Hadley v Kemp [1999] EMLR 589
High Court, Chancery Division; Park J; 30 April 1999.
Three members of Spandau Ballet failed to establish a binding agreement requiring Gary Kemp to continue sharing publishing income. Their alternative claim to joint authorship also largely failed, although the song Glow was an exception. The court nevertheless dismissed the action, including the financial claims advanced on the basis of joint ownership.
Facts and the dispute
Tony Hadley, John Keeble and Steve Norman sued Gary Kemp and his company, Reformation Publishing Company Ltd. Hadley was the band’s vocalist, Keeble its drummer and Norman a guitarist, saxophonist and percussionist. Kemp was principally responsible for composing its songs. His brother Martin, the bass player, was not a party to the proceedings.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The band operated through Marbelow Ltd, owned by its five members and manager Steve Dagger. For several years Reformation paid approximately half its net publishing profits to Marbelow, enabling the band and its manager to share in that income. Kemp then decided to discontinue the arrangement, with the payments covering income only up to the end of 1987.
The claimants said that oral discussions in late 1980 or early 1981 had created a binding agreement to share publishing income. Kemp maintained that he had chosen to make the payments voluntarily and could stop them. Alternatively, the claimants argued that their musical contributions made them joint owners of copyrights in some or all of the songs, entitling them to payments from Reformation.
Publishing income and recording income
The judgment distinguished two sources of income. Publishing income arose from rights in the compositions: the music and lyrics. Recording income arose from exploitation of particular recorded performances. Contributing to the band’s recordings and sharing recording income did not itself establish an entitlement to publishing income.
Why the contractual claim failed
The claimants bore the burden of proving the alleged agreement. Park J was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that they had done so. That conclusion did not mean he thought they had deliberately given false evidence. He recognised the difficulty of resolving sincere but conflicting memories of conversations almost two decades earlier.
The contemporary arrangements and evidence about how the payments had been explained to others supported Kemp’s case that they were discretionary. Dagger had described them as voluntary to the band’s administrative and professional advisers well before the litigation.
The court also examined the requirements of offer, acceptance, intention to create legal relations, consideration and sufficient certainty. These were not established. There had been no bargaining or negotiation, and even the claimants’ account contained no agreement or discussion about how long payments would continue. A history of sharing income did not, on these facts, prove the continuing contractual obligation alleged.
The joint-authorship claim
The central distinction was between creating the musical work and performing or interpreting it. Joint authorship required a significant and original contribution to the work’s creation. A contribution did not have to equal another author’s in quantity or quality, but it had to be more than a slight contribution and of the relevant kind.
The court found that Kemp generally composed the songs before presenting them to the band. Rehearsing, arranging their performance and recording them did not turn the other musicians into joint authors merely because those activities required considerable skill.
The absence of a written score did not alter that analysis. A musical work could already exist before it was recorded in material form, even though fixation was necessary for copyright to subsist. The group’s recording of a composition therefore did not itself establish that the group had created it collectively.
There was, however, an important qualification. Keeble and Norman’s drum and percussion contributions to Glow were recognised as significant and original contributions to its composition, making them joint authors with Kemp. That finding was confined to this song and did not establish joint authorship of the remaining compositions.
Outcome and significance
The action was dismissed. In addition to rejecting the alleged contract and most of the authorship claims, Park J held that the financial claims advanced against Reformation would not succeed even on the assumption of joint ownership.
The case separates three questions: whether income-sharing was contractually binding, who created the musical work, and whether the particular legal basis for the money claimed was made out. Success on one question would not automatically answer the others.