Legal Case Brief
Leaf v International Galleries [1950] 2 KB 86
Contract law – Sale of goods – Misrepresentation
Facts
The plaintiff purchased a picture from the defendants who represented that it was painted by the artist, J. Constable. Five years later, the plaintiff tried to sell the painting at an auction house and was told it had not been painted by the artist he had been told previously. He subsequently returned the painting to the defendant who retained it for inspection. The plaintiff brought an action to rescind the contract as the defendant had responded maintaining that the artist of the painting was J. Constable, despite the information that the plaintiff had been given by the auction house. The trial judge found in favour of the defendants, despite explaining that they had made an innocent misrepresentation regarding the artist of the painting, on the basis that the contract had been executed.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issue
There were two important issues for the court to provide a decision on. The first was whether the plaintiff had the right to rescind the contract, five years after agreeing on the terms with the defendant. The court also considered how rescission for innocent misrepresentation related to the buyer’s right to reject goods for breach of a contractual condition.
Held
The Court of Appeal dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal. By the time he sought rescission, he had kept the painting for five years, far longer than the reasonable time allowed in the circumstances.
Denning LJ treated the attribution to Constable as a contractual condition. Under the Sale of Goods Act 1893, the buyer’s acceptance of the painting meant that it was too late to reject it for breach of condition. He reasoned that the buyer could not be in a better position by seeking rescission for an innocent misrepresentation. A claim for damages had not been brought.
Jenkins LJ likewise regarded the five-year delay as excessive, and Lord Evershed MR agreed that rescission should be refused on these facts. The court did not unanimously decide that completion alone always barred rescission for innocent misrepresentation: the general question was left open, with any assumed right to rescind having been lost in this case.