Monarch Airlines Ltd v London Luton Airport Ltd  CLC 698
Clarity of exclusion clauses, negligence
The Claimant airline had one of its planes damaged by a loose paving stone, while taxing on the runway of the airport operated by the Defendant. The parties’ relationship was governed by a contract which included an exemption clause excluding liability ‘… for any damage to aircraft resulting from an omission, neglect or default….’ by the Defendant.
The issue in this case was the meaning of this clause, and specifically on whether it could extend to negligence. In this instance it was a matter of clarity whether reference to “neglect” would also mean negligence within the specific legal meaning.
It was held that the wording of the clause was sufficiently clear to extend to negligence, and did indeed so extend. Use of what effectively amounted to synonyms of a term (in this case “neglect”, “omission” etc, does not mean that the court will be blind to the meaning of the words used. In this instance, the words used clearly amounted to the same thing as they would have if the word “negligence” was used, and the clause was treated as such. The court held that making such determinations ought to involve considerations of the full set of facts and context of the case. It was held that this was the correct approach to be adopted (instead of an automatic exclusion of liability), and that this is the correct application of the third part of the test in Canada Steamship Lines v The King  AC 192.
Cite This Work
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:
Related ServicesView all
Related ContentJurisdictions / Tags
Content relating to: "UK Law"
UK law covers the laws and legislation of England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. Essays, case summaries, problem questions and dissertations here are relevant to law students from the United Kingdom and Great Britain, as well as students wishing to learn more about the UK legal system from overseas.
A Comparative Analysis Between the Legal Rights in Marriage
The aim of this assignment is to critically evaluate and compare the financial rights of cohabitants and married couples in respect to termination ......
In The Matter of K (a child) - NI
In K (A Child) (Northern Ireland)  UKSC 29, the Supreme Court were asked to determine the scope of the term ‘rights of custody’ in relation to wrongful removal of a child from a country....