Facts
Cavendish agreed to buy shares from Mr El Makdessi and another seller, taking its holding in a marketing group to 60%. The agreement provided for staged payments and restricted the sellers from competing with the group. After Mr El Makdessi breached those restrictions, Cavendish relied on clauses that withheld the outstanding interim and final payments and let it buy his remaining shares at a price that excluded goodwill. The High Court upheld the clauses, but the Court of Appeal held them unenforceable as penalties.,ParkingEye managed a retail car park for the landowner. Prominent signs offered up to two hours of free parking and warned of an £85 charge for overstaying. Mr Beavis stayed for almost three hours and challenged the charge. ParkingEye succeeded at trial and in the Court of Appeal.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issue
When does the rule against penalties make a contractual term unenforceable? Mr Beavis also argued that the charge was unfair under the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999.
Decision
The Supreme Court retained the penalty rule. It applies to a secondary obligation imposed for breach of a primary obligation. The question is whether the term imposes a detriment out of all proportion to the innocent party’s legitimate interest in enforcing the primary obligation. That interest can extend beyond compensation for loss.
The Court allowed Cavendish’s appeal and upheld both clauses. Lord Neuberger and Lord Sumption treated the payment clause as part of the mechanism for setting the share price, and the option as part of the parties’ bargain about the sale of the remaining shares. The value of the goodwill depended on the sellers’ continued loyalty.
The Court dismissed Mr Beavis’s appeal by a majority. The £85 charge was enforceable because it protected a legitimate interest in keeping parking spaces available and funding the scheme, and was proportionate in the circumstances. The majority also held that the charge was fair under the 1999 Regulations. Lord Toulson dissented on that issue.
Reported citations: [2015] 3 WLR 1373, [2016] CILL 3769, [2016] AC 1172, 162 Con LR 1, [2016] BLR 1, [2015] WLR(D) 439, [2016] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 55, [2016] RTR 8
Source: Full judgment