J Evans & Son (Portsmouth) Ltd v Andrea Merzario Ltd [1976] 1 WLR 1078
Court of Appeal — an express promise to carry machinery below deck prevailed over inconsistent standard conditions.
Facts
J Evans & Son imported machinery from Italy to England and used Andrea Merzario as its forwarding agent. The machinery had previously travelled in crates on trailers. When the forwarder proposed using containers instead, the importer sought an assurance about how they would be carried.
The forwarder’s representative promised that containers would not be carried on deck. The importer agreed to the change in reliance on that assurance and would not have agreed without it. Nevertheless, a container holding machinery was carried on deck and was lost.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The forwarder’s printed conditions gave it considerable freedom in arranging transport. They also restricted liability for loss outside its actual custody and control and limited compensation to £50 per ton. It relied on those conditions in resisting the importer’s claim.
Issue and decision
At first instance, the case was argued on the basis of a collateral oral warranty: a separate assurance alongside the written terms. Kerr J held that there was no binding warranty of that kind.
The Court of Appeal allowed the importer’s appeal. The assurance was an enforceable contractual promise, and the forwarder could not rely on the inconsistent exemption and limitation provisions to avoid responsibility for breaking it.
How the judges identified the contractual promise
Lord Denning MR treated the express oral assurance as binding despite the printed conditions. It had induced the importer to accept container transport, making it part of the basis on which the business continued.
Roskill LJ explained that the parties’ contract was partly oral, partly written and partly established by conduct. The court therefore had to consider their dealings as a whole to identify the bargain. It did not need to treat the assurance as an external collateral warranty simply to admit evidence of it.
Geoffrey Lane LJ similarly regarded the assurance as a new express term to be included in subsequent contracts for carrying the machinery from Italy. The obligation was to ensure that containers travelled under deck between Rotterdam and Tilbury.
Why the standard conditions did not protect the forwarder
The particular promise to carry below deck had been essential to obtaining the importer’s agreement. Allowing the forwarder to rely on the printed restrictions after breaking that promise would have deprived the promise of practical effect.
The result depended on the bargain actually made and the conflict between the express undertaking and the standard conditions. The case did not establish that any oral statement automatically overrides written terms. Here, the assurance was intended to be binding and directly addressed the risk which led the importer to object to the proposed change.