, EU:C:2019:772.
[19]Cable News Network LP v CNNews.com [2001] 177 F Supp 2d 506 (ED Va 2001) U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia <http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp2/177/506/2571196/> Accessed 16 July 2017
[20] Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act 1999, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(d)
[21]United States v $734,578.82 in United States Currency, 286 F 3d 641 (3d Cir 2002)
[22]Young v New Haven Advocate [2002] 315 F3d 256 <http://www.internetlibrary.com/pdf/young-new-haven-advocate.pdf> Accessed 16 July 2017
[23]International Shoe v State of Washington [1945] 326 U.S. 310 <https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/326/310/case.html> Accessed 16 July 2017
[24]1-800 FLOWERS Inc v Phonenames Ltd [2001] EWCA Civ 721 <http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2001/721.html> Accessed 16 July 2017. See also Lifestyle Equities CV v Amazon UK Services Ltd [2024] UKSC 8.
[25] Graham Smith, 'Cyberborders and the Right to Travel in Cyberspace', p.126
[26] Milton Mueller, Networks and States, p. 256
[27] Ibid, pp. 256 - 258
[28] Ibid., pp. 256-257
[29] Ibid., p. 257
[30] Ibid.
[31] Ibid., p. 258. Convention on Cybercrime (ETS 185), arts 23, 25 and 35. UN Convention against Cybercrime, annex to UN General Assembly resolution 79/243, arts 35 and 65.
99
Estimated costs for: Undergraduate 2:2 • 1000 words • 7 day delivery
Place an orderDelivered on-time or your money back
Give yourself the academic edge today
Each order includes
- On-time delivery or your money back
- A fully qualified writer in your subject
- In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
- 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
- Standard 7-day amendment period
- A paper written to the standard ordered
- A detailed plagiarism report
- A comprehensive quality report
Related Services
Our academic writing and marking services can help you!