Political and sociological context
In 2002 the UK Labour government published a White Paper entitled ‘Secure Borders, Safe Haven: Integration with Diversity in Modern Britain’. The Paper identified a concern that over half those claiming asylum were found not to be in need of protection. There were also concerns about the number of unqualified immigration advisors in the UK. In 2003 the government introduced a Bill to improve the existing asylum system and clamp down on its abuse by those making unfounded asylum claims. The government stated that fairness, firmness and speed would be the hallmarks of this new system.
Legal context
The Act aimed to end abuse of the immigration appeals system by dishonest applicants and unqualified advisors. To deter groundless claims and to deal with genuine claims more efficiently, the Act replaced the existing two-tier appeals system with a single tier. The Act also introduced criminal offences of failing to have an immigration document at a leave or asylum interview, subject to exceptions and defences, of trafficking people for non-sexual exploitation, and of advertising or offering immigration advice or services when unqualified to provide them. Additionally, the Act provided rules about assessing the credibility of claims, especially for those claimants who travelled through a safe third country before applying for asylum in the UK. Finally, the Act aimed to deal with ‘sham marriages’ where a marriage without a genuine relationship was entered into to circumvent immigration controls.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Main changes to the law
Section 2 created offences of attending a leave or asylum interview without having an immigration document in force establishing the identity and nationality or citizenship of the person or of a dependent child with whom they claim to be travelling or living. If the interview takes place after entry to the UK, no offence is committed if the required document is provided within 3 days beginning with the date of the interview. Defences include a reasonable excuse for not having the document (or, for an interview after entry, for not providing it within those 3 days); producing a false document and proving it was used as an immigration document for all purposes in connection with the journey to the UK; or proving that the person travelled to the UK without possessing the relevant immigration document at any stage of the journey. Under s.2(7), deliberate destruction or disposal is not a reasonable excuse unless it was for a reasonable cause or beyond the defendant’s control. A purpose of delaying a decision or increasing the chances of success is not a reasonable cause; nor is following an immigration adviser’s or facilitator’s instructions, unless it was unreasonable to expect non-compliance in the circumstances.
Section 2 remains in force. Its original defences for EEA nationals and qualifying family members have been replaced by defences for Irish citizens, people with leave under the residence scheme immigration rules and qualifying frontier workers; equivalent defences apply in respect of dependent children (s.2(4)–(6)).
Under s.4 it was an offence to arrange or facilitate the arrival of another person in the UK intending to exploit them or believing that another person was likely to do so. The section also covered departure from the UK and, subject to its conditions, travel within the UK. Exploitation included slavery or forced labour, organ removal and specified forms of coercion or abuse of vulnerability. Section 4 was later repealed: the principal trafficking legislation is now the Modern Slavery Act 2015 in England and Wales, the Human Trafficking and Exploitation (Scotland) Act 2015 in Scotland, and the Human Trafficking and Exploitation (Criminal Justice and Support for Victims) Act (Northern Ireland) 2015 in Northern Ireland (s.4 repeal annotations).
Section 8 requires a deciding authority to take specified behaviour into account as damaging to a claimant’s credibility when assessing an asylum or human rights claim. The section covers behaviour designed or likely to conceal information, mislead, or obstruct or delay a decision. As enacted, it included: failing without reasonable explanation to produce a passport on request to an immigration officer or the Secretary of State; producing an invalid passport as if it were valid; destroying, altering or disposing of a passport, ticket or travel document without reasonable explanation; failing to answer a question asked by a deciding authority without reasonable explanation; and failing to take a reasonable opportunity to make an asylum or human rights claim in a safe country. It also covered failure to claim before notification of an immigration decision, unless the claim relied wholly on matters arising afterwards, and failure to claim before arrest under an immigration provision, unless there had been no reasonable opportunity to claim earlier or the claim relied wholly on matters arising after the arrest. The evidence must be assessed as a whole: such behaviour does not automatically defeat a claim.
From 28 September 2023, s.62 of the Illegal Migration Act 2023 widened the passport provisions to identity documents and added failure to provide requested information or other assistance needed to access electronic information on a thing held by the immigration authorities in the circumstances specified in s.8(3)(da). These amendments remain in force. The further credibility amendments in s.19 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022, including provisions concerning late evidence, have not been brought into force.
Under s.9 the Secretary of State could certify that a failed asylum-seeker with a dependent child, who continued to qualify for asylum support on that basis, had failed without reasonable excuse to take reasonable steps to leave the UK voluntarily or to put themselves in a position to do so. The resulting exclusion from specified support applied after 14 days beginning with receipt of the certificate, subject to the safeguards in Schedule 3 to the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, including support necessary to avoid a breach of Convention rights. There was a right of appeal against the resulting asylum-support decision. Section 10 separately authorised regulations governing the provision or continuation of accommodation under s.4 of the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999, and provided appeal rights against refusal or discontinuance. Support under s.4(2) remains available to eligible destitute failed asylum-seekers who meet the conditions in the 2005 Regulations; the relevant replacement scheme enacted in Schedule 11 to the Immigration Act 2016 has not been brought into force.
Sections 19–25 established a Certificates of Approval scheme for marriages involving a person subject to immigration control. In England and Wales, s.19 required both parties to give notice together in person at a designated register office for marriages under the superintendent registrar’s certificate procedure; Anglican marriages were outside the scheme. Sections 21 and 23 made corresponding provision for Scotland and Northern Ireland. Under ss.19(3), 21(3) and 23(3), notice could be accepted only if the person subject to immigration control had entry clearance for marriage, written permission from the Secretary of State, or fell within an exempt category. Section 25 concerned applications for that permission and fees. The Certificate of Approval scheme was abolished on 9 May 2011 by the 2011 Remedial Order.
The Immigration Act 2014 introduced a separate referral and investigation scheme, operating across the UK from 2 March 2015. Proposed marriages or civil partnerships must be referred where the required exemptions are not established. A referral does not automatically lead to investigation: where the statutory conditions are met, including reasonable grounds to suspect a sham, the notice period may be extended from 28 to 70 days. The scheme is no longer defined simply by non-EEA nationality. British and Irish citizens and people with qualifying EU Settlement Scheme status are exempt; exemptions also cover appropriate immigration status or a relevant marriage or civil partnership visa, subject to the evidence requirements (Immigration Act 2014, Part 4).
Under s.26 the existing two-tier system of asylum and immigration appeals was replaced by a single Asylum and Immigration Tribunal headed by a President. Under this provision most appeals would be heard by a single judge, with Designated Immigration Judges providing mentoring. The scheme also provided for reconsideration and onward appeals on points of law. On 15 February 2010 the Asylum and Immigration Tribunal was abolished and its functions transferred to the First-tier Tribunal under the Transfer of Functions of the Asylum and Immigration Tribunal Order 2010. The current system has Immigration and Asylum Chambers in the First-tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal, with appeals to the Upper Tribunal on points of law requiring permission.
Section 39 created an offence of advertising or offering to provide immigration advice or services where providing them would be an offence under s.91 of the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999. This remains in s.92B of the 1999 Act; qualification is governed by s.84, rather than simply by possession of a legal qualification.
Schedule 3 laid down rules for removal to safe third countries without substantive consideration of the asylum claim in the UK, including presumptions about safety and restrictions on appeal rights. As enacted, Part 2 listed 26 countries: the other EU Member States, Norway and Iceland. Bulgaria and Romania were added in 2007, Switzerland in 2010, and Croatia and Liechtenstein in 2022. The list now comprises the 27 EU Member States, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. Other countries could also be certified as safe for an individual under Part 5. The Schedule distinguishes Refugee Convention protection from human rights protection; inclusion on a list is not a guarantee that every removal is lawful. Under the amended paragraph 3(1A), the presumption that removal to a Part 2 country complies with Article 3 ECHR, and that onward removal from it will not breach Convention rights, can be rebutted in the claimant’s particular circumstances.
For asylum claims made on or after 28 June 2022, subject to transitional arrangements, ss.80B–80C of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 permit an inadmissibility declaration where the claimant has a specified connection to a safe third State. Transit alone does not automatically dispose of a claim. The Home Office’s current guidance requires a reasonable prospect of removal to a safe third country within a reasonable time; if that is absent, the claim should ordinarily be admitted for substantive consideration. These inadmissibility declarations do not determine human rights claims, which require separate consideration.
The 2004 Act has been substantially amended by a series of subsequent statutes including the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006, the UK Borders Act 2007, the Immigration Act 2014, the Immigration Act 2016, the Nationality and Borders Act 2022, and the Illegal Migration Act 2023. The Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 repealed much of the Illegal Migration Act 2023, including its removal-duty provisions, on 2 December 2025. It also repealed the Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Act 2024. Those repeals did not abolish the safe-third-country provisions in ss.80B–80C of the 2002 Act or the credibility amendments made by s.62 of the 2023 Act.
Last updated: 11 November 2026