Hartley v Mayoh & Co [1954] 1 QB 383
Court of Appeal; 15 January 1954.
The widow of a fire officer who was electrocuted while fighting a factory fire recovered damages in negligence. Although the officer was outside the class protected by the electrical safety regulations relied on, that did not defeat the separate common-law claim.
Facts
On 24 September 1950, a fire broke out at Mayoh & Co’s pickle factory in Salford. Divisional Officer Reginald Hartley attended with other members of the fire brigade. Before tackling the fire, the officers sought to disconnect the electricity supply.
The factory manager directed them to a switchboard. Several switches were turned off, but two small tumbler switches were left on because their function was not understood. After some officers received minor shocks, further inquiries were made. The manager checked the main switches and assured the officers that these were off and that there was no other main switch. Shortly afterwards, Hartley was fatally electrocuted.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Two faults combined to cause the death. The tumbler switches, which controlled the lighting supply, had not been turned off. In addition, electrical leads had been transposed, leaving the normally neutral wire live. Consequently, switching off the other controls did not make that wire safe. The accident would not have happened if the tumbler switches had been off or if the current had been carried through the correct wire.
The claim and appeal
Hartley’s widow sued Mayoh & Co and the North Western Electricity Board. Barry J awarded £10,000, finding both defendants negligent and also holding Mayoh & Co responsible for breach of statutory duty. Responsibility was apportioned 90% to the electricity board and 10% to Mayoh & Co.
Mayoh & Co appealed against being held responsible at all. Its argument was therefore broader than a request to adjust the percentage: it sought to place the whole responsibility on the electricity board.
Decision
The appeal was dismissed. The statutory-duty claim against the factory failed because a fire officer attending to extinguish a fire was not within the protected class of persons employed for the purposes of the relevant regulations. Being lawfully present and carrying out his own employment duties did not, by itself, bring Hartley within that class.
However, the factory remained liable in negligence. The manager’s failure to identify how the electricity supply could be safely disconnected supported the common-law claim independently of the regulations. The electricity board’s fault did not eliminate the factory’s concurrent responsibility. The apportionment of 90% to the board and 10% to Mayoh & Co therefore remained.
Legal significance
The decision distinguishes breach of statutory duty from negligence. A claimant relying on a statutory protection must fall within the class it protects; injury resulting from non-compliance is not enough by itself. But falling outside that class does not necessarily prevent recovery under an independently established common-law duty. In Hartley, rejection of the statutory basis was not rejection of the widow’s claim as a whole.
Other citations: [1954] 1 WLR 355; [1954] 1 All ER 375.