Downsview Nominees Ltd v First City Corporation Ltd [1992] UKPC 34; [1993] AC 295
Privy Council, on appeal from New Zealand, 19 November 1992. Judgment delivered by Lord Templeman.
The decision
The Privy Council held that a first debenture holder and its appointed receiver had breached equitable duties owed to a subsequent secured lender. The receiver had used his powers to obstruct that lender’s enforcement rather than to realise the security for the proper purpose of repaying the secured debt.
The Board dismissed the receiver’s appeal and allowed the lenders’ cross-appeal, restoring the damages award against both defendants. It rejected a general duty of care in negligence as the basis of liability. The relevant duties were to act in good faith and exercise security powers for their proper purpose. A separate order disqualifying the receiver from company management was not restored.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Facts: two competing securities
Glen Eden Motors Ltd, a New Zealand motor dealer, had granted a first debenture to Westpac and a second to First City Corporation Ltd. Each secured lending over company assets and authorised the appointment of a receiver and manager.
After the company traded at a loss and the second secured debt became payable, First City appointed receivers in March 1987. They provisionally considered an asset sale necessary and removed the company’s principal shareholder, Mr Pedersen, from management.
Pedersen consulted Mr Russell, who controlled Downsview Nominees Ltd. Downsview acquired Westpac’s first debenture and appointed Russell as receiver and manager under it. Because that security ranked first, Russell displaced First City’s receivers and restored Pedersen to management. He proposed to continue trading the company out of its difficulties.
First City promptly offered either to buy the first debenture for everything outstanding or to sell its own debenture. Its requests for an assignment were resisted. The business continued to lose money, while Russell retained control. Court orders eventually secured assignment of the first debenture and the return of the assets to First City’s receivers.
What the lower courts decided
Gault J found that Russell’s purpose had been to disrupt First City’s receivership and prevent enforcement of its security. The powers were being used for the defendants’ own objectives, rather than their proper purpose. The judge awarded NZ$554,566.33 against Russell and Downsview, reasoning in negligence, and imposed a five-year prohibition on Russell’s involvement in company management.
The New Zealand Court of Appeal upheld Russell’s damages liability but held Downsview not liable. It also held that the statutory jurisdiction did not permit the management prohibition. Russell appealed to the Privy Council; First City and its associated finance company cross-appealed to restore the trial orders.
Why the duties extended to the second lender
The Board rejected the argument that a debenture holder fell outside mortgage principles. For these purposes, a mortgage, charge and debenture all provided security for repayment of a debt.
A second mortgagee held an interest in the same property, subject to the first lender’s priority. Misuse of the first security could therefore harm the second lender’s entitlement to the remaining value. Equitable duties were owed both to the borrower and to subsequent secured creditors.
Russell’s description in the debenture as the company’s agent did not remove those duties. When exercising the receiver’s powers, he was dealing with the secured property to obtain repayment of the debt. He had to act in good faith for that purpose, including in his dealings affecting subsequent security holders.
Proper purpose and negligence
The Board explained that a receiver was not obliged immediately to sell every asset. Continuing the business could be legitimate. Equally, the receiver was not required to run it for the shareholders’ benefit at the secured lender’s expense.
The question was whether the security powers were being exercised in good faith to preserve and realise the lender’s security. A decision could disadvantage the company without necessarily breaching that duty. On the findings here, however, Russell had acted for an improper purpose from the outset and throughout the receivership.
The Board rejected imposing a general negligence duty to take reasonable care in dealing with all company assets. It considered that such a duty would conflict with the receiver’s position and the specific duties already imposed by equity. It nevertheless recognised the particular duty, illustrated by Cuckmere Brick Co Ltd v Mutual Finance Ltd, to take reasonable care to obtain a proper price when exercising a power of sale. The rejection of a general negligence duty did not abolish that specific obligation.
Downsview’s liability and the final orders
Downsview’s liability rested on its own failure to assign the first debenture when First City offered full payment at the end of March 1987. First City was entitled to redeem and require an assignment. Had Downsview complied, Russell’s receivership would have ended and the avoidable losses would not have occurred.
The damages compared the loss that would have occurred if First City’s original receivership had proceeded with the loss actually incurred. Changing the legal basis from negligence to breach of equitable duty did not change that calculation. The NZ$554,566.33 award against both defendants was restored.
The Board agreed, however, that the trial judge lacked jurisdiction under section 189 of the Companies Act to impose the management prohibition on Russell. Its order therefore preserved the distinction between the successful damages claim and the unsuccessful attempt to reinstate that prohibition.
Original judgment: Downsview Nominees Ltd v First City Corporation Ltd [1992] UKPC 34.